📋 Grammar A2-23: have to / don’t have to
The twenty-third material of the Fleydo A2 grammar series, and the one that turns must into a system. It rests on two ideas. The first is that have to only sounds like a rule word: it is built like an everyday verb, so it takes -s after he, she and it, it borrows do, does and did for negatives and questions, and it has a past form that must does not have. A four-column table conjugates play, have to and must side by side until the third column visibly collapses. The second idea is the one that costs marks for years: mustn’t and don’t have to are not two ways of saying the same thing. Mustn’t closes a door, don’t have to opens one, and a compare-and-verdict pair tests both against four extra words — but you can if you want. A four-step procedure decides every sentence, and three worked examples run a positive, a negative and a question through it step by step, showing why the helper word always sends have back to its plain shape. Practice is spread over four sets of eight, seven, eight and eight explained items, plus ten club rules to sort into obligation and free choice, six transformation cards that stay hidden until the learner commits, six real errors to repair and three traps. A tap-and-explain notice from a climbing club shows all three forms working in natural writing. Teacher notes give a 45-minute sequence, the two-column board move, a two-second demonstration at the classroom door, and the Cambridge A2 Key relevance.
Text version of this lesson
Grammar A2-23: have to / don’t have to
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus
A2
≈ 25 min
A2-23
① The idea
Some things you have to do. Some things you don’t have to do.
A rule, a timetable, a job or a coach makes something necessary — that is have to . Nothing makes it necessary and you may decide for yourself — that is don’t have to . The two forms look almost the same on the page, and they mean opposite things.
Dev + has to + wear + a helmet
who the rule the action, plain
a rule from outside → subject + have to / has to + plain verb
no rule at all → subject + don’t / doesn’t + have to + plain verb
Protect the second line. You don’t have to bring a snack never means “snacks are banned here”. It means “bring one if you like — nobody is asking you to”. Don’t have to hands the choice back to you.
② The form
It sounds like must , but it is built like play
This is the whole secret of the topic. Have to says the same kind of thing as must , but it is put together like any everyday verb: it takes -s after he , she and it , it borrows do , does and did for negatives and questions, and it has a past form. Must does none of those three things.
Subject There is a rule There is no rule Question
I / you / we / they I have to stay I don’t have to stay Do you have to stay?
he / she / it She has to stay She doesn’t have to stay Does she have to stay?
finished time, any subject We had to stay We didn’t have to stay Did you have to stay?
Now read it beside a verb you have known since A1. Column two is play , column three is have to : the same machine, every row. Column four is must , which refuses to play along.
play have to must
after he / she / it he play s he has to he must — no -s ever
negative he doesn’t play he doesn’t have to he mustn’t — no helper
question Does he play? Does he have to ? Must he? — no helper
past he play ed he had to no past form at all
The one thing everybody gets wrong: the moment do , does or did arrives, the word after it is plain have . Never has , never had . The helper is already carrying the -s and the past tense for the whole group, and English lets only one word carry them. That is why we write She doesn’t have to wait and Did you have to wait? — exactly as we write She doesn’t play and Did you play?
And the verb after “to” stays plain. Whatever happens at the front of the sentence, the action word at the end never changes shape: She has to leave , not leaves . They had to leave , not left . Everything before it has already done the work.
③ How to choose
Four questions, always in this order
Do not pick the form by feel. Run these four questions, in this order, until they run themselves.
Where does it come from? If a rule, a timetable, a job, a ticket or a parent makes it necessary, you want have to . If nothing makes it necessary and the person may choose, you want don’t have to .
Who is the subject, and when? He, she, it, one person, everybody → has to . Everyone else → have to . If the time is finished, every subject takes had to .
Is it a negative or a question? Then remember what this verb really is: an ordinary one. It borrows do , does or did , just as play and eat do.
When the helper arrives, put “have” back. Does and did already carry the -s and the past, so the next word is plain have — and the action word after to is plain too.
Sentence
Zuri ___ (wear) a helmet on the high wall.
Question 1
The club made the helmet rule, not Zuri. Something outside her makes it necessary, so this is the have to side, not the free side.
Question 2
Zuri is one person — she . An everyday verb adds -s after she , and this verb is an everyday one, so have to becomes has to .
Question 3
The sentence is positive, so no helper word is needed and nothing else changes.
Answer
Zuri has to wear a helmet on the high wall. The action word stays plain: wear , never wears . Only one word in the group takes the -s.
