📰 Grammar B2-23: Impersonal passive
The B2 material for reporting a claim while refusing to name who made it — the structure journalism, science, rumour and cautious officialdom all run on. It opens by naming the job rather than the form: a newsroom knows what is alleged but cannot yet say who alleges it, and English has one frame built to put the claim on the page and delete its author. From the single rumour People say that she lives in Vienna the material builds both shapes side by side in the flagship compare and verdict: the it shape, It is said that she lives in Vienna, where the dummy subject holds the slot and the clause survives with its own subject and finite verb, and the subject-raised shape, She is said to live in Vienna, where the person moves to the front and what is left behind becomes an infinitive. Both are correct; the second is shorter, changes what the sentence is about, and is what the Cambridge B2 First transformation task rewards. The machinery then gets a formula, a six-row mapping table and two worked runs, because the tense mapping is the hard part: a claim set at the moment of the report takes the plain infinitive, is said to lie, while an earlier claim takes the perfect one, is believed to have buried, with to be living and to have been living covering the progressive cases. Section five isolates that decision as two independent clocks — the reporting verb records when the report was made, the infinitive records where the claim sits — and drills the overcorrection nobody warns about, was believed to run against is believed to have run. A nine-verb table sorts say, believe, think, know, report, expect, claim, allege and consider by how much the writer will stand behind the claim, adds rumour and understand, and notes that consider alone may drop its to be: she is considered the finest restorer. A 150-word newspaper feature on the disputed Vellheim hoard carries eight tappable choices. Practice runs to thirty explained multiple-choice items in four sets, twelve claims sorted by which infinitive they need, six reveal cards, six repairs and four traps built against the crossed shapes, the finite verb after to, the missing dummy it and the misread clock. Teacher notes give a 45-minute sequence, the two-arrow board move, the paper-strip rescue and B2 First relevance.
Text version of this lesson
Grammar B2-23: Impersonal passive
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus
B2
≈ 30 min
B2-23
① The idea
The claim survives — the claimer disappears
Some claims travel without a passport. A newsroom knows what is being alleged but cannot yet name who alleges it. A science paper reports what the field currently holds without pretending it is proved. A town repeats a story about a buried hoard that nobody has ever signed their name to. English has one structure built for exactly this job: it puts the claim on the page and quietly deletes the person who made it. That is the impersonal passive — and at B2 it is less a rule than a register.
It is said that she lives in Vienna .
the dummy subject the reporting verb, passive the claim, untouched
She is said to live in Vienna .
the person, moved to the front the reporting verb, passive the claim, now an infinitive
The rumour: People say (that) she lives in Vienna.
Shape 1 — the it shape: It is said that she lives in Vienna.
Shape 2 — the subject-raised shape: She is said to live in Vienna.
Is said that she lives in Vienna. — English will not start with a bare verb
Both shapes are correct. They report the same rumour and neither is more honest than the other. The difference is weight: the it shape keeps the claim whole and formal, the subject-raised shape is shorter, faster and puts the person under the spotlight — which is why examiners, editors and the Cambridge B2 First transformation task all reward it. Learn to build both, then choose.
② The contrast
One rumour, two shapes
Start from a claim nobody will own: People say that Osvald Brandt buried nine hundred coins under the harbour office. There is no witness, no document, no name worth printing. Delete the sayers and the sentence can go two ways — and the choice you make decides what the reader looks at.
The it shape — the claim stays whole
It is said that she lives in Vienna.
Nothing inside the claim moves. She lives in Vienna arrives exactly as it was, with its own subject and its own finite verb, and the dummy it simply holds the subject slot open in front of it. Because the clause survives untouched, this shape can carry anything — a long claim, several verbs, a date, a second clause. It is the safe shape, and the formal one: reports, minutes and legal writing live in it.
The subject-raised shape — the person comes forward
She is said to live in Vienna.
The subject of the claim is lifted out of the clause and made the subject of the reporting verb, and what is left behind turns into an infinitive. The sentence loses a that , loses a repeated subject, and gains speed. It also changes the topic: the sentence is now about her , not about a floating rumour, which is why headlines and profiles reach for it first.
Verdict: build the it shape when the claim is long, complicated or not really about one person — It is said that the two cellars were sealed at some point after the war is unbearable with a raised subject. Build the subject-raised shape when one person or thing is the topic and you want the sentence tight: Brandt is believed to have taken the secret with him . What you may never do is mix them. Choose it + that + finite verb , or subject + to + infinitive ; the moment a that meets a to , or an infinitive follows It is said , the sentence collapses.
