📖 Lesson B2 Grammar📐 Grammar

🕵️ Grammar B2-7: Modals of deduction and speculation

At B1 you learned to deliver verdicts about the present — must for one surviving answer, might / may / could for several, can’t for an answer the evidence rules out. This material bolts a second axis onto that scale: time. One grid of six cells holds the whole system — must be and must have gone, might be waiting and might have been waiting, can’t be and can’t have driven — and the two questions that fill it are always the same: what does the evidence allow, and is the mystery now or already finished? Along the way the material exiles mustn’t have from the certainty scale where learners keep planting it, separates the strong no (couldn’t have) from the weak no (might not have), and insists that a verdict without a piece of evidence behind it is a bluff a reader can hear. Thirty-two multiple-choice items, a ten-chip now-or-then sort, six corrections and six reveal cards drill the movement around the grid, and a mini-mystery in a Monday-morning office lets the reader deduce alongside the narrator.

🎒 Teens (11–16) 🧑‍💼 Adults (17+) 30 min Challenging 16
FREE
Text version of this lesson

Grammar B2-7: Modals of deduction and speculation

Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus

B2

≈ 30 min

B2-7

① The idea

Someone must be in there now. Someone must have been there at three. It can’t have been Anselm.

You already deliver verdicts about the present: must when the evidence leaves one answer, might / may / could when several survive, can’t when the evidence shuts a door. This material bolts a second axis onto that scale — time . The certainty word never changes when the mystery moves into the past; only the part behind it does. They must be out becomes they must have gone out , and the whole detective apparatus swings round to face a finished moment.

They + must + be out

who the verdict — one answer fits the mystery is NOW: bare be

They + must + have gone out

who the same verdict, untouched the mystery is THEN: have + past participle

the mystery is NOW → must / might / can’t + be → The office is dark — they must be out.

the mystery is THEN → must / might / can’t + have + past participle → The lights are off — they must have gone to bed.

an action stretching through the mystery → be doing · have been doing → she must be waiting · she must have been waiting

Two questions build every sentence in this material. What does the evidence allow — only one answer, several, or not this one? And when is the mystery — now, or already finished? Answer both and the form assembles itself. One warning up front: mustn’t have is not the negative of must have . The negative is can’t have . mustn’t stays in the rulebook, where it gives orders.

② The form

One grid, six cells: certainty across, time down

This is the whole system on one page. Read across a row and the certainty stays fixed while the time changes; read down a column and the time stays fixed while the certainty changes. Nothing else in the sentence moves — the modal never takes -s , never takes to , and have is frozen for every person.

How certain? The mystery is NOW The mystery is THEN

must the evidence leaves one answer standing

must + be The office is dark — they must be out. must + be + -ing That noise — she must be moving the filing cabinets.

must + have + past participle The lights are off — they must have gone to bed. must + have been + -ing The chair is still warm — he must have been sitting here.

might · may · could several answers are still alive

might / may / could + be She could be on the roof terrace. might + be + -ing He may be finishing the layout.

might / may / could + have + past participle She may have taken the earlier train. might + have been + -ing She might have been sleeping when you called.

can’t · couldn’t the evidence rules this one out

can’t + be That can’t be her handwriting. can’t + be + -ing He can’t be waiting outside — it’s locked.

can’t / couldn’t + have + past participle The car’s still here — they can’t have driven . can’t + have been + -ing She can’t have been listening ; she asked twice.

The right-hand column is the only new machinery: have plus the third form of the verb. It is the same engine as the modal perfects, pointed at a different job — not regret, not a missed chance, but a conclusion about what happened.

Job Shape Example

the weak no — perhaps not might / may + not have + participle She might not have seen your message.

the strong no — impossible can’t / couldn’t have + participle He couldn’t have known — nobody had told him.

asking instead of answering Could … have + participle Could she have taken the earlier train?

short answer — the frame, then stop modal + have “Did he read it?” “He must have .” / “He can’t have .”

the shape that does not exist mustn’t have + participle Never a verdict — the negative of must have is can’t have .

Three slips the frame invites: She must has left. They must have wrote it. I must of missed it. After a modal, have is frozen — no -s , ever. Only the third form walks through the door have opens — written , not wrote . And the whisper you hear in must’ve is have , never of : of is not a verb and cannot carry a sentence into the past.

