🙋 Grammar A2-33: Subject questions
The thirty-third material of the Fleydo A2 grammar series, and the one that finally explains why Who broke the window? has no did in it. The learner is given a procedure rather than a feeling: find the verb, say the answer out loud as a full sentence, and watch where the name lands. In front of the verb means the question word is the doer, so nothing moves and no helper appears; after the verb means it is an ordinary object question, and do, does or did comes back with the plain verb behind it. The whole material is built on one minimal pair — Who called Ben? against Who did Ben call? — four identical words that two different people have to answer, shown with the answer sliding into the exact place the question word was standing in. Who, What, Which and How many are all covered as subjects, together with the third-person -s that a helperless present question has to carry on its own (Who lives here?), the plural exception after how many, questions with be, the single place a helper legitimately returns (Who didn’t bring a pen?), and the natural short answers Rosa did, Petra does, I do and Tariq is. Practice runs to four sets of eight, seven, eight and eight items, every one explaining its own answer, plus ten things-to-ask-about to sort, six reveal cards on short answers, six real errors to repair and four traps. A tap-and-explain scene about muddy footprints in a school corridor shows both question types alive in one conversation. Teacher notes give a 45-minute sequence, the cover-a-word board move, what to do with a stuck learner, why the double-marked Who did break it? sounds acceptable to learners, and the Cambridge A2 Key relevance.
Text version of this lesson
Grammar A2-33: Subject questions
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus
A2
≈ 25 min
A2-33
① The idea
Some questions ask who did it — and those need no did .
Every question has a hole in it, and the question word marks where the hole is. Usually the
hole sits after the verb — the thing you ate, the person you saw — and English props that kind of question
up with do , does or did . But sometimes the hole is the doer itself. Then the
question word is already standing exactly where the answer will stand, nothing has to move, and the helper
has no job left to do.
Who + broke + the window ?
the doer itself the verb carries the past the rest
Who + did + you + see ?
the person you saw helper the doer plain verb
the question word is the doer → question word + verb + the rest + ?
the question word is not the doer → question word + do / does / did + the doer + plain verb + ?
A question carries its tense once . In Who broke it? the word broke is
already the past, so there is no room for did as well. Who did break it? marks the past twice,
and that is the single most common mistake on this whole page.
② The form
Four question words that can stand in the doer’s place
Not every question word can be the doer. Where , When and Why never can —
a place cannot do anything. These four can, and when they do, the question looks exactly like a statement
with its first word swapped out.
Word Subject question Full answer Short answer
Who Who wrote this note? Greta wrote it. Greta did .
What What happened at the gate? A branch fell down. —
Which Which bus goes to the harbour? The 12 goes there. The 12 does .
How many How many children came ? Nine children came. Nine did .
Read the middle column again: there is no do , no
does and no did anywhere in it. The verb is doing all the work by itself, so it has to be in
the right shape.
Situation Subject question What the verb is doing
present Who lives in the flat above? the he/she form, because one unknown person is the doer
present Which train stops at Rye? one train, so the verb takes -s as well
present, plural How many children stay for lunch? “how many children” already means more than one, so no -s
past Who took the last one? the past sits inside the verb — no did anywhere
with be Who was at the door? be never needed a helper in the first place
negative Who didn’t bring a pen? the one place the helper comes back
The -s catches everybody. A subject question in the present simple uses the he/she form of the verb,
because you are asking about one unknown doer: Who lives here? What makes that noise? Which car
belongs to you? Even when three people put their hands up, the question was still Who wants a
ticket? The only exception is how many plus a plural noun, which has already told us there is
more than one: How many people work here?
③ How to choose
Four steps, and the second one decides everything
Do not listen for a feeling. Say the answer out loud as a full sentence and watch where the
name lands — in front of the verb, or behind it. That is the whole trick.
Find the verb. Every question has one action word carrying the meaning: broke ,
happened , lives , called . Put your finger on it before you decide anything else.
Answer it with a name, and watch where the name lands. If the name goes in front of the
verb — Rosa called Ben — then the question word was the doer. If it goes after the verb —
Ben called Petra — then it was not.
Is the doer? Change nothing. Drop the question word into the place the name would have taken
and stop. No do , no does , no did . In the present, the verb takes the he/she form:
Who lives here?
Is not the doer? Build an ordinary question. Question word + do / does / did + the doer +
the plain verb: Who did Ben call? The helper has taken the tense, so the verb goes back to its
plainest shape.
Question
You want the name of the runner who finished first: ___ the race?
Step 1
The verb is won . Everything else in the question is furniture.
Step 2
Say the answer: Delia won the race. The name Delia lands in front of the verb, so the missing piece is the doer.
