📖 Lesson B1 Grammar📐 Grammar

🕵️ Grammar B1-25: Modals of deduction (present)

The twenty-fifth material of the Fleydo B1 grammar series turns the learner into a detective: every modal of deduction is a verdict resting on a piece of evidence. must says the facts allow exactly one answer — the lights are off, so they must be out; might, may and could say several answers are still alive; can’t says the evidence rules this one out — that can’t be Jess, she’s at the dentist. The teaching hangs on one scale with two sure ends and a maybe middle, and on the asymmetry that costs B1 marks every year: the opposite of must be is can’t be, while mustn’t stays in the rulebook giving orders. A four-question decision routine — find the evidence, count the explanations, keep the middle words while several survive, use can’t when a door shuts — is walked through three worked runs, one of them adding be + -ing for deductions about actions happening right now, such as she must be sleeping. Six evidence cards make the learner commit to a verdict before checking, a knock-at-the-door compare puts must be and can’t be side by side, and a note separates the weak no, might not, from the strong no, can’t. Practice is spread across four sets of eight, seven, eight and eight items — every stem carrying its own clue and every answer explaining its reason — plus ten pieces of evidence to sort by how many answers they allow, six real learner errors to repair and three traps led by mustn’t invading the deduction scale. A 130-word missing-cake mystery gives eight tappable verdicts, each pointing at the evidence it rests on. Teacher notes add a 45-minute sequence, the certainty-line board move with mustn’t exiled to a RULES box, a physical rescue drill, Cambridge B1 Preliminary relevance and a preview of past deduction at B2-7.

🎒 Teens (11–16) 🧑‍💼 Adults (17+) 30 min Challenging 13
FREE
Text version of this lesson

Grammar B1-25: Modals of deduction (present)

Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus

B1

≈ 30 min

B1-25

① The idea

Someone must be inside. It might be Ms Hale. It can’t be Liam.

Detective grammar. You cannot see who is in the storeroom — but you can see the light under the door, and the light is evidence . must , might , may , could and can’t are the verdicts English attaches to evidence: must says the facts allow only one answer, might / may / could say several answers still fit, and can’t says the facts rule this one out. None of them reports what is happening — they report how sure you are.

Someone + must + be inside

the subject the verdict word the bare verb — no to, no -s

They + must / might / can’t + be eating

any subject, same modal any strength of verdict be + -ing for an action happening right now

only one answer fits → must + verb → The lights are off — they must be out.

several answers fit → might / may / could + verb → She might be at choir. He could be on the bus.

the evidence says no → can’t + verb → That can’t be Jess — she’s at the dentist.

must be and can’t be are the two ends of one scale: completely sure it’s true, completely sure it’s false. The middle belongs to might , may and could . And the opposite of must be is can’t be — mustn’t never joins this scale. It stays in the rulebook.

② The form

One machine, three strengths

Every deduction has the same skeleton: subject + modal + bare verb. The modal never changes for the person — I must, she must, they must — and nothing squeezes in between the modal and its verb. What changes is only the strength of the verdict.

Verdict How sure? Example

must + verb sure it’s true — the evidence allows one answer You’ve been up since five — you must be exhausted.

might / may / could + verb not sure — several answers still fit She might be at choir. He may be asleep. It could be anyone.

can’t + verb sure it’s false — the evidence rules it out That can’t be Erin’s bag — hers is blue.

After the modal Shape Example

a description or a name modal + be + adjective / noun He must be the new coach. You can’t be serious.

a place modal + be + place She can’t be at home — the car’s gone.

an action happening right now modal + be + -ing They might be waiting outside. She must be sleeping .

any other verb modal + bare verb She must know the answer. They must have a key.

When a detective wants to ask instead of answer, the question runs on could : Who could it be? Could it be Ms Hale? — must and can’t rarely ask. They deliver.

The classic slips: He must to be tired. She musts be nervous. They must are hungry. A modal bolts straight onto the bare verb — no to , no -s , no am / is / are beside it: he must be tired, she must be nervous, they must be hungry . One skeleton serves every person from I to they.

③ How to choose

The detective’s four questions

Never start from the modal — start from the evidence. Run these four questions and the verdict chooses itself.

Find the evidence. The fact you can point at: the light, the locked door, the timetable, the message from the airport. No evidence, no deduction — a verdict without evidence is just a guess.

Count the explanations. How many answers does the evidence allow? If everything points one way and nothing points anywhere else, the verdict is must .

More than one answer still alive? Then the verdict is might , may or could — three words, one middle strength. This could is not the past of can: it is today’s maybe.

Does the evidence shut a door? When the facts rule an idea out, the verdict is can’t . Last check: if the deduction is about an action happening at this moment, follow the modal with be + -ing — she must be sleeping.