③ The machinery
Two moves, and one decision about time
Building the it shape is almost free: write It , put the reporting verb in the passive, write that , copy the claim. Building the raised shape costs one real decision, and it is the decision this whole material turns on — which infinitive . Everything else is copying.
It + is / was + said · believed · thought · reported + that + full clause
subject + is / was + said · believed · thought · reported + to + infinitive
claim at the same time as the report → to live · to be living
claim earlier than the report → to have lived · to have been living
The rumour The it shape The raised shape
People say she lives in Vienna. It is said that she lives in Vienna. She is said to live in Vienna.
People say she is living in Vienna. It is said that she is living in Vienna. She is said to be living in Vienna.
People say she lived in Vienna. It is said that she lived in Vienna. She is said to have lived in Vienna.
People say she has lived there for years. It is said that she has lived there for years. She is said to have lived there for years.
People say she was living there in 1998. It is said that she was living there in 1998. She is said to have been living there in 1998.
People expect she will return . It is expected that she will return . She is expected to return .
Read the third and fourth rows together. A past simple and a present perfect inside the claim come out as the same perfect infinitive — to have lived — because an infinitive has no tense of its own and can only say earlier , not how much earlier . That is the one thing the raised shape cannot keep. When the difference matters, keep the it shape, where the clause holds its own tense.
Claim
People in Vellheim say that the hoard lies under the old harbour office. Present tense: this is a claim about the town as it stands today.
Delete the sayers
The people are the part nobody can stand behind, so the reporting verb goes passive and they vanish: is said .
Shape 1
It is said that the hoard lies under the old harbour office. The clause is untouched — the hoard lies , subject and finite verb, exactly as before.
Shape 2
Lift the hoard to the front and turn lies into an infinitive: The hoard is said to lie under the old harbour office.
Which infinitive
Plain. The lying and the saying are true at the same moment, so to lie is enough. To have lain would mean the hoard was down there once and is not any more.
Claim
Historians believe that Brandt buried the coins in 1903. Past tense: the burying was over more than a century before anyone believed anything about it.
Shape 1
It is believed that Brandt buried the coins in 1903. The date and the past tense sit inside the clause and nothing has to change.
Shape 2
Raise Brandt , and the past has to be rebuilt on an infinitive, which cannot carry tense on its own: Brandt is believed to have buried the coins in 1903.
The slip
Brandt is believed to bury the coins in 1903. A plain infinitive says the burying and the believing happen together — a sentence in which historians are watching a man dig in 1903.
What decided it
Distance in time, not the tense of the reporting verb. Is believed stayed present because the belief is held now; only the claim moved back, and only the claim needs have .
④ Practice 1
The two shapes, eight items
Form first. Each item gives you the rumour and asks for one piece of the machinery: the dummy subject, the passive reporting verb, the that , or the infinitive. Say the whole sentence out loud before you choose. 0 / 8
⑤ The hard part
Plain or perfect — the claim decides
This is where the structure is actually won or lost. The reporting verb tells you when the report was made; the infinitive tells you when the claim is set. They are two separate clocks, and learners who read only one of them produce sentences that quietly say the wrong thing.
Find the verb inside the claim. Not the reporting verb — the one belonging to the person or thing you are about to raise. In People think the council is stalling , that verb is is stalling , not think .
Ask whether it is happening at the same time as the report, or before it. Same time means the claim and the reporting live in one moment; before means the claim points back past the moment the report was made.
Same time → to + base form , and to be + -ing if the claim was in progress: is said to live , is thought to be stalling .
Earlier → to have + past participle , and to have been + -ing if the earlier action was in progress: is believed to have buried , is thought to have been digging .
Leave the reporting verb where the report happened. A belief held today is is believed even when the claim is a century old; a report printed in 1908 is was reported even when the claim is about now.
The two clocks, side by side. Brandt is believed to have died in Lisbon — the belief is current, the death is old. The tunnel was believed to run to the pier — the belief is old, and the running was true at the same old moment, so the infinitive stays plain. Reading was believed and reaching automatically for to have run is the commonest overcorrection at this level; it pushes the tunnel back before the belief, which is not what anybody meant.
Six items on the infinitive alone. For each one, find the claim’s own verb and place it against the moment of the report. 0 / 6
⑥ The reporting verbs
Nine ways to not name your source
The frame is the same for all of them; what changes is how much the writer is prepared to stand behind the claim. Reading down this table is reading a scale of commitment, from a shrug to a courtroom.