Step 3
Subject question. Put Who exactly where Delia was standing and leave the rest alone. The past is already inside won .
Answer
Who won the race? — and the short answer is Delia did. Notice that adding did to the question would have given you two past words: Who did won the race? is impossible, and Who did win the race? says the past twice.
Question
You want the name of the person Delia met: ___ at the station?
Step 1
The verb is meet , and Delia is already sitting in the question.
Step 2
Say the answer: Delia met Tariq at the station. The name Tariq lands after the verb, so the question word is not the doer — Delia is.
Step 4
Ordinary object question, so build it the normal way: Who + did + Delia + the plain verb.
Answer
Who did Delia meet at the station? — met goes back to meet , because did is carrying the past now. Same question word, same four ideas, completely different shape.
④ Practice 1
Doer, or not the doer?
Eight to begin with. The first sentence of each one tells you who is doing what — read it
before you look at the choices. 0 / 8
⑤ The contrast
Four words, two questions, two different people
Here are the same four words twice. Nothing has been added and nothing has been taken away
except the position of did — and yet a different person has to answer each one.
no helper — who is the doer
Who called Ben?
No helper. Who is standing straight in front of the verb, in the doer’s place, so who is
the one making the call. Ben only answers the phone.
the question
Who called Ben?
the answer, in the same place
Rosa called Ben.
or, shorter
Rosa did.
helper — Ben is the doer
Who did Ben call?
The helper is here, and so is the doer: Ben . He is making the call. Who has been pushed
out of the doer’s place, so it must be the person at the other end.
the question
Who did Ben call?
the answer lands after the verb
Ben called Petra.
or, shorter
Petra.
Verdict: the position of the answer tells you which question you were asked.
If the question word sits straight in front of the verb, it is the doer: no helper, and the answer
slides into that same place. The moment did appears, the doer is already named inside the question,
so the question word has to be something else. Who called Ben? is answered by Rosa did.
Who did Ben call? is answered by Petra.
Seven items on that contrast, and nothing else. Read every
sentence twice: the meaning decides the shape. 0 / 7
⑥ Short answers
The helper you left out comes back in the answer
Nobody replies to Who broke it? with a whole sentence. In real speech the answer is a
name and one small word — and that small word is the very helper the question refused to take.
Who broke it? → Kian did.
Who lives here? → Petra does.
Who wants one? → I do.
Who is ready? → Tariq is.
Why is that not a contradiction? In the question the helper had nothing to do, because the verb was
already sitting in its right place with its right ending. In the answer it has a real job: it stands in for
the whole verb, so you never have to say Kian broke the window again. Choose it by the tense of the
question — past → did , present → do or does , and with be the answer simply
repeats is , am or was .
Six cards. Say your short answer out loud before you tap
the card open — the guessing is the exercise, the reading is only the check.
⑦ In context
The muddy footprints
Every coloured question was built on purpose. Tap one and the reason appears underneath.
On Monday morning a line of muddy footprints ran the whole length of the science corridor.
“ What happened
here?” asked Mr Lars. Twenty-eight children studied the floor and said nothing at all. “All right, let me
ask it another way.
Who walked
through the flower beds?”
Delia put her hand up. “ Tariq did ,”
she said, “but it honestly was not his fault.” Mr Lars turned round.
“ What did you do
out there, Tariq?” “Our ball went over the fence, so I climbed after it.”
“ Who did you ask
first?” “Nobody,” said Tariq, going pink.
“ Who kicked
the ball over there in the first place?” Kian looked at his shoes.
“ I did .”
“ How many balls did you lose
this term?” “Four,” said Kian.
Mr Lars sighed and looked down the corridor.
“ Who cleans
this floor on a Monday?” “ Mrs Petra does ,”
said Delia quietly. “Then Tariq and Kian can help her at four o’clock. And by the way,”
he added, “ Who wrote
MR LARS IS GRUMPY on my board?” Nobody moved.
“ What did you write
it with?” he said. “A pencil,” said Delia. “Good. Then you can rub it off.”
Tap any coloured question above. Blue = the question word is the doer, so no helper · green = an ordinary question with a helper · orange = a short answer.
⑧ Practice 2
Eight questions inside real moments
Harder now, and mixed. Find the verb, then say the answer to yourself and listen for where the
name lands. 0 / 8
⑨ Sort it
What do you want to know?
Each chip says what is missing. Decide how you would ask for it: with no helper at all, or
with do , does or did . Tap the chip and it drops into a box.
0 / 10
ask with no helper
ask with do / does / did
Start with the girl who won . Who is doing the winning?
⑩ Fix the mistake
Six sentences to repair
Every one of these is written by real A2 learners every week. Tap a sentence to see the
correction and the reason behind it.