Situation

Seven in the morning. The gym lights are on, and Coach’s car is the only one in the car park.

Evidence

Lights on, plus exactly one car — and it’s his. Point at both.

Count

Who turned the lights on? Every explanation except Coach has already driven out of the car park. One answer survives.

Verdict

One answer → must : Coach must be in the gym.

Situation

Jess hasn’t answered a message all afternoon.

Evidence

It’s Thursday, four o’clock. Thursday means choir — but her bus also loses signal in the tunnel, and she sometimes naps after school.

Count

Three explanations, all still alive. The evidence narrows nothing down to one.

Verdict

Several answers → the middle words: she might be at choir, she could be on the bus, she may be asleep. All three carry the same weight.

Situation

Piano music is coming from the music room. Liam says: “That’s Owen showing off again.”

Evidence

You walked Owen to the gym ten minutes ago and watched the door close behind him.

Count

For “it’s Owen”, the evidence doesn’t just fail to help — it says no. That idea is ruled out. And whoever it really is, the music is happening right now.

Verdict

Ruled out → can’t : it can’t be Owen. And about the mystery pianist, an action-now verdict: they must be practising for the concert — be + -ing.

Now you deliver the verdict

Six pieces of evidence. Say the verdict out loud — must, might / could, or can’t — then tap the card to check yourself.

④ Practice 1

Verdicts and the bare verb

Eight to start. Find the evidence in each sentence first — it is always there — then let it choose the modal. 0 / 8

⑤ The contrast

The opposite of must be is can’t be

Here is the asymmetry that costs B1 marks every year. One knock at the door, two verdicts — and the word that looks like the negative of must is not on the scale at all.

must be — the evidence says yes

That must be Jess — she said eight, and it’s eight exactly.

Everything points one way: the arrangement, the clock, the knock. When only one answer survives, the verdict is a confident yes.

can’t be — the evidence says no

That can’t be Jess — she’s at the dentist till nine.

The same knock, one new fact — and the idea is dead. When the evidence rules an answer out, the verdict is a confident no.

Verdict: must be and can’t be are one machine running in opposite directions — both completely sure, one sure-yes, one sure-no. So the opposite of must be is can’t be . mustn’t be is not its negative: mustn’t lives in the rulebook — You mustn’t be late — and a rule cannot judge who is knocking at a door.

Where does mustn’t live, then? In orders and rules about behaviour: Passengers mustn’t open the doors. You mustn’t be late tomorrow. It tells people what not to do; it never weighs evidence. If you catch yourself writing mustn’t be as a conclusion, swap it for can’t be and the sentence snaps into place. English also has a weak no: might not — She might not be home means perhaps she isn’t. can’t is the strong no: impossible.

Seven items on exactly this, and nothing else. 0 / 7

⑥ In context

The case of the missing cake

Every coloured verdict below rests on a piece of evidence in the text. Tap one and read what it rests on.

Friday, ten past three. The end-of-term cake has vanished from the art room, and Erin has ten minutes. The door was locked all lunchtime and nothing is broken, so the thief must have a key . That leaves Mr Frost, Ms Hale or a monitor.

“It might be Frost — he loves lemon cake,” says Liam. Erin points at the window: Frost has been painting the fence since twelve. “It can’t be him . Ms Hale skipped the meeting, so she could be here — and a monitor may know something .” Then Jess spots the storeroom light. Someone must be in there — and from the clinking, they must be eating .

The door opens: Ms Hale, plate in hand. “It was melting in the sun, so I moved it. A thief? You can’t be serious .”

Tap any coloured verdict above. Blue = must (one answer) · green = might / may / could (several) · orange = can’t (ruled out).

⑦ Practice 2

Verdicts in the wild

Harder now: actions in progress, clues that disagree, and the weak no against the strong no. The evidence is still in every stem. 0 / 8

⑧ Sort it

One answer, or several?

Ten pieces of evidence, no modals in sight. For each one, count the explanations it allows — that count is the whole decision. 0 / 10

must — only one answer fits

might / could — several answers fit

Start anywhere: read the evidence, count the explanations, then tap the chip.

⑨ Fix the mistake

Six verdicts to repair

Every line below comes straight from real B1 writing. Tap a sentence to see the repair and the reason.

⑩ Watch out

Three traps that cost marks

Each box shows the sentence that feels right first — and the one that is.

Trap 1 · The opposite of must be is can’t be

She mustn’t be at school — her bike is still here.

She can’t be at school — her bike is still here.

mustn’t makes rules about behaviour — You mustn’t run by the pool — and it has no power over evidence. When the facts say no, the verdict word is can’t . must be and can’t be are the two ends of one scale, and mustn’t be is simply not on it.

Trap 2 · Nothing squeezes in beside the modal

He must to be exhausted after that match.

