🔗 Grammar B1-15: Defining relative clauses
The fifteenth material of the Fleydo B1 grammar series teaches the defining relative clause as a label glued straight onto a noun — no clause, no idea which one. The opening pair of cards makes the stakes plain: I talked to the girl points at nobody, I talked to the girl who sits behind me finds her. The word kit is a five-row table — who for people, which for things and animals, that as the everyday all-rounder, whose for the owner, where for places — with the warning that what is never on the team and that where, meaning in which, refuses a second in or at. A four-question decision list picks the word, rescues learners from the where-as-subject trap, and sets up the heart of the material: the one-glance test. Read the word straight after the pronoun — a verb next means the pronoun is the subject and must stay, a new person or thing next means the clause has its own subject and the pronoun may silently vanish: the film we watched, but always the man who called. Two worked runs walk the glance step by step, a compare-and-verdict pair fixes it, and a twelve-label sorter drills stay against vanish. A 129-word tap-and-explain text about Astrid’s best friend, a climbing wall, a café owner and his old dog shows kept, dropped and specialist labels working in prose, and a six-card definitions game turns the grammar into play. Practice runs to thirty-one explained multiple-choice items in four sets, plus six repairs of real learner sentences — the doubled pronoun, the vanished subject, which for a person, everything what, where as a subject, and commas around a defining clause. Teacher notes give a 45-minute sequence, the arrow board move, the crossing-out rescue for the double pronoun, and Cambridge B1 Preliminary relevance.
Text version of this lesson
Grammar B1-15: Defining relative clauses
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus
B1
≈ 30 min
B1-15
① The idea
Which girl? The girl who sits behind me
Say I talked to the girl and your friend leans in at once: which girl? English answers with a label — a little sentence glued straight onto the noun: the girl who sits behind me . A little sentence living inside a bigger one is called a clause , and this kind, the kind whose whole job is to say which one , is a defining relative clause . Cut the label off and the sentence points at nobody.
Without the label
I talked to the girl.
Which girl? The canteen is full of girls.
The sentence is perfectly grammatical — and useless. It points at nobody in particular.
With the label
I talked to the girl who sits behind me .
Found her. The clause narrows the girl down to exactly one person.
That is the whole trade: one clause in exchange for knowing which one.
the girl + who + sits behind me
the noun the label word the rest of the clause
a noun + who / which / that / whose / where + the rest of the clause
the boy who plays goalkeeper · the app that saves my homework · the café where we meet
No clause, no idea which one — so no commas, ever. A defining clause is not extra information; it is the address of the noun, and you do not separate an address from its house. Students who forget their kit run laps — no commas, because the clause says which students. The comma kind, the kind that only adds a side note, is a different animal, and it waits for you at B1-31.
② The word kit
Five label words, one job each
Every defining clause hangs on one of five words. Grammar calls them relative pronouns , because inside the clause each one stands in for the noun it labels — in the boy who plays goalkeeper , the who is the boy, doing the playing. Choosing between the five is a single question: is the noun a person, a thing, a place, or the owner of something?
Word It labels Example Worth knowing
who people the teacher who runs chess club the safe choice for any person
which things & animals the app which saves my homework slightly formal — speech usually prefers that
that people and things the shoes that I wanted the everyday all-rounder; when in doubt, that
whose the owner the boy whose phone rang replaces his / her / its inside the clause
where places the café where we meet = in which — so no extra in / at / to after it
“What” is not on the team. Everything what he said… is one of the most common B1 slips in the world, and it is always wrong: what never glues a clause to a noun. After everything , something , the thing — use that : everything that he said.
Where carries its place inside it
the café + where + we meet
a place = in which a complete little sentence
Where only earns its seat when something happens in the place: we meet in the café, you borrow books in a library. If the place is simply doing or being something — the town ___ is famous for its cheese — then the clause still needs a subject, and where can never be one. That decision gets its own step in section ③.
③ How to choose
Four questions, always in this order
Run these four every time. The first two pick the word, the third rescues you from the where-trap, and the fourth — the biggest idea in this material — decides whether you need a word at all.
Which noun am I labelling? Find it and put your finger on it. Everything else hangs on what kind of noun it is.
Person, thing, place or owner? A person → who (or that). A thing or an animal → which (or that). The owner of the very next noun → whose . A place → possibly where , but ask question 3 first.
Does the clause happen in the place? We play football in the park → the park where we play. But if the place itself does the action — the park ___ has the skate ramp — the clause needs a subject, and where can never be a subject. A place acting as a subject takes that or which .
Look at the word straight after the gap. A verb next → your pronoun will be the subject of its clause, and it must stay. A new person or thing next → the clause already has a subject, and your pronoun can often disappear completely. Section ⑤ is entirely about this glance.
Sentence
I met a boy ___ sister plays for the county team.