③ How to choose

Two questions, then assemble

Never start from the modal. Start from the fact you can point at, run the two questions, and the six cells sort themselves out.

Point at the evidence. Name the fact out loud: the warm chair, the timestamp, the boarding pass, the empty rack. A deduction with nothing behind it is not a deduction — it is a guess in a smart coat, and readers hear the difference immediately.

Question 1 — what does the evidence allow? Only one answer, and nothing competes → must . Several answers still standing → might , may or could , three words of identical strength. This particular answer is out → can’t or couldn’t . If the evidence merely makes it doubtful rather than impossible, you want the weak no: might not .

Question 2 — is the mystery now or then? Look at the tense of the clue itself. The chair is warm, I can hear it, the light is on → the mystery is NOW. When I got back, at 23:06, last night, the queue says → the mystery is THEN. The evidence and the verdict must sit in the same time.

Assemble. NOW takes be ; THEN takes have + past participle. Last check: was the thing you are guessing about a state, or an activity stretching through the moment? A stretch takes the continuous cell — be doing for now, have been doing for then.

Situation

You reach the shared kitchen at 07:20. The kettle is warm, one mug is upside down on the drainer, and the door panel logs an entry at 06:44.

Evidence

Warm kettle, washed mug, a code entered at 06:44. Three traces, and all of them point at a visit that is finished.

Question 1

How many stories survive? The code entry names a real arrival and nothing competes with it. One answer.

Question 2

Now or then? Nobody is in the kitchen. The arrival is over — 06:44 is a closed moment.

Assemble

One answer + THEN → must have come : somebody must have come in before seven.

Situation

A colleague insists Rosalind ran the print job at eleven last night.

Evidence

Rosalind’s boarding pass: her flight landed at 06:15 this morning. At eleven she was somewhere over the Atlantic.

Question 1

The evidence does not merely fail to help the idea — it kills it. This answer is out.

Question 2

The print job happened at 23:06. Finished time, so the denial has to travel there too.

Assemble

Ruled out + THEN → can’t have printed (or couldn’t have printed ). Not mustn’t have printed — that shape is not a verdict in any time.

Situation

You ring Vesna at eight in the morning. She answers slowly, sounds confused, and admits she has no idea what time it is.

Evidence

A slow answer and a lost sense of time — but also forty-one messages she sent between midnight and three.

Question 1

Two stories are alive at once: a night of work, or simply being asleep when the phone rang. Several answers survive, so the verdict stays in the middle band.

Question 2

Both stories sit in the past — but each was an activity running through the moment, not a single point. That is the continuous cell.

Assemble

Several answers + THEN + a stretch → might have been working all night, or she might have been sleeping when you called. And about right now, the evidence has hardened: she must be barely awake .

Six scenes: call it before you tap

Each card gives you a fact and half a sentence. Finish it aloud — certainty word first, then the time — and only then open the card.

④ Practice 1

Building the past frame

Eight items on the machinery. Find the clue first, decide whether it sits in now or in finished time, then check that have and the participle are doing their jobs. 0 / 8

⑤ The contrast

Two pairs that decide most B2 marks

The past half of the grid has two fault lines. The first runs between the two ends of the scale — and the word that looks like the negative of must have is not on the scale at all. The second runs through the middle of the negative: impossible against possibly not .

must have — the evidence says yes

The porch light is off and the car’s gone. They must have left before the storm.

Every trace points one way and nothing competes. must have claims the evidence has narrowed the past down to a single story — it is the strongest thing you can say without having watched it happen.

can’t have — the evidence says no

The car’s still here. They can’t have driven anywhere.

One new fact and the story is dead. can’t have is equally certain, pointed the other way — a confident no about a finished moment. couldn’t have says exactly the same thing with a slightly more formal tread.

Verdict: must have and can’t have are one machine running in opposite directions. So the negative of they must have left is they can’t have left — never they mustn’t have left . mustn’t is exiled to the rulebook, where it forbids behaviour: Visitors mustn’t take photographs . A rule cannot weigh a piece of evidence, and it certainly cannot judge last night.

couldn’t have — impossible

Anselm handed his key back in June. He couldn’t have got into the archive.

The evidence does not leave a crack. couldn’t have (and can’t have ) close the question: there is no version of the night in which this happened.

might not have — possibly not

The email went to his old address. He might not have got it.

