💪 Grammar A2-15: can / can’t, could / couldn’t: consolidation
A1 taught the forms of can and could one at a time. This A2 consolidation teaches the choice. A four-question decision procedure runs through the whole material: am I describing or asking, is the ability now or then, who actually performs the action, and how careful do I need to be with this person. Three worked examples show the procedure running on real sentences, and a side-by-side comparison resolves the politeness pair Can you…? against the softer Could you…?, with a verdict that tells the learner which to pick when they are unsure. Thirty multiple-choice items, a ten-question sorter on who performs the action, six error corrections and three trap boxes drill the choice until it is automatic. Be able to appears only as far as A2 needs it: after will, after to, and in the fixed was able to for one past success.
Text version of this lesson
can / can’t, could / couldn’t
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus
A2
≈ 25 min
A2-15
① The idea
Two small words, three big jobs
You already know how to build a sentence with can and could . What A2 adds is the choice : the very same two words describe what a person is able to do, ask to be allowed to do something, and ask another person to do something for you. Building the sentence is no longer the hard part. Reading the situation is.
Rosa + can + climb
who · the helper word · the plain verb
Could + you + hold ?
helper word first · who · the plain verb
Job The question behind it Example
Ability What is this person able to do? Rosa can climb six metres.
Permission Am I allowed to do this? Could I try the red wall?
Request Will you do this for me? Can you hold the rope?
The whole topic in one line: can is about now, could is about then — and the moment you start asking somebody for something, could becomes the polite one instead.
② The form
The form is the easy part
Every person takes exactly the same shape. There is no -s for he or she , no to after the helper word, and no do / does / did anywhere near these two verbs.
subject + can / could + plain verb
subject + can’t / couldn’t + plain verb
Can / Could + subject + plain verb ?
Now — can Then — could
+ I / you / he / she / we / they can swim. I / you / he / she / we / they could swim.
− … can’t swim. (cannot) … couldn’t swim. (could not)
? Can she swim? Could she swim?
Short answer Yes, she can . / No, she can’t . Yes, she could . / No, she couldn’t .
The three mistakes that cost marks. ✗ She cans swim. ✗ She can to swim. ✗ She doesn’t can swim. The helper word never changes and never borrows a helper of its own. Write She can swim and She can’t swim , and the same for could .
The two shapes that do not exist
You cannot put can after will , and you cannot put it after to . Those two shapes simply do not exist in English. When you need one of them, borrow be able to — it carries the same meaning and it bends into any shape you like.
will be able to + plain verb → Next year I’ll be able to dive.
want to be able to + plain verb → I want to be able to cook.
One more use, then leave it alone. For one difficult thing that somebody really managed on one occasion, English prefers was / were able to : The lift was broken, but Rosa was able to carry the case up six floors. Everywhere else at this level, could is still your word.
③ How to choose
Four questions, in this order
Run these in your head before you write anything. Almost every wrong answer at A2 comes from skipping question 1 and guessing between can and could as if the choice were only about time.
Am I describing, or am I asking? If the sentence tells you what somebody is able to do, it is ability and it ends with a full stop. If it asks somebody for something, it is permission or a request , and it ends with a question mark.
Ability — now or then? Now, today, always, these days → can / can’t . A finished past time — when I was six, last year, the room was dark → could / couldn’t .
Asking — who does the action? If I do it, I am asking to be allowed: Can I…? / Could I…? If the other person does it, it is a request: Can you…? / Could you…?
How careful do I need to be? A friend and a two-second favour → can . A teacher, a stranger, or a favour that costs somebody real time → could . Could is never rude. Can sometimes is.
Worked example 1
Sentence
Ines is carrying two trays. She turns to Ms Verner: “___ open the door for me, please?”
Step 1
Nobody is describing a skill. Ines wants something, and the line ends with a question mark → asking . Skip step 2.
Step 3
Ms Verner does the opening — Ines has no free hands. The action belongs to the other person → you .
Step 4
A teacher, and the favour costs her a walk to the door → the softer word.
Answer
Could you open the door for me, please?
Worked example 2
Sentence
Rosa ___ swim one length at six. Now she swims a kilometre.
Step 1
It describes what Rosa was able to do, and it ends with a full stop → ability .
Step 2
“at six” names a finished time, and the second sentence contrasts it with now → the past form.
Answer
Rosa could swim one length at six.
Worked example 3
Sentence
Malik leans across to Theo at the next desk: “___ pass me the glue?”
Step 1
He is asking, not describing → skip step 2.
Step 3
Theo has the glue and Theo passes it → you .
Step 4
A friend at the next desk, and the favour lasts one second → the direct word is friendly here, not rude.
Answer
Can you pass me the glue?
④ Practice 1
Ability now, ability then
Eight sentences, easiest first. Look for the time words before you choose. 0 / 8
⑤ The contrast
Can you…? or Could you…?
Both are correct English, and both ask for the same thing. The difference is not grammar — it is distance. Could steps back half a pace and leaves the other person room to say no.
Can you …?
Can you hold the rope?
