🔦 Grammar B2-29: Emphasis: cleft sentences
Speech can lean on a word; a page cannot. Cleft sentences are how a writer puts one element in the spotlight, and this lesson teaches both families from the reader's side rather than the grammar's. Family one, the wh-cleft: what we published was a set of dates; what she did was rewrite it; all we ask for is an answer; the reason we left was that the hall was cold — with the pivot verb agreeing with whatever follows it. Family two, the it-cleft: it was Solenne who sent the email; it was on Monday that she sent it; it wasn't until Tuesday that anyone replied — it plus be plus the spotlight plus the compulsory joint who or that. The heart of the material is a single neutral sentence re-clefted three ways to answer three different unspoken objections, followed by the harder half of the skill: recognising the paragraphs where nothing is in dispute and the plain sentence wins. Thirty-one multiple-choice items, a twelve-chip family sorter, six corrections and a tappable editorial rebuttal in which every cleft answers a named accusation.
Text version of this lesson
Grammar B2-29: Emphasis: cleft sentences
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus
B2
≈ 30 min
B2-29
① The idea
Writing cannot raise its voice — so it rebuilds the sentence
Say Solenne sent the email aloud and you can put the spotlight anywhere you like: lean on Solenne and you are correcting somebody who blamed Barnaby; lean on email and you are correcting somebody who expected a letter. On a page that stress does not exist. A reader sees flat, even words and takes the sentence as one undivided piece of news. So written English does the pointing structurally: it splits the sentence in two — cleaves it, which is where the name comes from — and parks one element in the spotlight. That is a cleft sentence , and this lesson is about the two families that do the job.
What we published + was + a set of dates .
the wh-clause: what is already agreed is / was the spotlight
It was + the traffic office + that supplied them .
it + be the spotlight who / that + the rest
Family 1 · wh-clefts
What + the part already agreed + is / was + the spotlight
What I need is a week off. · What she did was rewrite the whole thing.
All I want is a straight answer. · The thing that worried us was the price.
The reason we left was that the hall was freezing.
What I need are a week off. → What I need is a week off.
Family 2 · it-clefts
It + is / was + the spotlight + who / that + the rest
It was Solenne who sent the email. · It was on Monday that she sent it.
It wasn’t until Friday that we heard. · It is only now that the figures make sense.
who for people · that for absolutely everything, people included
It was Solenne sent the email. → It was Solenne who sent it.
A cleft is an answer to a question nobody asked out loud. Every one of these sentences carries the same facts as its plain version — nothing is added, nothing removed. What changes is the shape, and the shape tells the reader: you are assuming something, and this is the word that fixes it . That is why clefts cluster in corrections, complaints, rebuttals and arguments, and why they feel odd in the first line of a story, where the reader has not assumed anything yet.
② The form
Two machines, one job
Take one neutral sentence — Solenne sent the email on Monday — and watch both families take it apart. Nothing in the table below is new information; every row is the same event, re-packaged so a different word carries the weight.
The machinery wh-cleft — what / all / the reason it-cleft — it + be + spotlight
Statement What Solenne sent was an email. It was Solenne who sent the email.
Negative What she sent wasn’t a letter. It wasn’t Barnaby who sent it.
Question What is it you actually want us to print? Was it Solenne who sent it?
Spotlight on… a thing, or the whole action: What she did was resend it. one element: a person, a day, a place, a cause.
The pivot verb agrees with what follows it: was an email · were two emails. stays singular: it was the interns who spotted it.
Tense copies the original: what she sent was… · what she needs is… copies the original: it was … · it is …
The joint none needed — the wh-clause and be do all the work. compulsory: who for people, that for everything.
Reversible? yes: An email is what she sent . no — an it-cleft only runs one way.
The wh-cleft is not limited to what . Six openers do almost all the work in real writing, and each one promises the reader a slightly different kind of spotlight.
Opener Example What it puts in the spotlight
What … What this crossing needs is money. a thing, named by a noun phrase.
What … did What Vidar did was reshoot the whole street. the action itself — the verb goes bare after was .
All … All we ask for is a working phone number. the only thing — it quietly means and nothing more .
The reason (why) … The reason we ran it early was that the tender closed. the cause. It takes that , never because .
The thing that … The thing that surprised Lenka was the date on the file. a detail or a fact you want isolated.
The person who … The person who signed the correction off was Naledi. a person, when you want them at the end of the line.