Verb What it signals Example
say The default. Widest of all, and the least committed — it reports that the words are in circulation, nothing more. The hoard is said to lie under the quay.
believe A conviction that is widely held but not documented. Warmer than say , colder than know . Brandt is believed to have died in Lisbon.
think The softest. A general impression, easily dropped if the evidence turns. The council is thought to be stalling.
know The claim is treated as established fact; the writer is no longer hedging, only declining to cite. It is known that the office had two cellars.
report The source is a press or official channel. Usually past, because a report is an event with a date. It was reported in 1908 that two crates left at night.
expect Points forward. Takes a plain infinitive even though the meaning is future. The survey is expected to take four months.
claim Someone asserts it in their own interest, and the writer is not endorsing it. It is claimed that the map still exists.
allege A serious, unproved accusation. Legal armour: the charge is reported, never adopted. Vasse is alleged to have dug beneath the wall.
consider A judgement rather than news — an evaluation the writer attributes to everyone. The hoard is considered a legend.
The one verb that lets you drop to be . After consider , the infinitive may simply vanish in front of a noun or an adjective: She is considered (to be) the finest restorer in the region — both versions are good English, and the shorter one is commoner in print. After think , believe and say the to be stays: He is thought to be the owner , never He is thought the owner . Two more worth collecting: rumour , which exists almost only in this frame — She is rumoured to have resigned — and understand , the journalist’s quiet signal that the story is sourced but unconfirmed: The council is understood to be reluctant .
Keep the report in its own tense. The passive reporting verb records when the reporting happened, so it does not follow the claim backwards. It was reported in 1908 that… because the newspaper printed it in 1908; The hoard is now considered a legend because that judgement is being made today. Writing It is reported in 1908 hands a living newsroom a date it cannot have.
⑦ Practice 2
Real reporting, eight items
Harder, and the verb now matters as much as the shape: an accusation, a judgement, a leak and a forecast all want different reporting verbs for the same frame. 0 / 8
⑧ In context
The Vellheim hoard, and nobody’s name on it
A hundred and fifty words from a regional newspaper’s anniversary feature. Count how many claims it makes and how many sources it names — that gap is the whole reason this structure exists. Tap any coloured phrase to read why it was built that way.
For a hundred and twenty years the Vellheim hoard has refused to be found. It is said that a customs officer named Osvald Brandt buried nine hundred silver coins under the old harbour office in 1903 . Brandt is believed to have taken the secret with him : he died in Lisbon two years later, and no map has ever surfaced.
It was reported at the time that the coins had been counted twice before they vanished, which is why the figure is so oddly precise. Modern surveys are thought to have ruled out the cellar. The hoard is now widely considered a legend , though the council is understood to be reluctant to say so publicly. Tourism is said to bring in more than the coins ever would. Corentin Vasse is alleged to have dug beneath the east wall without permission. He denies it.
Tap any coloured phrase above. Blue = the it shape · green = the subject-raised shape · orange = the reporting verb doing register work.
⑨ Sort and commit
Now, or earlier?
Twelve claims from the Vellheim file. Read each one, imagine it raised into X is said… , and decide which infinitive that sentence would need: the plain one for a claim set at the moment of the report, the perfect one for a claim set before it. 0 / 12
set at the moment of the report — plain infinitive
set before the report — perfect infinitive
Start with the hoard lies under the quay . Is that claim about the same moment as the reporting, or about a time before it?
Now commit before you check. Each card gives you a situation; say the full sentence aloud — both shapes if you can — and then tap to reveal.
⑩ Fix the mistake
Six sentences to repair
Every one of these comes from a learner who has understood what the structure is for and has crossed its two shapes while building it. Tap each sentence for the correction and the reason.
⑪ Watch out
The four ways this collapses
Three of these are the two shapes bleeding into each other, and the fourth is a clock read wrongly. None of them stops a reader understanding you — which is precisely why they survive into C1 unless somebody points at them.
Trap 1 · the two shapes crossed
It is said she to live in Vienna.
It is said that she lives in Vienna.
You have started the it shape and finished the raised one. Once It is said is on the page, what follows is a whole clause with its own subject and its own finite verb: that she lives . The infinitive belongs to the other sentence entirely — She is said to live in Vienna — and the two can never share a line.
Trap 2 · a finite verb after is said to
The tunnel is believed to runs under the pier.
The tunnel is believed to run under the pier.
An infinitive has no person and no tense — that is what makes it an infinitive. The tense of the sentence is already carried by is believed , so anything after to is a bare base form, or have plus a participle. The same slip produces is said to buried and is thought to was digging : both are finite verbs stranded where only an infinitive can stand.
Trap 3 · the missing dummy it
Is said that the hoard lies under the quay.
It is said that the hoard lies under the quay.