Direct and friendly. Right for a classmate, a brother, a teammate — somebody you speak to every day — and for a favour that costs two seconds. Said to a stranger, the same words can land like an instruction.
Could you …?
Could you hold the rope?
Softer. It sounds less like an order and more like a genuine question, so it fits a teacher, a stranger, any adult you do not know, and any favour that costs real time or effort.
Verdict: when you are not sure, choose could . It is never too polite, and nobody has ever been annoyed by it. Keep can for the people you know well. Permission works in exactly the same way: Can I…? among friends, Could I…? with everybody else.
Six situations. Read who is speaking to whom before you choose. 0 / 6
⑥ In context
Ten minutes at the climbing wall
All three jobs, inside one short conversation. Tap any coloured word to read why the speaker chose it.
ability permission or request
— Ms Verner, could I try the red wall today?
— Let me see. Can you reach the third hold?
— I think so. In September I couldn’t get past the second one, but I can now.
— Good. Malik, could you hold the rope for her?
— Yes. Can I use the blue harness?
— That one is broken. Theo can’t use it either.
— One more thing. Could you check my knot, please?
— Always. And keep training: next spring you will be able to lead the black wall on your own.
Tap a coloured word above.
⑦ Practice 2
All three jobs, mixed
Harder now: the time words are hidden inside the story, and asking and describing sit side by side. 0 / 8
⑧ Sort it
Who does the action?
This single question decides between I and you , and it is where most marks are lost. Tap each question and send it to the right box. 0 / 10
Permission — I do it
Request — you do it
Start with the first one. Who actually performs the action?
⑨ Fix the mistake
Six sentences an A2 learner really writes
Tap each one to see the correction and the reason behind it.
⑩ Watch out
Three confusions worth watching
Could you is not Could I
✗ Could you borrow your pen? This asks whether the other person is able to borrow their own pen, which makes no sense.
✓ Could I borrow your pen? The borrowing is yours, so the question turns to I . Ask who moves, and the word chooses itself.
Could is not always the past
Could you open the window? has nothing to do with yesterday. In a question aimed at another person, could carries politeness, not time.
Could only points backwards in a statement about ability: I couldn’t swim at five. Check the punctuation mark at the end before you decide.
Answer a request in the present
✗ A: Could you help me? B: No, I couldn’t. That answers a question about the past, which nobody asked.
✓ A: Could you help me? B: Sorry, I can’t. The request is about right now, so the refusal is about right now too.
⑪ Quick test
Eight questions, no hints
Run the four questions from §3 in your head on every item. 0 / 8
Answer all eight to see your result.
Teacher notes
Sequence (45 min): §1–2 on the board, 7 min — the table is revision, so move fast and do not re-teach it. §3, the four questions, 6 min: write them on the board and leave them there for the rest of the lesson. §4 alone, then compared in pairs, 8 min. §5 the politeness pair, 6 min, acted out rather than explained. §6 read aloud in threes, one voice each, 5 min. §7 and §8, 8 min. §9 as a board race, 3 min. §11 silent, as the exit ticket.
The board move that works: two columns headed I do it and you do it . Every question the class produces goes into one of them before anybody worries about can or could. Nearly every error at this level is a learner who has not decided who performs the action.
Politeness is a role-play, not a rule. Hand the same request to two learners — one asking a friend, one asking the head teacher — and let the class hear the difference. A2 learners rarely believe the rule until they hear the direct version aimed at a stranger.
If a learner freezes, take the choice away: give ten sentences that are all ability and ask only now or then? Once that runs without thinking, put the asking half back. Three jobs at once is what causes the freeze, not the forms themselves.
Cambridge A2 Key relevance: Reading and Writing Part 6 asks for a short message that very often contains a request, and Could you…? reads better there than the direct version. Speaking Part 2 rewards the same choice when learners ask each other for information.
Keep be able to small. At A2 it is needed only after will , after to , and in the fixed was able to for one past success. The full contrast with could belongs to B1 — do not open it here.
Follow-up: A2-16 (so, because, when, before, after), A2-17 (will / won’t for offers and promises), then the B1 obligation verbs.
Printing: the browser’s print command hides the buttons and opens every correction, so this page prints straight out as a worksheet.
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus A1–B2 · topic A2-15
Lesson Plan
- Two words doing three jobs: ability, permission, request
- The two pattern strips: Rosa + can + climb / Could + you + hold?
- A table of the three jobs and the question behind each one
Key Vocabulary
Grammar Points
- subject + can / could + plain verb — no -s, no to, no do / does / did
- can / can’t for ability now; could / couldn’t for ability in a finished past time
- Can I…? / Could I…? asks permission for your own action; Can you…? / Could you…? asks another person to act
- could as politeness, not past time, in a question aimed at another person
- will be able to and to be able to fill the shapes can does not have
- was / were able to for one difficult thing somebody managed on one occasion
Prerequisites
Unisciti alle Nostre Lezioni!
Crediamo che le domande giuste portino le risposte giuste. Se hai domande sul tuo percorso di apprendimento, siamo sempre qui per te.
