📏 Grammar B1-14: Obligation: consolidation
A2 taught must, have to and should as separate topics; this material welds them into one system with two axes — how strong the pressure is (must / have to, then should, then can) and which direction it pushes (obliged, advised, free, forbidden). The two load-bearing contrasts each get a compared pair with a verdict: mustn’t bans the action while don’t have to only removes the duty, and must announces the speaker’s own rule while have to reports an outside one. The genuinely new B1 ground is time: must and mustn’t have no past or future, so had to and will have to take over — a takeover with its own formula, two worked runs (including the past ban, which needs couldn’t or wasn’t allowed to) and dedicated practice. need to and don’t need to appear throughout as the everyday twins of have to and don’t have to. The context text is Livia’s first Saturday job at a garden centre, mixing every strength in one dialogue with tap-to-explain reasoning. Practice is heavy: thirty-eight multiple-choice items across five sets, a ten-chip sorter on the rule-maker, six repairs and three trap boxes, every answer teaching a reason. Teacher notes add a 45-minute sequence, a two-axis board move and the Cambridge B1 Preliminary connection.
Text version of this lesson
Grammar B1-14: Obligation: consolidation
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus
B1
≈ 30 min
B1-14
① The idea
You mustn’t open it. You don’t have to open it.
Both sentences are negative, both contain the same verb — and they point in opposite
directions. The first one bans the action: opening it is against the rules. The second only
removes the duty : open it or don’t, nobody minds. At A2 you met these verbs one by one;
at B1 you need the whole system, because the verbs only make sense against each other.
must / have to / need to + verb → do it — no choice
should + verb → a good idea — your choice
can + verb · don’t have to + verb → free — your choice
mustn’t / can’t + verb → do NOT do it — no choice
The map has two axes. How strong is the pressure — total ( must, have to ), advice
( should ), or none ( can )? And which direction does it push — do it, a good idea,
your choice, or do not do it? Every mistake with these verbs is a wrong answer to one of those two questions.
② The map
Four directions, one table
Read the table twice: once down the direction column, once down the
strength column. Notice that mustn’t and don’t have to sit in different
rows — they are not a pair, whatever their spelling suggests.
You say Direction How strong Example
must + verb do it — obliged total — no choice I must reply tonight. (my own rule)
have to / need to + verb do it — obliged total — no choice I have to wear the apron. (their rule)
should + verb a good idea — advised strong, but you choose You should ask first.
can + verb allowed — free zero — an open door You can take a break at one.
don’t have to / don’t need to not necessary — free zero — skip it if you like You don’t have to stay late.
mustn’t / can’t + verb do NOT do it — forbidden total — no choice You mustn’t water in full sun.
The machinery
must have to need to
after he / she / it must (never “musts”) has to needs to
negative mustn’t — a ban! doesn’t have to — no need doesn’t need to — no need
question Must we…? (rare) Do we have to …? Do we need to …?
past — none — had to needed to
future — none — will have to will need to
Why the table has holes: must and mustn’t are modals — no -s , no
to after them, no do in questions, and no other tenses at all. have to and
need to are ordinary verbs: they take does , did and will like any
other verb. That is exactly why they own the past and the future — section ⑥ lives on this fact.
③ How to choose
Four questions, in this order
Run them from the top and stop at the first yes . The order matters: direction
first, rule-maker last.
Is it only advice? If the listener can ignore it and nothing official happens, it is a good
idea, not a rule. Use should .
Does the rule say “do NOT do this”? A real ban, with a reason or a consequence behind it.
Use mustn’t (or can’t ).
Is the action simply unnecessary? Nobody minds whether you do it or not — the duty is
missing, not the permission. Use don’t have to or don’t need to .
So it is a real obligation. Whose rule is it — and when? Your own rule → must . The
world’s rule (law, boss, timetable) → have to . In the past → had to . In the future →
will have to .
Worked example 1 — same rule, two speakers
Scene
The sign-in rule at the Fern & Pot garden centre. Mrs. Okafor invented it, and she checks the sheet herself every morning.
Sentence
Mrs. Okafor, to her new Saturday worker: “You ___ sign in before nine.”
Steps
Not advice, not a ban, not unnecessary — a real obligation, so question 4 decides. Whose rule is it? Hers. The speaker made the rule she is announcing.
Answer
“You must sign in before nine.” must is the rule-maker’s word.
Switch
Livia, telling Callum about her new job: “I ___ sign in before nine.”
Steps
The rule has not changed — the speaker has. For Livia the rule arrives from outside: her boss made it, not her.