The pivot verb looks forward, not back. In a wh-cleft, is or are agrees with the spotlight that comes after it, and never with the wh-clause in front of it: What we need is a lawyer but What we need are two more subeditors . The wh-clause is grammatically singular whatever it contains, so it will happily let a plural slip past — this is the single most common slip in the whole topic.
The reason … was that , not because . The opener has already said reason ; adding because says it a second time and leaves the sentence without a proper complement: The reason we ran it early was that the tender closed a week later. The same goes for the it-cleft version, which needs its own joint: It was because the tender closed that we ran it early.
③ How to choose
Four questions — and the first one is about your reader
Clefting is not a decoration you sprinkle on a finished paragraph. It is a reply. So the questions start outside the sentence, with the person reading it.
What is the reader likely to assume? Before you touch the grammar, name the wrong idea in the reader’s head: they think Barnaby wrote it ; they think we ran the piece after the vote ; they think we were sent a report . If you cannot name an assumption, stop here — you do not need a cleft at all, and question 4 will tell you why.
Which single word or phrase corrects that assumption? One element, not two. In Solenne sent the email on Monday the correcting word might be Solenne , or on Monday , or email — and each choice produces a different sentence. Circle it. That circled element is going into the spotlight, and everything else is now treated as agreed.
Is the spotlight one element, or the whole action? A person, a day, a place, a cause, a named thing — one element the reader can point at — takes the it-cleft : It was the traffic office that supplied them. The action itself, or a thing you want to define, takes the wh-cleft : What she did was resend it ; What we published was a set of dates. When both would work, the it-cleft is sharper and the wh-cleft is warmer.
Is anything genuinely in dispute? Reread the paragraph before your sentence. If nothing there has been claimed, assumed or denied, a cleft promises a contrast that the reader then hunts for and never finds — and the plain sentence, which is shorter and faster, wins. Two clefts in a paragraph is emphatic; four in a paragraph is noise.
The claim
Councillor Godfrey writes: “Your magazine published an opinion piece and printed it as news.”
Question 1
The assumption is clear enough to quote: the reader now believes that what appeared on page five was somebody’s personal view.
Question 2
The correcting element is a set of dates . Nobody disputes that we published something, or when — only what the something was.
Question 3
The spotlight is a thing you can name with a noun phrase, and the rest of the clause is already agreed, so the wh-cleft takes it: what we published + was + the spotlight.
Answer
What we published was a set of dates , not an opinion. The comma phrase at the end is the other half of the trick: a cleft invites a not X tail, because it has already told the reader that a correction is under way.
The claim
“Your reporter lifted those figures off a campaign blog.”
Question 1
The assumption is about the source: the reader believes the numbers came from an outsider with an interest.
Question 2
One element corrects it — the source itself, the council’s own traffic office . The action, supplied the figures , is not in dispute at all.
Question 3
A single nameable element, and it happens to be the subject of the plain sentence. That is the it-cleft’s home ground: it + was + the spotlight + that + the rest.
Answer
It was the council’s own traffic office that supplied the figures. The joint that is not optional decoration — without it the sentence has two verbs, was and supplied , and nothing holding them together.
The claim
None. This is the opening line of a straight news item, before anybody has argued about anything.
Question 1
Name the assumption… and you cannot. The reader has read nothing yet, so there is no wrong idea in their head to correct.
Question 4
A cleft here would raise a contrast the paragraph never delivers. It was two lanes that closed at noon makes the reader ask “as opposed to how many?” — a question the story never answers.
Answer
Two lanes of Ormsby Street closed at noon. Plain, and correct. Save the cleft for paragraph four, where the council says the closure never happened.
④ Practice 1
The machinery first
Eight items on how the two families are built — the pivot verb, the joint, and the words that must not go missing. 0 / 8
⑤ The contrast
One sentence, three spotlights — and one case for leaving it alone
Here is the neutral sentence: Solenne sent the email on Monday. Four facts, all lying flat, none of them louder than the others. Now watch the same facts re-packaged three times. Nothing is added; the only thing that changes is which unspoken objection the sentence is answering.
No spotlight — the flat version
Solenne sent the email on Monday.
This answers what happened? and nothing else. It is the right sentence when the reader has no wrong idea to correct — a report, a timeline, a first line.
Spotlight: the person
It was Solenne who sent the email.
