⛔ Grammar A2-22: must / mustn’t
The twenty-second material of the Fleydo A2 grammar series, and the first of the obligation topics. It treats must and mustn’t as a single decision made in three steps: is there a rule here at all, which way does the rule point, and is the verb after the word still plain? The form is short — must never changes, takes no -s, refuses to, and builds its own negative and its own question without do or does — so the material spends its weight on meaning instead. The error it is designed against is the big one: learners read mustn’t as a gentle “no need” and drop it into sentences where nobody is stopping anything. A compare-and-verdict pair puts an order beside the opposite of an order, and a note box reads three sentences in a row so the learner hears the difference between a rule that asks, a rule that forbids, and a situation with no rule at all, where the honest word is can. Two worked examples run whole sentences through the procedure, one ending in must clip and one in mustn’t tap. Practice is spread over four sets of eight, seven, eight and eight items, each answer explaining itself, plus ten actions to sort into two bins, six signs to turn into sentences before the card opens, six real errors to repair and three traps. A four-paragraph story about a first hour at a climbing centre carries eleven tappable phrases, including one notice that prints the full must not. Teacher notes give a 45-minute sequence, a board drawing of a door with an arrow and a bolt, what to do with a learner who is stuck, the Cambridge A2 Key relevance and the hand-off to have to.
Text version of this lesson
Grammar A2-22: must / mustn’t
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus
A2
≈ 25 min
A2-22
① The idea
One word says do it . One word says never do it .
English keeps two short words for rules. must puts an action in front of you and says it has to happen. mustn’t takes the same action away and says it is not allowed. There is nothing gentle in the middle: both words are orders, and neither of them leaves you a choice.
You + must + wear a helmet .
who the rule says yes plain verb
You + mustn’t + touch the glass .
who the rule says never plain verb
the rule wants the action → subject + must + plain verb
the rule forbids the action → subject + mustn’t + plain verb
mustn’t is not a soft word. It never means “you can leave it if you like” — it means the door is shut . You mustn’t open that door carries exactly the message of a sign with a red line through it.
② The form
One shape, every person, no exceptions
This is the friendliest form of the whole A2 year. must never changes: no -s for he, she or it, no past ending, nothing. The verb that follows is the plain one you meet in a word list — go , wear , be — and no to stands in front of it.
Who The rule says do it The rule says never Asking
I I must go I mustn’t go Must I go?
you you must go you mustn’t go Must you go?
he / she / it she must go she mustn’t go Must she go?
we we must go we mustn’t go Must we go?
they they must go they mustn’t go Must they go?
a name Zola must go Zola mustn’t go Must Zola go?
subject + must + plain verb
subject + must not → mustn’t + plain verb
Must + subject + plain verb + ?
Three things to watch. First: no to after must — must wear , never “must to wear”. Second: no -s — she must go , never “she musts”. Third: no do and no does — must builds its own negative by taking not , and asks its own question by stepping to the front of the sentence. Signs and notices usually print the full must not ; in a message, a letter or a conversation you will meet mustn’t . The two are the same rule, written long and written short.
③ How to choose
Three questions, always in this order
Never choose these words by ear. Find the rule first, then read which way it points — the other half of the sentence almost always tells you, out loud.
Is there a rule here at all? A sign, a coach, a teacher, the law, a promise you made to yourself. If nobody is giving an order and the person may simply decide, stop now: neither of today’s words belongs in that sentence.
Which way does the rule point? Does it want the action to happen, or does it want the action stopped? The reason given in the sentence is your clue: a danger stops things, a need asks for them.
Choose, then build. The rule wants it → must . The rule stops it → mustn’t . After either word comes the plain verb: no to , no -s , no -ing .
Sentence
The rope is what holds you on the wall, so every climber ___ clip it before they leave the ground.
Question 1
Coach Petra runs Blue Rock and this is one of her six rules, so yes — there is a rule, and we know whose it is.
Question 2
Read the first half again: the rope is what holds you . The rule wants the clipping to happen. It points towards the action, not away from it.
Question 3
Towards the action, so must — and then the plain verb clip , with nothing at all between the two words.