Here the door is only half shut. might not have and may not have report a real possibility that something did not happen — honest hedging, not certainty. Note where the not sits: after the modal, never contracted onto it.

Verdict: ask yourself what the evidence has actually done. Has it made the thing impossible ? Then couldn’t have / can’t have . Has it only made it doubtful ? Then might not have / may not have . Overclaiming is the commonest B2 style fault in this area: writing can’t have when all you have is a suspicion tells your reader you cannot tell a fact from a hunch.

Eight items on those two fault lines and nothing else. Every stem carries its clue — read it before you choose. 0 / 8

⑥ In context

Monday, 08:12, Halden Street

Oriane gets to the Halden Street office first and writes down what she can work out. Read her account and deduce along with her — then tap any coloured verdict to see which fact it rests on, and which time it is pointed at.

The espresso machine is still warm, so someone must have been in before me. One desk lamp is burning. The print queue says forty-two pages went through at 23:06, so whoever it was must have been working on the anniversary issue half the night.

Rosalind’s flight landed at 06:15 this morning, so she can’t have printed anything at eleven. Anselm handed his key back in June, so he couldn’t have got in at all. That leaves Vesna, and the archive box marked 1998 is open on the floor beside her desk.

She might have been hunting for the flood photographs, or she may have come in early simply because the deadline is Thursday. Her coat is over the chair and the lamp is still on, so she must be somewhere in the building. She can’t have gone far.

Every colour marks a strength: blue for must, green for might / may / could, orange for can’t and couldn’t. Tap one to see its evidence and its time.

⑦ Practice 2

Now or then, state or stretch

Harder now. Half of these turn on the time of the clue rather than the strength of the evidence, and three of them need a continuous cell. Run both questions from §3 before you commit. 0 / 8

⑧ Sort it

Is the mystery now, or then?

Ten verdicts, arranged in minimal pairs — the certainty is identical inside each pair, and only the time changes. Read the shape after the modal and drop each one into its column. 0 / 10

the mystery is NOW

the mystery is THEN

Start anywhere: look at what follows the modal. Bare be means now; have plus a participle means then.

⑨ Fix the mistake

Six sentences from real B2 writing

Each line has one thing wrong with it, and all six faults live inside the grid. Tap a line to see the repair and the reasoning behind it.

⑩ Watch out

Four traps in the past half of the grid

Each box shows the sentence that feels right first — and the one that is.

Trap 1 · mustn’t have is not a verdict

She mustn’t have got my message — she never replied.

She can’t have got my message — she never replied.

mustn’t makes rules about behaviour: Visitors mustn’t take photographs. A rule cannot weigh evidence, and it cannot reach back into last night. The negative of must have is can’t have — or, if you only mean possibly not , might not have . Whenever you catch yourself writing mustn’t have , one of those two is the sentence you wanted.

Trap 2 · a verdict without evidence is a bluff

I have no idea where he is. He must have missed the train.

I have no idea where he is. He may have missed the train.

must have is a claim about your evidence: it says the facts leave one story standing. Used with nothing behind it, it does not sound confident — it sounds careless, and an examiner or an editor hears the gap at once. With nothing to point at, drop into the middle band: may , might or could have . Hedge honestly and the one time you do write must have , it lands.

Trap 3 · the clue’s time sets the modal’s time

There were muddy prints in the hall when I got back, so someone must be in the garden.

There were muddy prints in the hall when I got back, so someone must have been in the garden.

The clue is anchored in finished time by when I got back , so the verdict has to travel there with it. must be would vouch for the garden at this second, which dried mud cannot do. Match the two: present clue, present cell; past clue, have plus the participle.

Trap 4 · the continuous keeps its been

She must have working in here since six.

She must have been working in here since six.

The two continuous cells are be + -ing for now and have been + -ing for then, and been is the hinge that joins them. Drop it and the -ing form has nothing to hang on. The same hinge runs through the reactions English has frozen into these cells: you must be joking about this moment, he must have been joking about a remark already made.

⑪ Quick test

Eight verdicts, no help

No hints. Point at the evidence, ask what it allows, ask when the mystery is, then commit. 0 / 8

Answer all eight to see where you stand.

