📎 Grammar B1-31: Non-defining relative clauses
The thirty-first material of the Fleydo B1 grammar series picks up where Defining relative clauses left off and teaches the other kind: the clause that identifies nothing, because the sentence already knows exactly who it is talking about. The opening image is a whispered aside — My aunt Gwen, who lives in Lisbon, is arriving on Friday — and the delete test that proves it: lift the clause out and the same aunt is still arriving. Three rules guard the fence, and each gets its own formula line and trap: a pair of commas closes the aside off at both ends, that is banned completely between them, and nothing can be dropped — the pronoun-dropping trick from the defining clause dies at the first comma. A five-row table hands over the words that may enter the fence — who, which, whose, where — plus the B1 bonus move, which pointing at a whole event: The lunch lasted four hours, which nobody minded. The compare-and-verdict pair is the heart of the material: my brother who works at the bakery against my brother, who works at the bakery — identical words, and the commas alone decide how many brothers the writer has. A 124-word postcard from Lisbon makes every clause tappable, asides in green, identifying clauses in blue and event-which in orange. Practice runs to thirty-one explained multiple-choice items in four sets, twelve clause chips to sort into identifies and just adds, six real learner repairs and four traps. Teacher notes carry a 45-minute sequence, the count-the-brothers board move, the finger-over-the-clause rescue and Cambridge B1 Preliminary relevance.
Text version of this lesson
Grammar B1-31: Non-defining relative clauses
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus
B1
≈ 30 min
B1-31
① The idea
The sentence already knows — the clause just whispers
Say My aunt Gwen is arriving on Friday and nobody asks which aunt Gwen — you only have one. So when you slide in who lives in Lisbon , that little clause — a mini-sentence riding inside a bigger one — is not helping anyone find her. It is a whispered aside: a bonus fact, dropped into the middle of the sentence and fenced off by a pair of commas. You met the other kind of clause in Defining relative clauses — the working kind, the boy who sits behind me , which answers which one? . This kind answers nothing. It just adds.
My aunt Gwen , who lives in Lisbon , is arriving on Friday
already known the whispered aside complete without it
the aside — lives between the commas, leaves without damage
an identifying clause could never be lifted out like this
a name or a one-of-a-kind + , who / which / whose / where + bonus fact , + the rest
the fence: a comma on each side · that never enters · nothing gets dropped
Three rules guard the fence. ① A pair of commas closes the aside off — one to open it, one to close it, like brackets you can hear. ② That is banned inside it: who for people, which for things, however natural that sounds. ③ Nothing can be dropped — the pronoun-dropping trick from identifying clauses dies at the first comma. Break any of the three and the whisper turns into noise; the rest of this material drills all three.
② The form
Four words may enter the fence
Grammar books call the fenced clause a non-defining relative clause : it does not define who you mean — it decorates. The aside always opens with one of four words, chosen by what it points at. And notice which old friend is missing from the table.
Opens with Points at Example
who a person Sylvie, who never loses at cards, taught me a new game.
which a thing or an animal Our tent, which cost almost nothing, survived the storm.
whose something that belongs to them Joss, whose sister works at the airport, found us cheap flights.
where a place Lisbon, where my aunt lives, sits on a wide river.
which a whole event The lunch lasted four hours, which nobody minded.
Where is that? Nowhere — and not by accident. In an identifying clause, that works everywhere: the sofa that folds out, a café that stays open late. Between commas it is banned completely. Writing My aunt, that lives in Lisbon, is one of the most reliable ways to lose a mark at this level: inside the fence, a person takes who and a thing takes which — there is no third option.
The bonus move: which for a whole event
Sometimes the aside is not about a person or a thing at all — it is a comment on everything that just happened. English hands that job to which : the comma closes the event, and which scoops the whole of it up.
The train was late , which = the train being late
the whole event scoops it up what which means here
The train was late, which annoyed everyone. What annoyed everyone? Not the train — the lateness, the whole fact before the comma. This move only exists in the fenced world: an identifying clause can never point at an event.
One comma is not a fence. Mid-sentence, the aside needs a comma at both ends: Aunt Gwen, who never travels light, arrived with four bags. Forget the second comma and the aside swallows the rest of the sentence. Only at the very end does the full stop close the fence for you: We stayed with Aunt Gwen, who cooks like a dream.
③ How to choose
Four questions before you touch the comma key
Your ear will not warn you here — out loud, an identifying clause and an aside sound almost the same. The commas are decided by meaning, so run the questions, every time, until they run themselves.
