📖 Lesson B2 Grammar📐 Grammar

🔧 Grammar B2-24: Causative: consolidation

B1 taught one member of this family — have something done — and left the other four unopened. This consolidation gathers all five and sorts them by the single question that decides the shape of the sentence: is the object a thing or a person? A thing pulls a past participle to the end; a person pulls an infinitive, and then meaning decides which one — make for force, let for permission, have for an instruction to somebody whose job it is, and get for a result won by persuasion, the only member that keeps its to. A two-axis table sets the five side by side, and a second table runs the whole tense and modal range across one building project, so that the rule the tense always sits on have or get is seen rather than stated. The have and get contrast gets its own compared pair and verdict: not a grammar difference but a register and effort difference, which is why a text message says we finally got the wiring replaced and an insurance claim does not. A dedicated section then handles the passive of make, where the swallowed to comes back — was made to wait — together with the fact that let has no passive at all and hands the job to be allowed to. The context text follows a studio relocation in which the narrator arranges everything and builds nothing, with ten tappable forms. Practice runs to thirty-six multiple-choice items across five sets, a twelve-line sorter, six repairs and five trap boxes, every answer carrying its reason.

🎒 Teens (11–16) 🧑‍💼 Adults (17+) 30 min Challenging 16
FREE
Text version of this lesson

Grammar B2-24: Causative: consolidation

Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus

B2

≈ 30 min

B2-24

① The idea

Who did the work — and who arranged it?

Amaia is moving her design studio into the old print works on Kessel Street, and in four months she has not picked up a single tool. The roof was surveyed, the ground floor was rewired, a door was knocked through the back wall, a permit was chased for three weeks — and Amaia did none of it. English has a whole family of structures for exactly this situation, and choosing between them is not a matter of taste: each one names a different relationship between the speaker and the person doing the work.

At B1 you met the first member of the family — have something done . This lesson gathers the other four and sets them side by side, because in real writing they compete: did you arrange a job, instruct somebody, persuade them, force them, or simply allow them?

Amaia + had + the roof + surveyed .

the arranger the tense lives here a thing past participle

Magnus + made + us + keep the windows.

the one with power the tense lives here a person bare infinitive

have / get + a thing + past participle → we had the roof surveyed

have / make / let + a person + bare infinitive → he let us knock it through

get + a person + to + infinitive → I got the council to approve it

make us to keep · let us to paint · have the roof survey

One question decides almost everything: what stands immediately after have, get, make or let — a thing or a person ? A thing pulls a past participle to the end of the sentence. A person pulls an infinitive, and then the only remaining question is whether that infinitive carries to .

② The form

Five structures, two axes

Read the table down the first column and you are reading the family in order of pressure: arranged, instructed, persuaded, forced, permitted. Read across and you see the two mechanical facts that never change — what kind of object each verb takes, and what shape the second verb wears.

Structure Object Second verb Example What it claims

have + thing + participle a thing past participle We had the roof surveyed . I arranged it and paid. Who held the ladder is not the point.

get + thing + participle a thing past participle We got the lift repaired . The same job, told informally — and often with effort behind it.

have + person + bare verb a person bare infinitive Amaia had Sindre fit the boards. An instruction to somebody whose job it already is. No pressure.

get + person + to + verb a person to + infinitive She got the council to approve it. Persuasion. The to is the visible trace of the effort.

make + person + bare verb a person bare infinitive Magnus made us keep the windows. No choice was offered. Power, rules, obligation.

let + person + bare verb a person bare infinitive Magnus let us paint the front. Permission. He could have refused, and did not.

The bare infinitive is the first trap. After make and let the second verb loses its to completely: made us keep , let us paint . Only get keeps to in front of a person’s verb, and it keeps it for a reason — get reports a result you had to work for, and the extra word feels like the extra work.

The tense always sits on the first verb

This is a consolidation lesson, so here is the whole range at once. Whatever the tense, whatever the modal, the machinery never moves: surveyed , delivered , reset stay frozen at the end and have or get does every piece of grammatical work.

