📖 Lesson A2 Grammar📐 Grammar

💡 Grammar A2-24: should / shouldn’t

The twenty-fourth material of the Fleydo A2 grammar series, and the third of three about how hard a sentence pushes. It treats should as a decision about power rather than about grammar: if the listener can say no and no rule is broken, the sentence takes should; if a law, a sign, a timetable or a person in charge decides instead, it takes must or have to from A2-22 and A2-23. A four-question procedure runs that test, chooses between should and shouldn’t, decides whether advice is being given or asked for, and ends by insisting on the bare verb. Three worked examples walk whole situations through it, one positive, one negative and one turning into a question. A compare-and-verdict pair sets a jacket you may leave at home against a helmet you may not, and a three-step scale separates shouldn’t from mustn’t from don’t have to, because those three negatives mean three different things and learners routinely swap them. A full section is given to Should I…? and to the answer shapes that come back, from a bare Yes, you should to the far more common I don’t think you should. Practice is spread over four sets of eight, seven, eight and eight items, each one explaining its own answer, plus ten situations to sort by who decides, six reveal cards of real teenage problems, six errors to repair and three traps. A tap-and-explain group chat about a sore knee shows advice and club rules working side by side in one conversation. Teacher notes give a 45-minute sequence, a board line from you decide to somebody else decides, what to do with a stuck learner, the two errors to name out loud, and the Cambridge A2 Key relevance.

🧒 Kids (6–10) 🎒 Teens (11–16) 25 min Medium 27
FREE
Text version of this lesson

Grammar A2-24: should / shouldn’t

Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus

A2

≈ 25 min

A2-24

① The idea

Advice you can take — or leave .

When you tell somebody what you think is a good idea, English hands you one small word: should . It gives no orders. It says “this is the sensible thing to do here” and then puts the decision straight back into the listener’s hands, where it stays. They are free to say no, and quite often they will.

You + should + rest

who should / shouldn’t the plain verb

advice → subject + should + verb

advice against → subject + shouldn’t + verb

asking for advice → Should + subject + verb + ?

The word straight after should is the whole test. It stays plain: She should rest. Never “shoulds”, never “to rest”, never “resting”. should itself never changes for anybody, and the verb behind it never changes either.

② The form

One shape for everybody

This is the calmest form in the whole A2 course, because almost nothing moves. Every person takes the same word. The negative is that word plus not . The question is the same sentence with should pulled to the front. Read the table down the columns and count how few changes there are — the answer is none.

Person Advice Advice against Asking

I I should ask. I shouldn’t ask. Should I ask?

you You should ask. You shouldn’t ask. Should you ask?

he / she / it She should ask. She shouldn’t ask. Should she ask?

we We should ask. We shouldn’t ask. Should we ask?

they They should ask. They shouldn’t ask. Should they ask?

Three things that never happen with this word. It takes no -s , not even for he, she and it: he should , and “he shoulds” does not exist. The verb behind it takes no to : should see a doctor , not “should to see”. And neither the question nor the negative wants do or does : Should I go? and I shouldn’t go , never “Do I should go?”. The long form of shouldn’t is should not , which you write when the advice is serious or when you are writing carefully.

③ How to choose

Four questions before you write

Choosing should is not really a grammar decision at all — it is a decision about who is in charge of what happens next. Ask these four questions in this order and the sentence more or less writes itself.

Can the person say no? If they can refuse and no rule is broken, you are giving advice, and advice is what should is for. If a law, a timetable, a sign or a teacher decides it instead, you need must or have to .

Do I want them to do it, or not do it? Do it → should . Not do it → shouldn’t . Put the negative inside that one word and nowhere else in the sentence.

Am I giving the advice or asking for it? Giving it → the person comes first. Asking for it → should comes first: Should I …?

Write the verb plain. Whichever of the three you chose, the very next word is the bare verb: no -s , no to , no -ing .

Situation

Elias has a headache after training and I want to tell him what to do about it.

Question 1

Nobody on earth can make Elias drink a glass of water. He can shrug and walk away, and no rule has been broken — so this is advice, not obligation.

Question 2

I want him to do it rather than avoid it, so the positive word: should .

Question 3

I am the one giving the advice, so Elias goes first in the sentence and should follows him.

Answer

You should drink some water. The verb is bare drink — should to drink and should drinking are both dead ends.

Situation

Dara wants to climb the wet rock behind the club hut, and I think that is a bad idea.

Question 1

No sign, no rule, no teacher. Dara can ignore me completely, so we are still in the advice family.

Question 2

This time I want her not to do it. That single change flips the word to shouldn’t , and the rest of the sentence stays exactly as it was.

Question 4

Bare verb after it: climb . No to , no -ing , and no second negative word anywhere.

Answer

You shouldn’t climb it today. Watch the trap: You don’t should climb it puts the negative outside the word, and English never does that here.

Situation

I cannot decide whether to tell Coach Rivera about my sore knee, and I want Dara’s opinion.