Does the sentence already know? A name (Hazel, Lisbon, Grandad Kit) or a one-of-a-kind (my mum, our car, the sun) leaves the clause nobody to identify — it can only add. A bare label (a boy, the café, people) usually needs the clause to say which one.
Run the delete test. Read the sentence without the clause. Still pointing at the same person or thing? It is an aside — fence it off. Suddenly you cannot tell which one? It is an identifying clause — keep the commas away and use the old rules.
Pick the word at the gate. Who for a person, which for a thing or a whole event, whose for belonging, where for a place. That never enters the fence, however natural it sounds.
Close what you open. Mid-sentence, the aside needs a comma at both ends. At the end of the sentence, the full stop closes the fence for you.
Sentence
Grandad Kit ___ is coming for the weekend. The fact to add: he taught me to fish .
Question 1
Grandad Kit is a name, and a name points at exactly one person. The clause cannot help anyone find him — it can only add.
Question 2
Delete test: Grandad Kit is coming for the weekend — still the same grandad, nothing lost. An aside, so it gets the fence.
Question 3
He is a person, so the clause opens with who — and that was never on the menu between commas anyway.
Answer
Grandad Kit , who taught me to fish, is coming for the weekend.
Sentence
The bakery ___ has moved. The fact: it sells the lemon buns .
Question 1
The bakery is just a label — this town has four of them. The clause is not decoration here; it is the only way to say which bakery.
Question 2
Delete test: The bakery has moved — which bakery? The sentence collapses, so the clause is doing identifying work.
Question 3
Identifying means the old rules apply: no commas, and that is welcome again.
Answer
The bakery that sells the lemon buns has moved — no fence anywhere.
Sentence
Our train stopped for an hour ___. The fact: nobody explained it .
Question 1
The fact is not about the train — it is about the whole event, the stopping. Only fenced which can point at an event.
Question 2
The aside ends the sentence, so one comma opens the fence and the full stop closes it.
Answer
Our train stopped for an hour , which nobody explained.
④ Practice 1
Who, which, whose, where — and both commas
Eight items on the machinery of the fence. Question 3 every time: what does the aside point at? 0 / 8
⑤ The contrast
Two commas change how many brothers you have
Read these two sentences slowly. Every word is identical — only the commas differ — and they describe two different families.
no commas — the clause chooses
My brother who works at the bakery gets up at five.
The clause is doing identifying work: it separates the bakery brother from my other brothers. Read it and you learn something about my family — I have more than one brother, and I need the clause to say which one I mean.
commas — the clause whispers
My brother , who works at the bakery, gets up at five.
The fence stops the clause from choosing anything. The sentence already points at my only brother; the clause just drops in a bonus fact. One brother, one bakery, nothing to pick between.
Verdict: an identifying clause is a filter — it answers which one? and refuses commas. An aside answers nothing; it adds a fact about someone already known, and it demands the fence. When you are not sure, run the delete test: if the sentence still points at the same person without the clause, the commas go in.
Seven items on exactly that line — most of them ask what the sentence means , because that is what the commas control. 0 / 7
⑥ In context
Postcard from Lisbon
A half-term text stuffed with asides — Aunt Gwen would approve. Every coloured clause was fenced, or left unfenced, on purpose. Tap one and read why.
Half-term at last! On Saturday we flew to Lisbon, where my aunt Gwen has lived for ten years . Gwen, who talks to absolutely everyone , made friends with our taxi driver before we had even left the airport. Her flat, which looks over the river , is tiny, so I slept on the sofa that folds out into a bed .
On Monday her neighbour, whose grandson is exactly my age , invited us to lunch — and the lunch lasted four hours, which nobody minded . On the last morning I bought a present for Hazel, who is feeding our cat all week : a box of the little custard tarts that the city is famous for . Dad ate three on the way home, which explains a lot about Dad .
Tap any coloured clause. Green = a fenced aside · blue = an identifying clause, no commas · orange = which pointing at a whole event.
⑦ Practice 2
Real sentences, all four questions at once
Harder now: fences to place, drops to refuse, and whole events to scoop up. 0 / 8
⑧ Sort it
Does the clause identify — or just add?
Twelve clauses with their owners, commas removed. One question each: does the sentence already know exactly who or what this is? Tap a chip and it goes into its box. 0 / 12
identifies — no commas
just adds — fence it off
Start with the boy who sits behind me . Could you find him without the clause?
⑨ Fix the mistake
Six sentences to repair
Every one of these is a sentence real B1 learners write. Tap it to see the correction and the reason.
⑩ Watch out
The four traps of the fence
Two of these are about commas, one is about that, and the last one changes what your sentence means without you noticing.