Time The studio move What carries the tense

present simple We have the alarm tested every quarter. have — a routine service

present continuous I ’m having the new sign delivered on Friday. am having — a fixed arrangement

past simple We had the floor sanded in August. had — finished time

present perfect We ’ve just had the boiler serviced. have had — two haves, both needed

past perfect By March we had already had the roof surveyed. had had — earlier than another past

will I ’ll get the plans printed before the meeting. will get — a decision made now

going to We ’re going to get the yard resurfaced. going to get — an existing plan

modal You should have that crack checked. should have — base form after a modal

after another verb We need to have the alarm reset. to have — an infinitive, unchanged

A quieter relative: need . When the thing itself is the subject and nobody is named at all, English drops the causative and uses need : The chimney needs to be looked at — or, more conversationally, The chimney needs looking at . Both mean somebody will have to be arranged; neither says who.

③ How to choose

Four questions, in this order

Do not start from the meaning you want — start from the object. The object decides the shape, and only then does the meaning decide the verb.

Did you do it yourself? If your own hands did the work, use the plain verb and stop: Farid built the shelves . The whole family exists to say the opposite, so reaching for it here would give the drill to somebody Farid never hired.

Is the object a thing or a person? A thing — the roof, the lift, the plans — takes a past participle at the end: had the roof surveyed . A person — Sindre, the council, us — takes an infinitive : had Sindre fit them .

If it is a person: forced, persuaded, instructed or allowed? Forced → make + bare verb. Persuaded, after resistance → get + to + verb. Instructed, because it is their job → have + bare verb. Allowed → let + bare verb.

Now choose the tense — and put it on the first verb. have , get , make and let take every tense and every modal; the second verb never moves again: I’m having it delivered · we had it rewired · you should have it checked .

Task

Amaia · the ground floor · rewire · finished before the move in March.

Question 1

Amaia touched nothing — an electrical firm did the work. So the plain verb is out.

Question 2

The object is the ground floor — a thing. Thing → past participle at the end: have the ground floor rewired .

Question 3

Skipped: question 3 only applies to people. Nobody was forced or persuaded; a firm was booked.

Question 4

The rewiring finished before another past event, so the past perfect rides on have : had had .

Answer

By March they had already had the ground floor rewired — two hads , and both of them are working.

Task

Amaia · the council · approve the new frontage · four phone calls and a redrawn plan.

Question 2

The object is the council — people. People take an infinitive, not a participle.

Question 3

She has no power over a planning department, so make is impossible. It took four calls, which is the definition of persuasion → get + person + to .

Question 4

Finished, last month, and told as a small victory: past simple got .

Answer

She finally got the council to approve the new frontage. Had the council approve would make a planning office sound like her staff.

Task

Magnus, the landlord · the original windows · the tenants have no say.

Question 2

The object is us — a person, so an infinitive follows.

Question 3

He owns the building and the lease says so: there was no negotiation at all → make , and after make the infinitive goes bare.

Answer

Magnus made us keep the original windows. Not made us to keep — the to only returns when the sentence turns passive, which is section ⑥.

④ Practice 1

Thing or person, bare or to

Eight items on the mechanics only. Read the object first, then decide what shape the second verb has to wear. 0 / 8

⑤ The contrast

had it repaired or got it repaired ?

These two build identical sentences and mean almost the same thing — which is exactly why the difference is worth a section. It is not grammar; it is register and it is effort.

have — neutral, and safe in writing

We had the wiring replaced.

A booked service reported without drama. This is the form a contract, a report or an email to an insurer wants: it states the arrangement and says nothing about how hard it was to organise.

get — informal, and it cost you something

We finally got the wiring replaced.

Speech, messages, conversation. Get leaves a trace of the struggle behind the result, which is why it collects words like finally , at last , in the end and after six weeks of emails .

Verdict: both are correct, so the choice is a piece of writing style rather than a rule. Ask what you want the reader to feel. If the job was routine, or the text is formal, use have . If the point of your sentence is that it took chasing, get earns its place — and I finally got the boiler fixed tells a story that I had the boiler fixed deliberately refuses to tell.

The same split runs through the person branch. I had Sindre fit the boards is a neutral instruction to somebody whose job it is. I got Sindre to fit the boards says he needed convincing — and brings the to with it. The effort is in the meaning of get whichever object follows it.