Sentence
Dev ___ come on Sunday. The lesson is only for people who want it.
Question 1
Nothing makes Sunday necessary — the second sentence says so. This is the free side: don’t have to .
Question 2
Dev is he , one person, and the time is now, so we are heading for the doesn’t row.
Question 3
It is a negative, so the helper word appears: he doesn’t play , he doesn’t come , he doesn’t have to .
Question 4
Doesn’t is already carrying the -s for the whole group, so has goes back to plain have . Two -s endings in one verb group is always a mistake.
Answer
Dev doesn’t have to come on Sunday. He may come — that is the point of this form. It removes the rule, not the choice.
④ Practice 1
Eight on the form
Ask question 2 first every time: who is the subject, and is the time finished? 0 / 8
⑤ The contrast that matters
mustn’t and don’t have to are opposites
Both of them are negative, both of them are short, and learners swap them for years. They are not two ways of saying one thing. Mustn’t closes a door. Don’t have to opens one.
mustn’t — the door is shut
You mustn’t touch the red ropes.
Somebody forbids it. There is no choice at all, and doing it anyway means breaking a rule. Ask yourself: is the answer to “may I?” a hard no ?
don’t have to — the door is open
You don’t have to bring a helmet.
Nobody forbids anything. Bring one, or take one from the box by the door — both are fine. Ask yourself: is the answer to “may I?” as you like ?
Verdict: mustn’t means it is not allowed ; don’t have to means it is not necessary . Test the sentence by adding four words: “…but you can if you want”. If those words fit, you need don’t have to . If they sound crazy, you need mustn’t .
not allowed → mustn’t + plain verb
not necessary → don’t / doesn’t have to + plain verb
Careful in the positive too. Must and have to are close there — both say something is necessary — but they point in different directions. Must usually comes from the speaker: I must phone my aunt (I decided). Have to usually comes from outside the speaker: I have to wear a tie at school (the school decided). And when the time is finished there is no competition at all, because must has no past form: Yesterday I had to wear a tie.
Seven items on that one contrast, and nothing else. Try the four extra words before you choose. 0 / 7
⑥ Asking and the past
Where the helper words do the work
Because this is an ordinary verb, the answer to a question about it is an ordinary short answer: Yes, I do. Not Yes, I have . The word that started the question is the word that finishes it.
Question Yes No
Do you have to sign in? Yes, I do . No, I don’t .
Does Halima have to work? Yes, she does . No, she doesn’t .
Did they have to wait? Yes, they did . No, they didn’t .
Question words go in front Why do we have to sign in? · When did she have to leave?
Sentence
Make a question: Halima ___ ___ work on Saturdays?
Question 1
We are asking whether her job makes Saturday necessary, so the structure is have to — we simply do not know the answer yet.
Question 2
Halima is she , and the time is now, so the helper for this row is does .
Question 3
A question puts the helper at the very front, before the subject: Does Halima… , exactly like Does Halima bake bread?
Question 4
Does is carrying the -s, so the next word is plain have , and work stays plain as well.
Answer
Does Halima have to work on Saturdays? — Yes, she does . Three plain words in a row, and every ending is on the first one.
Six cards. Say your answer out loud before you tap, then tap to see whether the helper words behaved.
⑦ In context
Saturday at Kestrel Hill
Every coloured phrase was chosen for a reason. Tap one and the reason appears underneath.
KESTREL HILL CLIMBING CLUB — please read this before you start. Everybody has to sign in at the desk. Every climber under sixteen has to climb with a partner. You don’t have to bring a helmet, because there is a box of them by the door. You mustn’t touch the red ropes; they belong to the staff.
Dev arrived at nine. He doesn’t have to pay today, because members don’t have to pay on their birthday. “ Do I have to book a lesson?” he asked Coach Prentis. “No, you don’t,” she said, “but you mustn’t climb the high wall alone.” Dev had to wait ten minutes for Zuri, who has to take two buses to get here.
Halima has to get up at five on Saturdays, because she bakes bread before the club opens. Last week the big oven broke, so she had to wash trays for two hours instead. “ Did you have to stay late?” Zuri asked. “No, I didn’t have to stay,” said Halima, “and today I don’t have to work at all.”
Tap any coloured phrase above. Blue = there is a rule · green = there is no rule · orange = it is forbidden.