Trap 1 · one past word, never two
Who did break the window?
Who broke the window?
This is the mistake to design against. Who is the doer, so the question is already in statement
order and broke is already the past. Adding did puts the past in twice.
Trap 2 · What happened? keeps its ending
What did happen after the storm?
What happened after the storm?
What is the thing that did the happening, so it is the doer of the sentence. There is no other
doer for did to sit in front of.
Trap 3 · the present still needs its -s
Who live in the house on the corner?
Who lives in the house on the corner?
With no helper in the question, the verb has to show the present tense on its own — and you are asking
about one unknown person, so it takes the he/she form.
Trap 4 · do not drop the helper from a real object question
Who Ben called last night?
Who did Ben call last night?
Ben is the doer and he is already in the question, so who cannot be the doer too. As soon as
there are two of them, the helper is compulsory.
⑪ Quick test
Eight questions, no clues
No first sentence to help you this time. Find the verb, then ask yourself the only question
that matters: is the question word the one doing it? 0 / 8
Answer all eight to see how you did.
Teacher notes
Sequence (45 min): §1 read together and sell the headline, 3 min — they must hear that the
helper is missing on purpose, not by accident. §2 board work with the second table, 6 min. §3 read the four
steps aloud, then walk both worked examples with the class calling out the step numbers, 8 min. §4 alone,
then in pairs to compare reasons, 6 min. §5 the contrast on the board first, items after, 7 min. §6 cards
in pairs, spoken answer before the tap, 4 min. §7 whole class, one reader and one tapper, 4 min. §8 alone,
5 min. §9 as a race against the clock, 2 min. §10 in pairs, 3 min. §11 silent, as the exit ticket, 5 min.
The board move that works: write Rosa called Ben. and nothing else. Cover Rosa
with your hand and ask the class to read what is left — they say “called Ben”, so write Who in the
gap and read it back: Who called Ben? Nothing moved. Now uncover Rosa and cover Ben
instead. Write who in that gap and read it: Rosa called who? The class will hear that this
one only works as a surprised echo, not as a real question — and that is the moment to show the ordinary
repair. The question word runs to the front of the sentence, and
because it has left the doer behind, it has to take did with it: Who did Rosa call? The
helper is the price of moving the question word.
If a learner is stuck, stop teaching questions and go back to step 2. Give them the answer
sentence first — Greta fed the cat — and ask them to point at the word you want to hide. Point at
Greta , they build Who fed the cat? ; point at the cat , they build What did Greta
feed? Ten of those, spoken, will do more than any written exercise. The rule they need is physical: if
the hole is in front of the verb, nothing moves.
Watch for the double past in speech, not just in writing. Who did break it? is a real
English sentence with heavy stress on did — it means “somebody definitely broke it, so own up”. That
is why it never sounds wrong enough for learners to notice. Say the two versions in class and let them hear
the difference in feeling; then rule that the emphatic one is off limits until B1.
Cambridge A2 Key: subject questions turn up in Reading and Writing Part 6 and Part 7, where
candidates have to write a short message answering “who did what”, and in the Speaking test, where the
examiner’s Who lives with you? gets answered with a full sentence when a two-word answer would do.
The short-answer drill in §6 is worth as many marks as the grammar itself.
Comes from: A1-8 (subject–verb–object word order), A1-9 (question words), A1-10 (present simple
with do / does and the third person -s), A1-26 and A2-1 (past simple), A2-2 (wh-questions in the past).
Next: B1-15 (defining relative clauses — the same “who is the doer?” test decides whether the
pronoun can be dropped), B1-28 (indirect questions), B2-29 (cleft sentences: It was Rosa who called
Ben ).
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus A1–B2 · topic A2-33
Lesson Plan
- Every question has a hole; when the hole is the doer, nothing has to move
- Two pattern strips side by side: Who broke the window? against Who did you see?
- One formula for both shapes, and the rule that a question carries its tense once
Key Vocabulary
Grammar Points
- Subject question: question word + verb + the rest — no do / does / did anywhere: Who wrote this note?
- Object question: question word + do / does / did + the doer + plain verb: Who did Ben call?
- A present subject question takes the he/she form of the verb: Who lives here? What makes that noise?
- How many + a plural noun keeps the plural verb: How many children stay for lunch?
- The answer to a subject question replaces the question word in place: Rosa called Ben. → Rosa did.
- The helper returns in the negative and in the short answer, but never in the plain subject question
Prerequisites
Присоединяйтесь к нашим занятиям!
Мы верим, что правильные вопросы приносят правильные ответы. Если у вас есть вопрос о вашем пути изучения английского, мы всегда здесь для вас.