Answers the unspoken I thought Barnaby sent it. The day, the email and the sending are all conceded; one name is under repair, and the reader hears the contrast even without not Barnaby being written.
Spotlight: the day
It was on Monday that she sent it.
Answers I thought it went out on Friday. Notice that the sender has now slipped back into an ordinary pronoun, she — once an element leaves the spotlight, it is treated as old news.
Spotlight: the thing
What she sent was an email.
Answers I was expecting a letter. Here the wh-cleft is the natural pick: the spotlight is a thing being defined, and the sentence practically asks for a not a letter tail.
Verdict: the facts never moved. What moved was the reader’s attention, and with it the assumption the sentence is quietly denying. So choose the cleft by working backwards: decide which objection you are answering, and the shape follows. A person, a time or a cause goes to the it-cleft; the action or a defined thing goes to the wh-cleft.
Plain — nothing is in dispute
At nine the alarm sounded and the hall emptied.
A narrative line, doing narrative work. It is fast, and the reader takes it whole.
Clefted — pointing at nothing
What happened at nine was that the alarm sounded.
Grammatically flawless and rhetorically empty. The shape announces a correction, so the reader stops and searches the previous sentence for the claim being denied — and there is none.
Verdict: a cleft is expensive. It costs the reader an extra clause and a pause, and it borrows against a promise: something you believed is about to be adjusted. Pay that cost where an assumption really is in play, and the sentence rings. Pay it in an ordinary narrative line and you have written a longer sentence that says less. If you cannot name the objection, do not cleft.
Seven items on exactly this decision: which spotlight — or none at all. 0 / 7
⑥ In context
The editor replies, page two
A councillor has accused the Ardley Review of inventing a story. Naledi, the editor, answers on the letters page — and every cleft in her reply is aimed at one sentence of his. Tap any coloured phrase to see which assumption it is correcting.
Councillor Godfrey writes that this magazine invented the delay at the Ormsby Street crossing. Let me be exact. What we published was a set of dates, not an opinion. It was the council’s own traffic office that supplied them, in a spreadsheet dated 3 March. The reason we ran the story that week was that the tender closed seven days later; a report published after the vote helps nobody.
It wasn’t until Tuesday that anyone at the council answered us, and even then what we were sent was a press release. The councillor is right about one thing. We misspelled his surname, and we have corrected it. It is only now, three weeks on, that the full figures have appeared. All we ask for is a working phone number. What the crossing needs is money, not a letter about us.
Tap any coloured phrase above. Blue = a wh-cleft (what · the reason · all) · green = an it-cleft · orange = a sentence left plain on purpose.
⑦ Practice 2
Harder: agreement, joints and restraint
Real editorial contexts now — plural spotlights, causes, repeated subjects, and one sentence that is better off with no cleft at all. 0 / 8
⑧ Sort it
Which family opened this sentence?
Twelve sentence openings from the Ardley Review ’s letters page. Read each one and finish it in your head — then tap it into the family whose machinery it is running. Watch what happens to the second column: every single entry there begins with the same two words. 0 / 12
wh-cleft — clause first, spotlight last
it-cleft — it + be, spotlight second
Start with What we published… . Which family opens with a clause and saves the spotlight for the end?
⑨ Fix it
Six sentences off the letters desk
Every one of these is a real B2 slip: a missing joint, a pivot verb looking the wrong way, or a word doing a job that is already done. Tap a sentence to see the repair and the reason.
⑩ Watch out
Four traps, and the last one is not about grammar
Three of these break the sentence. The fourth builds a perfectly correct sentence that should never have been written — and it is the one examiners and editors notice most.
Trap 1 · The pivot verb agrees with what comes after it
What we need is two more subeditors.
What we need are two more subeditors.
The wh-clause in front is grammatically singular whatever it contains, so your ear reaches for is automatically. Ignore the ear and look forward: the spotlight is two more subeditors , and the pivot must match it. The same rule runs the other way — What these figures show is a delay , singular, however plural the figures are.
Trap 2 · An it-cleft cannot live without its joint
It was the interns spotted the error.
It was the interns who spotted the error.
Drop who or that and the sentence is left holding two verbs, was and spotted , with nothing joining them. Use who for people, that for everything else — and if you hesitate for a second, use that , which is correct for people too. There is one more thing the joint fixes: the spotlight has already taken the subject slot, so never repeat it — It was Naledi who signed it off , not who she signed it off .