Answer
Every climber must clip it before they leave the ground.
Sentence
The sign on the shark tank says: visitors ___ tap the glass.
Question 1
A sign is a rule with the words taken out, so question 1 says yes straight away.
Question 2
A sign on a tank is there to stop something happening. It points away from the action: no tapping.
Question 3
Away from the action, so mustn’t . Careful here — this does not mean that tapping is optional. The sign has shut the door on it.
Answer
Visitors mustn’t tap the glass.
④ Practice 1
The shape first
Eight items on the form alone. Say the whole sentence in your head before you tap: the wrong option is nearly always a verb wearing an extra coat. 0 / 8
⑤ The contrast
An order, and the opposite of an order
Here is the confusion that costs the marks. Learners read mustn’t as a polite “no need” and drop it into sentences where nobody is stopping anything. mustn’t is not the quiet end of must . It is the loud end.
must — the rule wants it
You must wear a helmet.
Coach Petra has ordered the action. Climb without one and you have broken her rule.
mustn’t — the rule bans it
You mustn’t climb past the blue line.
The same coach has ordered you to stop. Climb past that line and you have broken her rule just as loudly.
Verdict: both sentences are orders, and neither one hands you a choice. must orders the action; mustn’t orders you not to do it. Quick test: if you can add “… but do as you like” to the end of your sentence and it still makes sense, you have picked the wrong word.
And when nobody is giving orders?
Then the answer is neither of these two. If the person may decide, say what is allowed instead — can , it is fine to , nobody minds . Writing mustn’t there tells your reader that something is forbidden when nobody has forbidden anything.
the rule wants it → must + plain verb
the rule forbids it → mustn’t + plain verb
there is no rule → neither word: You can bring a snack.
Three sentences, read one after the other. You must bring your ticket. — no ticket, no entry. You mustn’t bring food. — food is stopped at the door. You can bring a coat. — bring one, leave it at home, nobody is watching. Only the third sentence is a free choice, and notice that it uses neither of today’s words.
Seven items on that contrast and nothing else. Read the reason inside the sentence before you choose. 0 / 7
⑥ In context
Six rules at Blue Rock
Zola and her cousin Gus climbed for the first time last Saturday. Every coloured phrase below was chosen, not guessed — tap one and read why the rule points that way.
Blue Rock opens at nine, and Coach Petra reads the same six rules to everybody who comes through the door. “You must sign the book at the desk — I need to know who is on the wall. You must wear shoes from the box by the door, because street shoes tear the holds. And you mustn’t climb above the blue line until I have watched you twice.” A notice above her head says Climbers must not use the wall alone .
Gus wanted to start straight away. “Your rope must go through both clips,” said Coach Petra, and she stood there until it did. “And while Zola is off the ground you mustn’t let go of it. Not for a second. That is the one rule with no second chance.” “ Must I tie my hair back too?” asked Gus. “Yes,” she said. “Loose hair catches in the rope.”
Rufus, the family dog, watched the whole hour from the window. Dogs mustn’t come inside at all. “He must wait in the garden,” said Gus, “and he can sleep there if he likes. Nobody minds that part.”
At half past ten Coach Petra called them down. “Chalk on your hands, not on the mats,” she said. “You mustn’t leave this place worse than you found it. And you must come back next Saturday.”
Tap any coloured phrase above. Blue = must, the rule wants the action · red = mustn’t, the rule forbids it.
⑦ Practice 2
Real places, mixed items
Harder now, and the two words are mixed with the third answer — the one for when there is no rule at all. Read the whole sentence first. 0 / 8
⑧ Read the sign
Six signs, six sentences
A sign is a rule with the words taken out. Say the whole sentence — with must or mustn’t — before you tap the card open. Commit first; the reason is worth more once you have decided.
⑨ Sort it
Coach Petra’s ten actions
You are back at Blue Rock. Tap each action and decide which word she puts in front of it. 0 / 10
must — do it
mustn’t — never do it
Start with clip the rope . Does the rule want that action, or stop it?
⑩ Fix the mistake
Six sentences to repair
Every one of these is a sentence A2 learners really write. Decide what is wrong before you tap — then read the correction and the reason underneath it.