Answer
“I have to sign in before nine.” Same rule, different mouth.
Worked example 2 — two negatives, two directions
Scene
Two lines from Zora’s exam-day letter: “Calculators are provided at every desk.” — “Phones are not permitted in the hall.”
Sentence
Her teacher sums it up: “You ___ bring a calculator, and you ___ bring your phone.”
Gap 1
Is bringing a calculator banned? No — bring your own and nobody blinks. Is it necessary? Also no. The duty is simply missing: question 3.
Gap 2
The phone is a genuine ban — “not permitted”, and there is trouble if you break it. Question 2: direction, do NOT do it.
Answer
“You don’t have to bring a calculator, and you mustn’t bring your phone.” Two negatives, opposite directions.
④ Practice 1
Eight to start
Forms and directions first. Read the whole sentence — the clue usually sits after the
dash. 0 / 8
⑤ The contrast
The two pairs that decide everything
One pair splits on direction , the other on the rule-maker . Read the scene
above each sentence, not only the sentence.
mustn’t — the door is locked
The till at the garden centre, during opening hours.
You mustn’t leave the till open.
This bans the action. Doing it anyway breaks a rule, and something bad follows — the money is
unsafe and the manager is called.
don’t have to — the door is open
The yard is already swept; the Sunday team does it.
You don’t have to sweep the yard.
This removes the duty. Sweep it or don’t — both are fine, nobody minds. The choice belongs
entirely to you.
Verdict: both sentences are negative, but they negate different things. mustn’t makes
the action wrong; don’t have to makes the action optional. Quick test — ask: “Is it OK if
I do it anyway?” Yes → don’t have to . No → mustn’t .
must — the rule is yours
Nobody has said a word to Livia about her room.
I must tidy this room tonight.
The pressure comes from inside the speaker: her own promise, her own standard. She is the
rule-maker and the rule-follower at once.
have to — the rule is theirs
The rota on the staff-room wall says 8:30.
I have to be in at half past eight.
The pressure comes from outside: a rota, a law, a boss, a timetable. The speaker only reports a
rule somebody else made.
Verdict: ask who made the rule . The speaker → must . The world → have to .
In the positive the difference is a flavour; in the negative it is a canyon — don’t have to
frees you while mustn’t bans you, as the first pair showed.
Eight items on these two pairs only. 0 / 8
⑥ Past and future
must cannot travel in time
must and mustn’t exist only in the present. The moment your sentence moves
to yesterday or to next week they vanish — and had to and will have to step in and cover
the gap for the whole family, must included.
today: I must go · I have to go
yesterday: I must go → I had to go
tomorrow: I will must go → I will have to go
a past ban: we mustn’t → we couldn’t / we weren’t allowed to
Worked example — the takeover
Scene
Last Saturday a lorry of ferns arrived at five, and the plants could not wait until Monday.
Sentence
Livia: “I ___ (stay) until six.”
Step 1
When is the obligation? In the past — and must has no past form at all. musted does not exist.
Answer
“I had to stay until six.” had to is the past for both must and have to — one form covers the whole pair.
Future
Mrs. Okafor: “From December, everyone ___ (start) at seven.”
Step 2
A future obligation — and will must is impossible, because two modals can never stand together.
Answer
“From December, everyone will have to start at seven.”
Worked example — a ban in the past
Scene
Callum’s old swimming pool had one strict rule: no phones on the poolside, ever.
Sentence
Callum, remembering last year: “We ___ (use) phones on the poolside.”
Step 1
A ban, in the past — and mustn’t is stuck in the present exactly like must .
Step 2
For a past ban English borrows other verbs: couldn’t , or wasn’t / weren’t allowed to .
Answer
“We couldn’t use phones on the poolside.” — or “We weren’t allowed to use phones.”
Six items on the takeover. 0 / 6
⑦ In context
Saturday, five to nine
Tap any coloured verb to see why it was chosen. Blue = no choice, do it.
Amber = no choice, do NOT do it. Green = your choice.
Livia’s first Saturday at the Fern & Pot garden centre. Just before opening,
Mrs. Okafor hands her a printed card.
Mrs. Okafor: Three rules matter. You must sign in
before nine — that rule is mine, and I check. You have to wear
the green apron; head office insists. And you mustn’t water
anything standing in full sun — wet leaves burn.
Livia: Do I have to learn
all the plant names today?
Mrs. Okafor: No — you don’t have to know
them for weeks. You can keep
the card in your pocket. But you should ask
before touching the orchids. And from December everyone will have to start
at seven — tree season.
Livia, texting Callum at lunch: Seven o’clock starts! I need to buy
a louder alarm.