Six items on the contrast alone: routine or struggle, formal or spoken, thing or person. 0 / 6

⑥ The passive

Where the missing to comes back

You have just learned that make refuses to . Now the exception — and it is not really an exception, because the to was always there. In the active, make is so tightly bound to its verb that the to is swallowed. Break the pair apart with a passive and the word surfaces again.

Sindre made Kaia to wait . → Kaia was made to wait .

They let her leave. → She was let to leave. → She was allowed to leave .

Active

The permit office made Kaia wait three weeks.

Turn it round

Kaia becomes the subject; made becomes was made .

The detail

The bare infinitive cannot sit alone after was made : English restores the to .

Passive

Kaia was made to wait three weeks — and is still furious about it.

make has a passive

Every visitor is made to sign in.

Common in reports, rules and complaints, precisely because it hides who is imposing the rule. It is also a favourite of exam transformation tasks.

let has none

We were allowed to use the yard.

We were let use the yard and we were let to use the yard are both impossible. When let needs a passive, English swaps the verb: be allowed to .

Verdict: remember the pair as one fact — make goes passive and gains a to ; let cannot go passive at all and hands the job to be allowed to . Have somebody do behaves like let : it has no passive either, so the thing-branch takes over — I had Sindre check it becomes I had it checked .

Six items on the passive border. 0 / 6

⑦ In context

Four months on Kessel Street

Amaia writes to a friend about the move. Tap any coloured phrase to read why that form, and no other, was chosen.

We take the keys to the print works in March, and I have arranged every single thing in that building without touching a tool. In January we had the roof surveyed , because Magnus made us prove it was watertight before he would sign anything. He let us knock a door through the back wall, which I still cannot quite believe, but he would not let us touch the windows.

It took four phone calls and a redrawn plan, yet I finally got the council to approve the frontage. Last week we had the ground floor rewired , and on Friday I am having the new sign delivered . Kaia was made to wait three weeks for the permit and has not forgiven anyone. Farid, who trusts nobody, built the shelves himself . I signed the lease ; everything else, somebody else did.

Tap any coloured phrase. Green = a job done to a thing · orange = something asked of a person · blue = the speaker’s own hands.

⑧ Practice 2

The whole range at once

Harder: tenses, modals, the scramble that changes the meaning, and one sentence you have to read rather than build. 0 / 8

⑨ Sort it

My own hands — or somebody I arranged?

Twelve lines from the studio move. One question each: whose hands actually did the work? Tap a line to file it, and read the reason underneath. 0 / 12

My own hands

Somebody I arranged

Start with I sanded the floor . Whose knees were on the boards?

⑩ Fix the mistake

Six sentences to repair

Every one of these is a sentence a real B2 learner writes, and each fails on a different member of the family. Tap a line to see the repair and the reason.

⑪ Watch out

Five borders worth guarding

Four of these five are about a single word — to — appearing where it should not, or vanishing where it should stay. The fifth is the word order that quietly rewrites your sentence.

Trap 1 · make and let refuse to

Magnus made us to keep the original windows.

Magnus made us keep the original windows.

In the active, make and let take a bare infinitive and nothing else. The pull towards to is strong because almost every other verb of this shape — ask, tell, want, allow, persuade — demands it. These two do not.

Trap 2 · but the passive gives the to back

Kaia was made wait three weeks for the permit.

Kaia was made to wait three weeks for the permit.

Having just learned to delete the to , learners delete it here as well. The passive breaks the tight bond between make and its verb, and the to reappears. This is a genuine exam point, not a nicety.

Trap 3 · let has no passive at all

The apprentices were not let use the machine.

The apprentices were not allowed to use the machine.

There is no passive of let in modern English, with or without to . When the doer disappears, the verb has to change: be allowed to takes over the whole job.

Trap 4 · the thing belongs in the middle

We had rewired the ground floor by a local firm.

We had the ground floor rewired by a local firm.

Put the participle straight after had and you have not made a small error — you have written the past perfect, which claims we did the wiring ourselves at an earlier time, and the by phrase is left pointing at nobody.

Trap 5 · get keeps its to before a person

I got Sindre move the deadline.

I got Sindre to move the deadline.

Get is the one member of the family that keeps to in front of a person’s verb. Drop it and the sentence reads as have — a flat instruction — which is exactly the meaning the persuasion was supposed to avoid.