He must be exhausted after that match.

No to , no -s , no is : the modal takes the bare verb directly. The same rule kills she musts be and they must are — one unchanging modal, then the verb, for every person in the language.

Trap 3 · can is not a verdict

That can be Jess at the door.

That could be Jess at the door.

can states what is generally possible — anyone can knock at a door. For a verdict about one particular moment, English steps sideways to could or might : that could be Jess, right now. Keep can for ability and general truth; give the guessing to could.

⑪ Quick test

Eight verdicts, no help

No hints this time — just evidence. Count the explanations, then commit. 0 / 8

Answer all eight to see your verdict.

Teacher notes

Sequence (45 min): §1 read the hero aloud and sell the scale — sure-yes, maybe, sure-no — 4 min. §2 board the two tables and drill the skeleton chorally: must be, might be, can’t be — no to, no -s, 6 min. §3 walk the four questions, then the three worked runs with the class calling the verdict before you reveal it; the six cards in pairs, spoken verdict before the tap, 9 min. §4 alone, 5 min. §5 the knock-at-the-door compare, then the mustn’t note — the heart of the lesson, 5 min. §6 whole class, tap and read, 4 min. §7 alone, then pairs compare reasons, 5 min. §8 as a race, 2 min. §9 in pairs, 3 min. §10 read aloud, 2 min. §11 silent, as the exit ticket, 3 min.

The board move that works: draw one horizontal line. Write can’t at the far left, must at the far right, and might / may / could bunched in the middle; label the ends sure it’s false and sure it’s true. Then write mustn’t on the board and let someone try to place it — and physically move it off the line into a box marked RULES. For the rest of the course, every mustn’t-as-verdict error can be corrected by silently pointing at the box.

If a learner is stuck, the rescue is one question: “How many answers does the evidence allow?” Make it physical — one finger up for must, five spread fingers for might / could, arms crossed for can’t. If mustn’t keeps invading conclusions, ask “Is anyone giving an order?” — the no sends them back to can’t. If be keeps vanishing before -ing, drill the chunk must-be-doing as one beat.

Cambridge B1 Preliminary: Speaking Part 2 (photo description) is where this grammar pays live — examiners reward hedged deduction, he might be waiting for someone, they could be celebrating , over flat present tenses. In Reading, the four-option grammar items regularly bait mustn’t where can’t is the key.

Comes from: A2-22 (must / mustn’t as obligation — the rulebook meaning this lesson keeps at arm’s length), B1-13 (may / might for future possibility) and B1-14 (obligation consolidation). Next: B1-26 (modal perfects) starts the past machinery, and B2-7 turns these same three verdicts to face the past — must have been, might have been, can’t have been. A thirty-second preview for fast finishers: the scale survives, only the time changes.

Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus A1–B2 · topic B1-25

Lesson Plan

  • Three verdicts on one scale: sure-yes must, middle might / may / could, sure-no can’t
  • Two pattern strips: modal + bare verb, and be + -ing for an action happening right now
  • A three-line formula tying each verdict to how many answers the evidence allows

Key Vocabulary

mustmightmaycouldcan’tevidenceverdictsuspectcaretakerstoreroomstaff meetinglost property

Grammar Points

  • must + bare verb for a sure yes — the evidence allows one answer: The lights are off — they must be out.
  • might / may / could + bare verb when several answers still fit: She might be at choir. He could be on the bus.
  • can’t + bare verb for a sure no — the evidence rules it out: That can’t be Jess — she’s at the dentist.
  • modal + be + -ing for deductions about actions in progress: They must be rehearsing. She must be sleeping.
  • The opposite of must be is can’t be — mustn’t gives orders about behaviour and never weighs evidence
  • might not is the weak no (perhaps not); can’t is the strong no (impossible)

Приєднуйтеся до наших груп!

Ми віримо, що правильні запитання приносять правильні відповіді. Чи маєте ви запитання про свій шлях вивчення англійської, чи потребуєте допомоги з певною мовною навичкою — ми завжди поруч.

Мобільний застосунок

Fleydo English School у вашій кишені

Уроки, домашні завдання, повідомлення та ігри для учнів Fleydo та їхніх батьків. Безкоштовно на iPhone та Android.

Завантажте в App StoreЗавантажити з Google Play
Докладніше про застосунок
QR-код, що відкриває застосунок Fleydo English School в App Store або Google PlayСкануйте й завантажуйтеВідкриє потрібний магазин для вашого телефона.fleydo.com/app
FleyPath

Персональна дорожня карта вашої дитини — 3, 6 або 12 місяців

🚀Старт
👋Hello
😊Body
🦁Animals
🔢Numbers
🏆Упевнена англійська
Гейміфікована практика англійської

Як гра — тільки вони справді вчаться