Tap a coloured verb above to see the reason behind it.
⑧ Practice 2
Harder: real scenes, questions, the future
Every item hides its clue in the second half of the sentence.
0 / 8
⑨ Whose rule?
must or have to — sort by the rule-maker
Ten situations. Ask one question each time: who made this rule for the person who
follows it? Tap a chip and it lands in its bin, with the reason underneath.
0 / 10
must — the speaker’s own rule
have to — an outside rule
Start with a promise you made to yourself — who made that rule?
⑩ Fix the mistake, and watch out
Six sentences to repair
Every one is a sentence a real B1 learner writes. Tap it to see the repair and the
reason.
Trap 1 · mustn’t is a ban, not a “no need”
You mustn’t bring a dictionary — they give you one.
You don’t have to bring a dictionary — they give you one.
If they give you one, bringing your own breaks no rule — it is just unnecessary. Save
mustn’t for real bans: You mustn’t write in the dictionary.
Trap 2 · must cannot travel in time
I must work last Saturday, so I missed the match.
I had to work last Saturday, so I missed the match.
must lives only in the present. The moment the sentence moves to the past, had to
takes over — and for the future, will have to .
Trap 3 · a past ban needs different words
At my old school we mustn’t use the lift.
At my old school we couldn’t use the lift.
mustn’t is stuck in the present exactly like must . A ban in the past is
couldn’t — or wasn’t / weren’t allowed to .
⑪ Quick test
Eight questions, no hints
Direction first, rule-maker second, time last. 0 / 8
Answer all eight to see how you did.
Teacher notes
Sequence (45 min): §1 and §2 on the board together — build the map from the learners’ A2 knowledge rather than presenting it (8 min) → §3, read the four questions aloud and walk both worked runs with the class (8 min) → §4 alone, check in pairs (6 min) → §5 as a whole-class discussion of the two pairs, then the eight items (9 min) → §6 with the board move below (6 min) → §7 in pairs (4 min) → §11 silent, as the exit ticket (4 min). §8, §9 and §10 are the homework set.
The board move that works: draw a cross. Vertical axis HOW STRONG (top = no choice, bottom = free), horizontal axis WHICH DIRECTION (left = do it, right = don’t). Hand out cards with must, have to, should, can, don’t have to, mustn’t and let learners pin them. The argument about where don’t have to goes IS the lesson — it belongs bottom-left-ish with can , nowhere near mustn’t .
The rescue for mustn’t vs don’t have to: one question — “Is it OK if I do it anyway?” Yes → don’t have to ; no → mustn’t . It repairs about nine mistakes in ten without any further explanation.
If must vs have to will not land, write ME / THEM above the sentence and ask only “who made this rule?” before they choose. Reassure them: in the positive the two are close and have to is nearly always safe; the negative is where the map punishes a wrong guess.
Do not teach “must is stronger than have to”. It is false — both are total obligation. The axis that separates them is the source of the rule, not its weight.
Hold the line on time: insist on had to / will have to now, but do not open should have — modal perfects are B1-26, and mixing them in here reliably breaks both topics. Likewise, if a learner offers “That must be the postman”, park it: deduction must is B1-25.
Cambridge B1 Preliminary relevance: Reading Part 1 (signs and notices) tests exactly the mustn’t / don’t have to split almost every session, and Reading Part 5 gaps regularly offer must / have to / should / can as the four options in one item.
Next: B1-25 (deduction must / can’t ) and B1-26 ( should have + past participle) both build directly on this map; revise A2-22, A2-23 and A2-24 first with learners who struggled in §4.
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus A1–B2 · topic B1-14
Lesson Plan
- Two negatives that point in opposite directions: mustn’t bans, don’t have to frees
- The two axes of the map: how strong the pressure is, and which way it pushes
Key Vocabulary
Grammar Points
- must / have to / need to + plain verb = obligation; mustn’t / can’t = prohibition; don’t have to / don’t need to = no obligation
- must = the speaker’s own rule; have to = an outside rule (law, boss, timetable)
- mustn’t bans the action; don’t have to removes the duty — the same spelling family, opposite directions
- must has no past or future: had to and will have to take over for the whole family
- a past ban is couldn’t or wasn’t / weren’t allowed to — mustn’t cannot reach the past
- have to and need to behave like ordinary verbs: do / does / did build their questions and negatives
Prerequisites
Присоединяйтесь к нашим занятиям!
Мы верим, что правильные вопросы приносят правильные ответы. Если у вас есть вопрос о вашем пути изучения английского, мы всегда здесь для вас.