⑧ Practice 2
Eight harder ones
Read the whole sentence before you choose: the words around the gap tell you the time and the subject. 0 / 8
⑨ Sort it
What the club asks for, and what it leaves to you
Kestrel Hill lends helmets, harnesses, shoes and ropes for nothing, and the snacks on the shelf are free too. It asks every climber to sign in, to climb in pairs, to book lessons in advance and to listen to the coach. Now sort these ten. 0 / 10
have to — the club asks for it
don’t have to — you choose
Start with sign in at the desk . Does the club ask for it, or is it up to you?
⑩ Fix the mistake
Six sentences to repair
Every one of these is written by A2 learners every week. Tap a sentence to see the repair and the reason.
Trap 1 · one -s for the whole group
She doesn’t has to wait.
She doesn’t have to wait.
Doesn’t is already the -s form. Once it appears, the word after it is plain have — exactly as we write She doesn’t wait , not She doesn’t waits .
Trap 2 · “not allowed” is not “not necessary”
You mustn’t bring a towel — we give everybody one.
You don’t have to bring a towel — we give everybody one.
The first sentence bans towels, which was not the idea at all. Mustn’t forbids; don’t have to simply says the rule is not there.
Trap 3 · the past belongs to “had to”
Yesterday I must help in the shop.
Yesterday I had to help in the shop.
Must has no past form, so when the time is finished this verb takes over the job. In the negative it is didn’t have to : Yesterday I didn’t have to help.
⑪ Quick test
Eight questions, no hints
Run the four questions in your head, silently, before you touch a button. 0 / 8
Answer all eight to see how you did.
Teacher notes
Sequence (45 min): §1 read aloud, 3 min — spend the time on the second line of the formula, not the first. §2 board work, 8 min: build the four-column table with the class and let them fill the play column from memory. §3 procedure read together, then both worked examples on the board with learners calling out the question numbers, 8 min. §4 alone, then pairs compare reasons, 6 min. §5 the contrast, 7 min — this is the heart of the lesson, do not rush it. §6 cards in pairs, spoken answer before the tap, 4 min. §7 whole class, 3 min. §8 alone, 4 min. §9 as a race, 2 min. §10 pairs, 3 min. §11 silent, as the exit ticket, 5 min.
The board move that works: write play and have to side by side and conjugate them together, line by line — he plays / he has to , he doesn’t play / he doesn’t have to , Does he play? / Does he have to? , he played / he had to . Then write must in a third column and try the same four lines. The column collapses in front of them, and they never ask again why one takes do and the other does not.
The contrast, physically: stand by the classroom door. Say “You mustn’t go out” and block it with your arm; say “You don’t have to go out” and step aside. Two seconds, and the meaning lands harder than any translation exercise. Then hold both up against the four test words: …but you can if you want .
If a learner is stuck, it is nearly always step 4 — they write doesn’t has to . Take have to away completely and drill doesn’t play / doesn’t watch / doesn’t go for one minute, then put it back. The mistake is not about this topic at all; it is the present simple negative, and it returns because have looks too important to leave plain.
Cambridge A2 Key: obligation language appears in Reading and Writing Part 4 and Part 5, where notices, club rules and short emails are exactly the text types this material imitates, and the mustn’t / don’t have to pair is a standard distractor in the multiple-choice items. In Speaking Part 2 candidates describe school and free-time routines, where I have to… and I don’t have to… carry most of the answer.
Comes from: A1-14 (can / can’t for permission), A2-15 (can, could — consolidation), A2-22 (must / mustn’t). Next: A2-24 (should / shouldn’t for advice), then B1-14, which puts must and have to together properly, and much later B2-25 (needn’t have done against didn’t need to do).
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus A1–B2 · topic A2-23
Lesson Plan
- A rule from outside against no rule at all, in one pattern strip and one formula
- Why “You don’t have to bring a snack” never means snacks are banned
Key Vocabulary
Grammar Points
- subject + have to / has to + plain verb for an obligation that comes from outside
- have to is an everyday verb: doesn’t have to, Does she have to? — never doesn’t has to
- Past for every subject: had to, didn’t have to, Did you have to? — must has no past
- mustn’t = not allowed; don’t have to = not necessary. They are opposites, not synonyms
- The verb after to never changes: She has to leave, They had to leave
- Short answers use the helper word: Yes, I do. No, she doesn’t. Yes, they did.