Trap 3 · One reason word per sentence
The reason we ran it early was because the tender closed.
The reason we ran it early was that the tender closed.
Reason has already announced the cause, so because announces it a second time and leaves the pivot verb with no proper complement. Use that . The it-cleft handles the same job differently and keeps both words in their own seats: It was because the tender closed that we ran it early.
Trap 4 · Clefting when nothing is in dispute
What I did was I walked to the office and then I opened the post.
I walked to the office and opened the post.
Nothing here is being corrected, so the shape promises a contrast that never arrives — and the doubled subject ( What I did was I walked ) belongs to speech, not to writing. In an argumentative paragraph one or two clefts land like hammer blows; in a narrative paragraph they read as padding. Before you cleft, name the objection you are answering. No objection, no cleft.
⑪ Quick test
Eight questions, no hints
Both families mixed, plus one item where the plain sentence is the better answer. Run the four questions from section ③ before you tap. 0 / 8
Answer all eight to see how you did.
Teacher notes
Sequence (45 min): §1 read the lede aloud and demonstrate the point physically — say Solenne sent the email four times, stressing a different word each time, and ask what each version denies; then show that the page cannot do it, 5 min. §2 the machinery table with one column covered, class predicting the other, 7 min. §3 walk the three worked runs, letting the class name the assumption before you reveal it, 6 min. §4 alone, then pairs compare reasons, 5 min. §5 the three-spotlight compare on the board as one sentence rewritten live, then the items, 8 min. §6 read once for meaning, then tap in pairs — ask specifically why the two orange sentences stayed plain, 4 min. §7 alone, 4 min. §8 as a race, 2 min. §9 pairs, 2 min. §10 read trap 4 last and dwell on it, 2 min. §11 silent exit ticket — takeaway: a three-sentence rebuttal of a false claim about the learner’s own town, containing exactly two clefts.
The board move that works: the objection line. Write one neutral sentence across the board and, underneath it, three objections in speech bubbles — I thought it was Barnaby · I thought it was Friday · I thought you posted a letter . Ask a learner to answer one bubble without adding any new facts. They will reach for stress; point out that the reader cannot hear them, and then build the cleft together. Once emphasis has been framed as a reply rather than a decoration, the form-teaching takes half the time it otherwise would.
Give the hook, then break it: the class will over-produce clefts the moment they can build one. Let it happen, then read a learner’s narrative paragraph aloud with every cleft intact and ask, after each one, “which sentence is this arguing with?” The silence does the teaching. Trap 4 is the real B2 skill here; the machinery is the easy half.
If a learner is stuck, take the grammar away and hand them a two-column game: your claim, my correction. You say Vidar took that photograph ; they must reply No — it was Lenka who took it. Fifteen exchanges with no writing at all, then transcribe three of them. Learners who cannot build a cleft from a rule build one instantly when they are contradicting somebody.
Cambridge B2 First: clefts are standard currency in Use of English Part 4 key-word transformations ( WHAT , IT and REASON as the given key words), and a well-placed It wasn’t until… or What surprised me most was… raises the Language band in a Writing Part 2 review or article. Speaking Part 4 disagreements are the natural home of the it-cleft.
Comes from: B2-10 (the relative-clause machinery that who and that are borrowed from) and B2-22 (the passive — the other structure whose entire job is moving an element to where the reader is looking). Next: B2-31 (advanced linkers — whereas , nevertheless , the connectors that argumentative paragraphs run on, and the paragraphs where clefts do their best work) and B2-28 (comparative structures, emphasis of a different kind).
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus A1–B2 · topic B2-29
Lesson Plan
- Why writing has no stress and clefting does the pointing
- Two pattern strips: what we published was… / it was the traffic office that…
- A formula for each family, with the classic wrong version struck through
Key Vocabulary
Grammar Points
- wh-clefts: what / all / the reason (why) / the thing that + clause + is / was + the highlighted element; the verb agrees with what follows, and after what … did the verb goes bare (was rewrite / was to rewrite)
- it-clefts: it + is / was + the highlighted element + who / that + the rest; the pivot stays singular (it was the interns who…), who for people and that for everything
- The reason … was that, never was because; and the it-cleft equivalent, it was because … that …
- It wasn't until X that Y and it is only now that Y — negative and restrictive spotlights on time
- Restraint: a cleft answers an unspoken assumption, so an undisputed narrative line stays plain