Questions 1–2
The noun is a boy — a person, so the hand reaches for who. But look at the next word: sister . This clause is not about him doing anything; it is about something of his.
The owner check
“Who his sister plays…” would name the owner twice — once with who , once with his . English folds both into one word: whose sister.
Answer
I met a boy whose sister plays for the county team.
Sentence
the park ___ we play football · the park ___ has the new skate ramp
Question 3
First gap: the clause happens in the park — we play football in it — and it already has its own subject, we . That is exactly the seat where was built for.
Question 3 again
Second gap: has comes straight after, so this clause still needs a subject, and the park itself must be it. Where can never be a subject — a thing in the subject seat takes that or which .
Answer
the park where we play football · the park that has the new skate ramp — the same park, two different jobs for the clause.
④ Practice 1
Pick the label word
Eight items on questions 1 to 3: find the noun, name its kind, and watch out for the where-trap. 0 / 8
⑤ The contrast
The label word that can vanish — and the one that never can
Everyday English drops the pronoun whenever it is allowed to: the film we watched , the shoes I wanted . Drop the wrong one, though, and the clause falls over. The rule that separates the two cases is exactly one glance long.
subject — it must stay
the man who called about the bike
Inside the clause, who does the calling — it is the clause’s subject. Remove it and called has nobody left: the man called about the bike is at the door collapses halfway through.
object — it can vanish
the film (that) we watched on Friday
Inside the clause, we does the watching; that only stands for the thing that gets watched. The clause already owns a subject, so the pronoun is optional: the film we watched.
The one-glance test: read the word straight after who / which / that. A verb next → the pronoun is the subject → it stays, always. A new person or thing next → the clause has its own subject → the pronoun is only the object, and object pronouns may silently disappear. That single glance is most of this topic.
Sentence
The trainers ___ I bought online are already falling apart.
The glance
The word after the gap is I — a new person. The clause has its own subject, so whatever fills the gap is only the object: the thing that gets bought.
Decision
An object pronoun is optional. That works, which works — and nothing at all works best. In conversation, the silence is what a fluent ear expects.
Answer
The trainers I bought online are already falling apart. (= the trainers that I bought online — both correct.)
Sentence
The man ___ called about the bike is at the door.
The glance
The word after the gap is called — a verb. Nobody else in the clause can do the calling, so the gap must hold the clause’s subject.
Decision
A subject pronoun never vanishes. Drop it and the listener parses the man called about the bike as a finished sentence — then crashes straight into is at the door .
Answer
The man who called about the bike is at the door. ( That also works here; silence does not.)
Seven items on the glance alone. Before you answer, look at the word after the gap — verb, or new subject? 0 / 7
⑥ In context
Astrid’s people and places
Eleven labels in one short text — some kept their pronoun, some dropped it, two use the specialists. Tap any coloured label and read why it looks the way it does.
My best friend is a girl who never gives up . Her name is Lottie, and we met at the climbing wall where our schools train on Thursdays. The first route she tried ended in a fall — and the fall that would make most people quit just made her laugh. Last month she finished a route that nobody else in our group can touch .
Afterwards we always go to the little café that sells hot chocolate with real cream. The man who runs it is called Reza, and the old dog that sleeps by the door is his. Reza is the kind of owner whose customers never want to leave. The corner table we take every week looks out at the park where half the town walks its dogs .
Tap any coloured label above. Blue = the pronoun is the subject and must stay · green = the pronoun dropped out (or could) — it was the object · orange = the specialists where and whose.
⑦ Practice 2
Real sentences, all four questions at once
Harder now: owners, places, vanishing pronouns and the doubled one — mixed together, the way real sentences arrive. 0 / 8
⑧ Sort it
Stay or vanish? Sort the twelve labels
Every phrase below still carries its pronoun. Run the one-glance test — what follows who / which / that? — and sort: is that pronoun holding the clause up, or could it silently go? 0 / 12
must stay — it is the subject
could vanish — it is the object
Start with the film that we watched . What is the word straight after that ?
⑨ The definitions game
Say it without saying it
A dictionary is just thousands of defining relative clauses wearing serious clothes. Read each label, guess the word it defines, then tap the card to check — and notice which label word the definition chose, and why.
🦷 a person who fixes teeth A dentist! A person, so the label starts with who — and fixes follows it, so who is the subject and has to stay.
🧊 a machine that keeps food cold A fridge. A thing takes that or which — and this that is doing the keeping, so it stays.
📚 a place where you borrow books A library. The borrowing happens in it, so where — the word that quietly means in which.
🧤 the player whose job is stopping goals A goalkeeper. The job belongs to the player, so the owner word whose does the gluing.
🎬 a film that makes you laugh A comedy. That is the subject — the film does the making — so there is no dropping it.