Teacher notes

Sequence (45 min): §1 open by saying both hero sentences yourself and make the point physically — say they must be out , then they must have gone out , and let the class hear that only the tail moved, 4 min. §2 the grid: cover the right-hand column, elicit the present cells they already own, then uncover it one cell at a time, 7 min. §3 walk the two questions and the three worked runs, with learners calling now or then before you reveal the answer; six cards in pairs, verdict spoken before the tap, 8 min. §4 alone, 5 min. §5 the heart of the lesson — the two compare pairs on the board before the items, 7 min. §6 read aloud once as a whole-class mystery, guess the culprit, then tap, 4 min. §7 alone, then pairs compare reasons, 4 min. §8 as a race, 2 min. §9 pairs, 2 min. §10 read aloud, 2 min. §11 silent, as the exit ticket.

The board move that works: draw the grid empty — three rows (must / might–may–could / can’t) and two columns (NOW / THEN). Fill the left column with the class in ninety seconds; they know it from B1-25. Then write have + past participle once, at the top of the right column, and let them fill the three cells themselves. The lesson is that six cells cost one new piece of machinery. Finally write mustn’t have on the board, invite someone to place it in a cell, and physically move it off the grid into a box labelled RULES. Every later error can then be corrected by pointing at that box in silence.

If a learner is stuck, it is almost always the time axis rather than the certainty axis. The rescue question is “What tense is your clue in?” — make them underline the clue and read it back. The chair is warm keeps you in the present cells; the chair was warm when I came in pushes you into the past ones. For the second common wall, over-strong negatives, ask “Impossible, or just unlikely?” Impossible earns can’t have ; unlikely earns might not have . If been keeps vanishing, drill must-have-been-doing as a single four-beat chunk.

Cambridge B2 First: this is high-value grammar. Reading and Use of English Part 4 (key word transformations) routinely tests I’m sure she didn’t see it → she can’t have seen it , and Part 2 bait-answers exploit mustn’t have . In Speaking Part 2 (comparing photographs), candidates who speculate with they might have been waiting a long time reach the higher range bands, while candidates who describe flatly do not. In Writing, one well-placed may have is worth a paragraph of hedging adverbs.

Comes from: B1-25 (must / might / can’t about the present — the left-hand column of today’s grid) and B1-26 (modal perfects, where have + participle first appears, in the service of regret rather than deduction). Next: B2-25 (needn’t have vs didn’t need to — the other modal that reaches back into a finished afternoon) and B2-22 (modal passives, where today’s frame swallows a passive: it must have been taken from the archive ). B2-23 ( it is said that… ) then turns the same instinct for hedging into a register tool.

Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus A1–B2 · topic B2-7

Lesson Plan

  • The certainty scale you already own, plus a second axis: time.
  • must be → must have gone: only the tail of the sentence moves.
  • The two questions that build every sentence in the material.
  • First warning: the negative of must have is can’t have, not mustn’t have.

Key Vocabulary

deductionspeculationevidenceverdictcertaintymust havemight havemay havecould havecan’t havecouldn’t havemight not havehave been + -ingpast participle

Grammar Points

  • Present deduction: must / might / may / could / can’t + be (+ -ing).
  • Past deduction: must / might / may / could / can’t + have + past participle.
  • Past continuous deduction: modal + have been + -ing for an activity running through a past moment.
  • The negative pair: can’t have / couldn’t have for impossible, might not have / may not have for possibly not — and never mustn’t have.
  • The frozen frame: no -s on have, only the third form after it, and never of in place of have.
  • Matching the verdict’s time to the clue’s time; questions (Could she have…?) and short answers (He must have.).

Rejoignez nos classes!

Nous croyons que les bonnes questions apportent les bonnes réponses. Nous sommes toujours là pour vous.

Application mobile

Fleydo English School dans votre poche

Cours, devoirs, messages et jeux pour les élèves de Fleydo et leurs parents. Gratuite sur iPhone et Android.

Télécharger dans l'App StoreDisponible sur Google Play
En savoir plus sur l'application
Code QR qui ouvre l'application Fleydo English School dans l'App Store ou sur Google PlayScannez pour téléchargerOuvre la boutique adaptée à votre téléphone.fleydo.com/app
Le FleyPath

La feuille de route personnelle de votre enfant — 3, 6 ou 12 mois

🚀Départ
👋Hello
😊Body
🦁Animals
🔢Numbers
🏆Anglais confiant
Entraînement d'anglais gamifié

Comme un jeu — sauf qu'ils apprennent vraiment