Question 3

I am asking for advice, not giving it, so the order turns around: should jumps to the front and the person follows behind it.

Question 4

Then the plain verb, tell . And no do anywhere in sight — should is already doing the question’s work.

Answer

Should I tell Coach Rivera about my knee? A useful answer comes back in the same shape: Yes, I think you should.

④ Practice 1

The form, eight times

Nothing tricky here — just the shape. Before you tap, say the whole sentence in your head and listen for the bare verb. 0 / 8

⑤ How strong is it?

Advice you can refuse, rules you cannot

You met must in A2-22 and have to in A2-23. All three words push somebody towards an action, but they do not push with the same force, and picking the wrong one changes what your sentence claims about the world.

should — you decide

You should take a jacket.

I think it is a good idea. You can leave the jacket on your bed and nothing official happens to you — you simply get cold on the way home. The decision was yours the whole time and it still is.

have to / must — somebody else decides

You have to wear a helmet.

The club rule says so. Your opinion is not part of the sentence: without a helmet you do not climb, and nobody is offering you a way out of it.

Verdict: ask one question — who decides? If the listener decides, write should . If a law, a sign, a timetable or a person in charge decides, write must or have to . Using should for a law is not a small slip: it quietly tells your reader that the law is optional.

should / shouldn’t Advice. A good idea, or a bad one. Your listener can still say no, and that is allowed.

have to / don’t have to A rule from outside you. Don’t have to is the free one: there is no rule, so do it or don’t.

must / mustn’t The heaviest. Mustn’t is a wall — it means never, and it comes with no exceptions.

The two negatives are not neighbours. You shouldn’t eat that means it is a bad idea and you will probably regret it. You mustn’t eat that means do not, ever, and somebody will stop you. Then there is don’t have to , which forbids nothing at all: it says no rule exists, so you are free either way. Three negatives, three completely different worlds.

Seven sentences on that scale and nothing else. Each time, find who is really deciding. 0 / 7

⑥ Asking for advice

Should I …? — and what comes back

Half of this topic is asking, not telling, and that is the half nobody practises. Turn the sentence around — should first, the person second, the plain verb third — and you have the most useful question in the language for anybody with a problem and no idea what to do about it.

Should + I / we / he + verb + ?

What / Where / Who + should + I + verb + ?

The question Answering yes Answering no

Should I call her? Yes, you should. No, you shouldn’t.

Should I call her? Yes, I think you should. No, I don’t think you should.

Should we wait here? Yes, definitely. No, I wouldn’t.

What should I say? You should tell her the truth. · I’d say sorry first.

The softer answer is the more useful one. A bare No, you shouldn’t can land quite hard. Put I think or I don’t think in front of it and the advice turns back into an opinion, which is what it always was. Notice where the negative goes: I don’t think you should is far more common than putting the not on the second verb, and it sounds friendlier as well.

Six problems from the climbing club. Say your advice out loud before you tap the card — a card you have not answered first teaches you nothing.

⑦ In context

Nine o’clock in the club group chat

Real advice, real rules, mixed together the way they always are. Every coloured word was chosen on purpose — tap one and read why.

Dara wrote to the climbing club group at half past nine. “My knee has been sore since Saturday. Should I tell Coach Rivera, or is that making a fuss about nothing?”

Nia answered in about four seconds. “Of course you should tell him. And you shouldn’t climb on it tonight, whatever he says. My cousin waited three weeks with a sore ankle and then had to rest for two months.”

Elias was less sure. “ Should we say something tonight, or shouldn’t we wait until Friday? What should I write to him?”

Coach Rivera read all of it at ten. “Thank you, Dara. Two different things here, so let me separate them. Every member must report an injury on the same day. That is the club rule, not my opinion, and you also have to fill in the yellow form before you train again.”

“The rest is only advice. You should rest it completely this weekend, and you shouldn’t use the stairs at school if there is a lift. You don’t have to come on Saturday at all — but if you do come, you mustn’t touch the wall. And Elias, you shouldn’t worry about writing anything clever. ‘My knee hurts’ is a perfect message.”

Tap any coloured word above. Blue = should, advice or a question · orange = shouldn’t, advice against · dark red = must / have to, where nobody has a choice.

⑧ Practice 2

Advice and rules, mixed

Harder now, because the sentence around the gap is what decides it. Read to the end of the line before you choose, and look for the words that say who is in charge. 0 / 8

⑨ Sort it

Whose decision is it?

Question 1 of the procedure, ten times over. Tap each one and drop it into the box where it belongs. 0 / 10

advice — should / shouldn’t

no choice — must / have to

Start with drink more water . Ask yourself: if I refuse, does anybody stop me?

⑩ Fix the mistake

Six sentences to repair

Every one of these is a sentence A2 learners really write. Read it, decide what is wrong, then tap it for the correction and the reason.

Trap 1 · no -s, and no to

She shoulds to rest her knee.