Trap 1 · mustn’t is a ban, not a free choice
You mustn’t bring a snack — bring one if you like.
You mustn’t bring a snack. Food is not allowed in the hall.
Those two halves cannot live in one sentence. mustn’t shuts the door; “if you like” opens it again. When the choice really is free, use neither word: You can bring a snack.
Trap 2 · nothing stands between must and its verb
She musts to leave at six.
She must leave at six.
No -s , because must never changes for he, she or it. No to , because the verb after must is always the plain one: must leave , must be , must go .
Trap 3 · must builds its own negative and its own question
He doesn’t must go. · Do you must go?
He mustn’t go. · Must you go?
do and does have no work here at all. must takes not to make the negative, and steps to the front of the sentence to ask a question.
⑪ Quick test
Eight questions, no help
No hints this time. Run the three questions in your head: is there a rule, which way does it point, is the verb plain? 0 / 8
Answer all eight to see how you did.
Teacher notes
Sequence (45 min): §1 read together and sell the headline — two orders, not one order and one shrug — 3 min. §2 on the board, 5 min: the table is short, so spend the time on the three crossed-out shapes. §3 read the three questions aloud, then walk both worked examples with the class calling the question numbers back at you, 8 min. §4 alone, then pairs compare reasons, 6 min. §5 board plus the seven items, 8 min — this is the section the lesson is for. §6 whole class, one reader per paragraph, 4 min. §7 alone, 5 min. §8 in pairs, spoken sentence before the tap, 3 min. §9 as a race against the clock, 2 min. §10 pairs, 3 min. §11 silent, as the exit ticket, 5 min.
The board move that works: draw a door. Write must on an arrow pushing through it and mustn’t on a bolt across it. Then write a third line beside the door with no arrow at all and the sentence You can bring a coat . Learners who see the empty third line stop putting mustn’t where no rule exists — that single picture prevents most of the errors in §10.
If a learner is stuck, it is nearly always meaning, not form. Give them a stack of real signs (no entry, tickets here, no photographs, keep left) and ask only one question per sign: “Does this sign want something, or stop something?” Do not let them write a word until they can answer that in one breath. Form errors are cheap to repair afterwards; the meaning error is the expensive one.
Say the ban out loud. A2 learners often hear mustn’t as a weak word because it is short and unstressed in fast speech. In class, stress it hard when you model it, and ask for the whole sentence back with the same stress — the meaning travels on that stress.
Cambridge A2 Key: signs and short notices are the bread and butter of Reading Part 1, where the task is to match a notice to the sentence that means the same thing — exactly the work of §8. Rules also appear in the Speaking test whenever candidates describe a school, a club or a sport, and in Writing Part 6 emails about what somebody has to do before an event.
Comes from: A1-14 (can / can’t for permission), A1-15 (imperatives — Don’t touch! is the A1 way of writing today’s ban), A2-15 (can / could consolidation). Next: A2-23 (have to / don’t have to — keep it out of this lesson, then teach don’t have to against mustn’t as the whole point of that one), A2-24 (should / shouldn’t for advice rather than orders), later B1-14 (obligation consolidation) and B1-25, where must starts meaning “I am sure”.
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus A1–B2 · topic A2-22
Lesson Plan
- Two orders, not one order and one shrug: must asks, mustn’t forbids
- Two pattern strips and a one-line formula for each direction
Key Vocabulary
Grammar Points
- subject + must + plain verb: the rule asks for the action (Every climber must wear a helmet.)
- subject + mustn’t + plain verb: the rule forbids the action (You mustn’t climb past the line.)
- must not is the full form used on signs and notices; mustn’t is the everyday short form
- must never changes: no -s for he, she or it, and no to in front of the verb that follows
- Questions and negatives take no do or does: Must I go? · He mustn’t go.
- No rule at all needs neither word: You can bring a snack — nobody minds.
Prerequisites
Присоединяйтесь к нашим занятиям!
Мы верим, что правильные вопросы приносят правильные ответы. Если у вас есть вопрос о вашем пути изучения английского, мы всегда здесь для вас.