🥇 the prize the winner takes home A gold medal — and did you notice? No label word at all. The winner is the clause’s own subject, so the object pronoun vanished: the prize (that) the winner takes home.
Now play it with a friend: define anything in the room — the thing that holds the door open , the person whose desk is always tidy — and make them guess. The game cannot be played without today’s grammar.
⑩ Fix the mistake
Six sentences to repair
Every one of these comes straight out of real B1 writing. Tap a sentence to see the repair and the reason.
⑪ Watch out
The three traps of the defining clause
The first one is the most common relative-clause error at this level, full stop. Learn to hear it.
Trap 1 · one label per noun
These are the trainers that I bought them online.
These are the trainers that I bought online.
Inside the clause, that already is the trainers. Say them as well and the shoes sit in one little clause twice. The pronoun does not just introduce the clause — it takes a seat inside it, and once the seat is taken, nothing else may sit there.
Trap 2 · a subject pronoun never vanishes
There’s the woman sold us the tickets.
There’s the woman who sold us the tickets.
You may only drop a pronoun when the clause has another subject. Here sold has nobody but who — remove it and the listener hears the woman sold us the tickets as a whole sentence, then waits for an ending that never lands properly.
Trap 3 · where already contains the place
That’s the campsite where we stayed at.
That’s the campsite where we stayed.
Where means at / in which — the little place word is already folded inside it, so a second at doubles it. If you really want the at , swap the pronoun instead: the campsite that we stayed at . One place word per clause, either way.
⑫ Quick test
Eight questions, no help
No hints this time. Person, thing, place or owner — then the one-glance test. 0 / 8
Answer all eight to see how you did.
Teacher notes
Sequence (45 min): §1 read the two cards aloud and play one live round — say “the person…” about someone in the room and let the class finish the label, 3 min. §2 the table, then a definitions chain around the room (a person who…, a place where…, the student whose…), 5 min. §3 the four questions on the board and both worked runs with the class calling the answers, 6 min. §4 alone, then pairs compare reasons, 5 min. §5 the one-glance test on the board, both runs, then the items, 7 min. §6 read the text aloud once, then tap in pairs, 4 min. §7 alone, 4 min. §8 as a race, 2 min. §9 play it live: learners define objects in the room for each other, 3 min. §10 in pairs, 2 min. §11 read the traps aloud, 1 min. §12 silent, as the exit ticket, 3 min.
The board move that works: write the film that we watched and the man who called one under the other, and draw an arrow from each pronoun back to its noun — the arrow is what the pronoun means. Then circle the word straight after the pronoun. A new subject → cross the pronoun out, read the line aloud, nothing breaks. A verb → cross it out, read aloud, and the class hears the crash. The double-pronoun error dies by arrows too: the book that I read it needs two arrows landing on one noun — one arrow too many.
If a learner is stuck on the double pronoun, it is because they build the clause as a separate full sentence first — I read it last week — and then glue it on without removing anything. Write the two sentences apart, physically cross out it , and walk that to the front of the clause: the label word does not join the clause, it replaces something inside it. One replacement, one crossing-out, every time.
Watch the quiet learners on where: the error the café where sells milkshakes hides easily because it sounds vaguely right. The rescue is the in-it test from §3: can you say the clause and add “in it”? We meet — in it works, so where. Sells milkshakes — in it fails — the café is the seller, so that / which.
Cambridge B1 Preliminary: who / which / where / whose are open-cloze regulars in Reading Part 6, and Part 5 options like to turn on that against what. In Writing Part 2 stories and articles, a couple of clean defining clauses are the cheapest range marks available — and examiners reliably flag the man which and the doubled pronoun.
Next: B1-31 (non-defining clauses — the comma kind this material keeps pointing away from), then B2-10 (whose and whom consolidated, prepositions inside the clause: the band whose songs, the man to whom) and B2-27 (reduced clauses: the boy standing over there — today’s vanishing act taken one step further).
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus A1–B2 · topic B1-15
Lesson Plan
- A defining relative clause is a label that says which one — cut it and the sentence points at nobody
- The girl who sits behind me: the noun, the label word, the rest of the clause
- No commas, ever: the clause is the address of the noun, not a side note
Key Vocabulary
Grammar Points
- noun + who / that for people: the teacher who runs chess club
- noun + which / that for things and animals: the app that saves my homework
- whose replaces his / her / its: the boy whose phone rang
- where = in which, for places where something happens: the café where we meet — never where + a second in / at
- the object pronoun can vanish: the film (that) we watched — the subject pronoun never can: the man who called
- defining clauses take no commas: students who forget their kit run laps
Prerequisites
Приєднуйтеся до наших груп!
Ми віримо, що правильні запитання приносять правильні відповіді. Чи маєте ви запитання про свій шлях вивчення англійської, чи потребуєте допомоги з певною мовною навичкою — ми завжди поруч.