She should rest her knee.

Two separate mistakes in four words. should is the same for every person, and the verb behind it is always bare. Say the pair together — should rest , should go , should ask — until anything else sounds odd.

Trap 2 · questions turn round; they never take do

Do I should call him? · What I should say?

Should I call him? · What should I say?

should is already the question word, so do has nothing to do and is not invited. In a wh-question the order is fixed: question word, should , person, plain verb.

Trap 3 · advice is not a rule

You should wear a seatbelt — it’s the law.

You must wear a seatbelt — it’s the law.

The grammar of the first sentence is perfect and the meaning is wrong. should always leaves the listener a way out, so putting it next to a law tells your reader the law is a suggestion. Laws, signs and safety rules take must or have to .

⑪ Quick test

Eight questions, no hints

No help in the sentences this time. Run the four questions in your head, starting with the only one that matters: who decides? 0 / 8

Answer all eight to see how you did.

Teacher notes

Sequence (45 min): §1 read aloud, 3 min — sell the idea that this word hands the decision back, or the class will treat it as a weak must all lesson. §2 board, 5 min: build the table live and let them tell you what changes. §3 read the four questions, then walk all three worked examples with the class calling out the question numbers, 8 min. §4 alone, 6 min. §5 is the heart of the lesson — 9 min, board first, items second. §6 in pairs, spoken advice before every tap, 6 min. §7 whole class on the screen, 4 min. §8 alone, 5 min. §9 as a race in teams, 2 min. §10 in pairs, 3 min. §11 silent, as the exit ticket, 5 min. Drop §9 before you drop §5.

The board move that works: draw a line across the board with you decide at one end and somebody else decides at the other. Write one situation — wear a helmet — and ask where it goes; then move it by changing only the context (at the climbing club, on a bike in the garden, in a car). The class sees that nothing about the action changed, only who is in charge, and that is precisely what chooses the word. Keep the line on the board for A2-25 next lesson.

If a learner is stuck, it is almost never the form — this form has nothing to learn. It is question 1. Give them ten situations orally and ask only can you say no? , with no English sentence at the end. Once the sorting is automatic, the word chooses itself. The second most common sticking point is the question shape: drill Should I …? as a chant with five verbs before you let anyone write it.

Watch for two errors in particular: Do you should …? from learners who over-apply the present simple question, and You should to go from learners who have just done want / would like + to. Both are worth naming on the board as “the two most popular mistakes in this room” — naming them halves them.

Cambridge A2 Key: advice appears in Reading and Writing Part 6, where the task is often to write a short message telling a friend what to do, and should is the single most useful word for it. Examiners also see must and should swapped in Part 5. In Speaking Part 2, candidates who can ask Should I …? keep the conversation moving instead of waiting to be asked.

Comes from: A2-15 (can / can’t, could / couldn’t — the same bare verb behind the word), A2-22 (must / mustn’t), A2-23 (have to / don’t have to). Next: A2-25 (Shall I …?, How about …?, Why don’t we …? — suggestions, which sit right beside advice), then B1-14 (obligation consolidation) and B1-26 (should have + past participle, for the advice that arrives too late).

Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus A1–B2 · topic A2-24

Lesson Plan

  • should gives advice and then hands the decision straight back to the listener
  • The three shapes in one formula: advice, advice against, asking for advice

Key Vocabulary

shouldshouldn’tshould notadvicemustmustn’thave todon’t have toa good ideaI thinkI don’t thinkruleapologiserest

Grammar Points

  • should + bare verb, identical for every person: I should ask, she should ask
  • shouldn’t = should not; the negative sits inside the word, never as don’t should
  • Questions invert instead of using do: Should I go? · What should I say?
  • Answer shapes: Yes, you should · No, you shouldn’t · I don’t think you should
  • should is advice the listener may refuse; must / have to leave no choice at all
  • shouldn’t (bad idea) against mustn’t (never) against don’t have to (no rule, free)

انضم إلى صفوفنا!

نؤمن بأن الأسئلة الصحيحة تجلب الإجابات الصحيحة. نحن دائمًا هنا من أجلك.

تطبيق الهاتف

Fleydo English School في جيبكم

الدروس والواجبات والرسائل والألعاب لطلاب Fleydo وأولياء أمورهم. مجاني على iPhone وAndroid.

نزّله من App Storeاحصل عليه من Google Play
المزيد عن التطبيق
رمز QR يفتح تطبيق Fleydo English School في App Store أو Google Playامسحوا الرمز للتحميليفتح المتجر المناسب لهاتفكم.fleydo.com/app
FleyPath

خريطة طريق شخصية لطفلك — 3 أو 6 أو 12 شهرًا

🚀البداية
👋Hello
😊Body
🦁Animals
🔢Numbers
🏆إنجليزية واثقة
تدريب على الإنجليزية بأسلوب الألعاب

مثل اللعبة — لكنهم يتعلمون فعلًا