The reporting verb has lost its human subject, and English refuses to leave the slot empty: something must sit in front of the verb, so it is drafted in to hold the place. It means nothing at all — it is scaffolding, not a pronoun pointing at the hoard. The same rule blocks There is said that… , which would be announcing that a rumour exists rather than reporting what it says.
Trap 4 · the wrong clock
Brandt is said to bury the coins in 1903.
Brandt is said to have buried the coins in 1903.
The infinitive is the only place left to record that the claim points backwards, and a plain one says at the same time as the report — so this sentence has people watching a man dig in 1903 and saying so as it happens. Whenever a finished date, a past tense or a present perfect sits inside the claim, the raised version needs to have + participle. The overcorrection is worth naming too: was believed does not force a perfect infinitive — The tunnel was believed to run to the pier is right, because the running was true at the same past moment as the belief.
⑫ Quick test
Eight questions, no hints
Before each answer, run the two checks from section ⑤: which shape am I in, and where is the claim sitting relative to the report? 0 / 8
Answer all eight to see how you did.
Teacher notes
Sequence (45 min): §1 read the two pattern strips aloud and write both shapes of one rumour on the board, 4 min. §2 the compare, with the class deciding which shape a headline would use and which a court report would use, 6 min. §3 the machinery table with the third and fourth rows covered, so learners predict the raised column, then the two worked runs, 8 min. §4 alone, then reasons compared in pairs, 4 min. §5 the flagship: the two clocks drawn on the board, the five decision steps read once, then the six items, 8 min. §6 the verb table as a commitment scale — ask which verb a lawyer, a gossip and a scientist would each choose, 5 min. §7 alone, 4 min. §8 the Vellheim feature read once for the story, then tapped in pairs, 3 min. §9 sorter as a race, cards as a closer, 2 min. §10 and §11 in pairs, 1 min. §12 silent exit ticket.
The board move that works: draw two horizontal arrows, one above the other, and label the top one REPORT and the bottom one CLAIM. Put a cross on the top arrow where the reporting verb sits — present for is said , past for was reported — and then ask a learner to put a cross on the bottom arrow for the claim. If the two crosses line up vertically, the infinitive is plain. If the claim’s cross is to the left, it needs to have . Nothing else makes the independence of the two clocks visible so quickly, and the picture kills the overcorrection after was believed in one stroke.
If a learner is stuck, it is almost never the meaning — it is the crossing of the two shapes. Give them a strip of paper with It is said on the left and that + subject + finite verb on the right, and a second strip with subject on the left and is said to + infinitive on the right. Physically holding two strips makes the point that a sentence lives on one strip or the other. Then dictate five rumours and have them build each one twice, once per strip.
The second leak is the infinitive after a past reporting verb. Learners who have finally understood is believed to have buried start writing was believed to have run for a tunnel that ran at the time of the belief. Drill the pair back to back — was believed to run against is believed to have run — until the class can say which one puts the tunnel further back.
Cambridge B2 First: this sits squarely on Reading and Use of English Part 4, where People say that he… ↔ He is said to… is one of the most reliably recurring transformations, and where the perfect infinitive is the discriminator between a four-mark answer and a two-mark one. Part 2 open cloze loves the bare It and to slots; Writing Part 2 reports and reviews reward is widely considered and is thought to be as hedges; Listening Part 4 interviews are full of is understood to and is alleged to .
Comes from: B1-24 (the simple passive and the by -phrase), B1-19 and B1-20 (reported speech), B2-22 (the passive across all tenses, with modal and infinitive passives). Next: B2-24 (the causative have something done ), B2-26 (participle clauses) and B2-29 (cleft sentences), which is the other structure in this band that rearranges a sentence purely to move the reader’s attention.
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus A1–B2 · topic B2-23
Lesson Plan
- Why a language needs a frame for a claim nobody will sign
- Two pattern strips: the dummy subject shape and the raised subject shape
- A formula that sets both against the original rumour, with the subjectless version struck out
Key Vocabulary
Grammar Points
- two shapes from one claim: It + is said + that + full clause, or subject + is said + to + infinitive — and never a mixture of the two
- the dummy it is compulsory in the first shape, because the reporting verb has lost its human subject and English will not leave the slot empty
- a claim set at the moment of the report takes the plain infinitive (is said to live, is thought to be stalling)
- a claim set earlier takes the perfect infinitive (is believed to have buried, is thought to have been digging); past simple and present perfect both flatten into it
- the passive reporting verb keeps the tense of the report, not of the claim: It was reported in 1908 that…, and was believed to run rather than to have run
- reporting verbs form a commitment scale — say, think, believe, know, report, expect, claim, allege, consider — and after consider the to be may be dropped