Trap 1 · one comma is not a fence
Aunt Gwen, who never travels light arrived with four bags.
Aunt Gwen, who never travels light, arrived with four bags.
An aside has two ends, so mid-sentence it needs two commas — one to open the fence, one to close it. With only the first, the whisper never stops and the main sentence never gets its verb back. Read your sentence aloud: the voice drops at both commas, and if it only drops once, one is missing.
Trap 2 · that never enters the fence
Her flat, that looks over the river, is tiny.
Her flat, which looks over the river, is tiny.
That is the workhorse of identifying clauses, so B1 writers reach for it out of habit — and the comma stops it dead. Between commas a thing takes which and a person takes who , with no exceptions. If you want that, you must want no commas either.
Trap 3 · the drop rule dies at the comma
The Half Moon Café, we love, is closing down.
The Half Moon Café, which we love, is closing down.
You learned to drop the object pronoun in identifying clauses — the café we love is perfect English. The trick only works without commas. Inside the fence, nothing may be dropped: which stays, however short the aside is.
Trap 4 · commas around a working clause
The students, who forgot their kit, ran laps.
The students who forgot their kit ran laps.
Only half the class forgot their kit — but the commas stop the clause from filtering, so the first sentence claims every single student forgot and every single one ran. If the clause is needed to say which ones , the fence changes the facts. Commas are meaning here, not decoration.
⑪ Quick test
Eight questions, no help
No hints this time. Run the four questions from section ③ in your head. 0 / 8
Answer all eight to see how you did.
Teacher notes
Sequence (45 min): §1 read together and act out the whisper — say the aside quietly, hands making brackets in the air, 5 min. §2 table plus the missing-that hunt (who can say why that is not in the table?), 6 min. §3 walk the three worked runs on the board with the class calling the four questions, 7 min. §4 alone, then pairs compare reasons, 6 min. §5 the two-brothers board pair first — count the brothers out loud — then items, 7 min. §6 read the postcard aloud once, then tap in pairs, 4 min. §7 alone, 4 min. §8 as a race, 2 min. §9 in pairs, 3 min. §10 read the traps aloud, 2 min. §11 silent, as the exit ticket, 5 min — takeaway: three true sentences about their own family, each with a fenced aside.
The board move that works: write My brother who works at the bakery gets up at five and ask the class to draw the writer’s family. Then add the two commas and ask again — the brothers shrink from several to one, and the class sees the commas change the facts, not the style. Keep both family drawings on the board all lesson and point at them whenever an item goes wrong.
If a learner is stuck, teach the finger test: cover the clause with a finger and read what is left. If the sentence still points at the same person — same aunt, same café — the clause was only whispering, and whispers get the fence. If the finger makes the sentence collapse into which one? , the clause was working, and working clauses refuse commas.
The deepest error is not the punctuation — it is that inside the fence, because it never sounds wrong to a B1 ear. Drill the repair as a reflex: every time a comma appears before that, the class choruses who or which. The §9 repairs work read aloud in pairs for exactly this.
Cambridge B1 Preliminary: relative pronouns are regulars in Reading Part 5 and the open cloze Part 6, and the safest distinguishing clue is the comma — a gap after a comma can never be that. In Writing Part 2 (the article and the story), one well-fenced aside per paragraph is an easy way to show range; examiners also reward the event-which ( …, which was a big surprise ) as a linking device.
Comes from: B1-15 (defining relative clauses: who / which / that / whose / where and the drop rule — assumed throughout). Next: B2-10 (relative clauses: full range — non-defining consolidation, prepositions in relative clauses, whose and whom).
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus A1–B2 · topic B1-31
Lesson Plan
- The whispered aside: the sentence already knows who, so the clause can only add
- The delete test drawn out: lift the aside and the same aunt is still arriving
- The three rules of the fence: two commas, no that, nothing dropped
Key Vocabulary
Grammar Points
- A name or one-of-a-kind + a fenced clause adds a bonus fact: My aunt Gwen, who lives in Lisbon, is arriving on Friday
- That never enters the fence: Our tent, which cost almost nothing — never Our tent, that cost almost nothing
- Nothing can be dropped between commas: The Half Moon Café, which we love — never The Half Moon Café, we love
- Commas flip the meaning: my brother who works at the bakery (one of several) vs my brother, who works at the bakery (my only brother)
- Which can point at a whole event: The lunch lasted four hours, which nobody minded
Prerequisites
Присоединяйтесь к нашим занятиям!
Мы верим, что правильные вопросы приносят правильные ответы. Если у вас есть вопрос о вашем пути изучения английского, мы всегда здесь для вас.