One habit covers all five. Look at the word immediately after have, get, make or let and name it aloud: thing or person . Thing → participle at the end, always. Person → infinitive, bare after make, let and have , with to after get and in every passive of make .

⑫ Quick test

Eight questions, no hints

Object first, meaning second, tense on the first verb. 0 / 8

Answer all eight to see how you did.

Teacher notes

Sequence (45 min): §1 put four sentences on the board with no explanation — I sanded it · I had it sanded · I had Sindre sand it · Magnus made me sand it — and ask only who held the sander and who had a choice, 5 min. §2 read the family table one row at a time, class supplying a second example each row, then the tense table read across, 8 min. §3 walk the three worked runs with the class calling the question numbers, 6 min. §4 alone, then pairs justify, 5 min. §5 the have/get pair read aloud twice, once as a report and once as a complaint, 5 min. §6 the passive, on the board as a transformation drill, 5 min. §7 read once, tap in pairs, 3 min. §8 alone, 4 min. §9 as a race, 2 min. §10 pairs, 3 min. §11 read aloud, 2 min. §12 silent, exit ticket, 5 min.

The board move that works: draw two columns headed THING and PERSON and put a past participle at the bottom of the first, an infinitive at the bottom of the second. Then feed the class objects — the roof, Sindre, the plans, the council, us, the boiler — and have them shout which column it lands in before anyone builds a sentence. The object-first habit is the whole lesson; the meaning questions are easy once the shape is settled.

If a learner is stuck, it is almost always made us to keep or was made wait — the same word in the two places it behaves oppositely. Do not re-explain: write the active and passive of one sentence one above the other, cover the rest of the board, and have them read the pair aloud five times. The rhythm teaches it faster than the rule does.

The deeper error is register, not shape. Strong learners produce all five structures correctly and then use get throughout a formal report, or make where the situation only involved persuasion. Drill it by giving a situation and a genre: the same event as a text message and as an insurance claim. The message gets we finally got it fixed ; the claim gets the wiring was replaced on 4 March .

Cambridge B2 First: this is prime key-word-transformation territory. Somebody repaired my laptop → I HAD my laptop repaired. They forced us to wait → we WERE made to wait. They did not permit us to enter → we WERE not allowed to enter. Reading and Use of English Part 4 returns to these three shapes year after year, and the passive of make is the one that separates the grades.

Comes from: B1-32 (have something done — the word order and the tense-on-have rule) and B1-33 (make / let + object + bare infinitive, and be allowed to). Sits beside: B2-22 (the full passive range), which explains why be made to behaves as it does. Next: B2-23 (impersonal passive) and B2-25 (modals of necessity in the past).

Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus A1–B2 · topic B2-24

Lesson Plan

  • A studio relocation in which the narrator arranges everything and builds nothing
  • The one question that runs the whole lesson: is the object a thing or a person?

Key Vocabulary

have something doneget something donehave somebody doget somebody to domake somebody dolet somebody dobe made tobe allowed tobare infinitivepast participlecausativearrangepersuadepermission

Grammar Points

  • have / get + thing + past participle — the arranger is the subject and the participle takes the last seat
  • have + person + bare infinitive for an instruction; get + person + to + infinitive for persuasion
  • make and let + person + bare infinitive — force and permission, with no to in the active
  • the tense and every modal sit on have, get, make or let; the second verb never changes
  • the passive of make restores the to: was made to wait
  • let has no passive — be allowed to takes over the job

加入我们的课程!

我们相信正确的问题带来正确的答案。无论您对英语学习之旅有疑问,还是需要特定语言技能的帮助,我们随时为您服务。

手机应用

Fleydo English School,尽在掌中

为 Fleydo 的学生和家长提供课程、作业、消息和游戏。iPhone 和 Android 均可免费使用。

App Store 下载去 Google Play 商店下载
了解应用详情
可在 App Store 或 Google Play 中打开 Fleydo English School 应用的二维码扫码下载自动打开适合您手机的应用商店。fleydo.com/app
FleyPath

您孩子的个性化路线图——3、6 或 12 个月

🚀起点
👋Hello
😊Body
🦁Animals
🔢Numbers
🏆自信的英语
游戏化英语练习

像玩游戏 —— 只不过他们是真的在学习