⏳ Grammar B1-3: Present perfect vs past simple
The decision material of the Fleydo B1 grammar series: present perfect or past simple, the contrast that decides more B1 marks than any other. The opening image is a pair of true sentences about the same art project — I finished it on Tuesday, a dated fact sealed inside last week, and I’ve finished it, news the present can still feel — with a timeline that draws the past simple as a sealed, named box and the present perfect as a line that reaches NOW. Both machines go on the bench side by side: a full comparison table of statements, negatives, questions and short answers, plus the time words each tense loves, and the half-built-perfect slip (has wrote). A four-step checklist — hunt for the time first — is walked through three worked runs, including the conversation swing: Have you ever been on TV? answered with the past simple and a date. The compare-and-verdict pair is the famous one — I’ve lost my keys against I lost my keys — with the recency rule attached: five minutes ago is still named time. A 95-word escape-room dialogue between Jade and Carlos shows the swing breathing in real talk, every tense tappable with its reason. Practice runs to thirty-one multiple-choice items in four sets, all explained, plus twelve time expressions to sort into sealed and open boxes, six real learner errors to repair, and three traps: the perfect with named time, the answer that must drop out of the perfect, and this morning changing tense at noon. Teacher notes give a 45-minute sequence, the box-and-arrow board move, the calendar-pointing rescue and Cambridge B1 Preliminary relevance.
Text version of this lesson
Grammar B1-3: Present perfect vs past simple
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus
B1
≈ 30 min
B1-3
① The idea
Finished time tells a story — open time touches now
Jade can say two true things about her art project. I finished it on Tuesday — a dated fact, sealed inside last week. And I’ve finished it — news, still warm, the folder sitting there ready to hand in. Same project, same girl, two tenses. Nothing decides between them except the time: is it finished and named , or open and unnamed ?
named, finished time — the past simple lives inside the box
open or unnamed time — the present perfect reaches now
named, finished time → past simple → I finished it on Tuesday · we met in 2022
open or unnamed time → present perfect → I have finished it · we have met before
Find the time before you touch the verb. If the sentence names a finished time — yesterday, last week, in 2022, when I was ten — the past simple takes it, always, no matter how recent. If the period is still open, or no time is named at all, the present perfect keeps the sentence connected to now.
② The form
Two machines, side by side
You own both of these already — A2 built them. This lesson is about choosing between them, so first put them on the bench together and watch the difference: everything the past simple does with did , the present perfect does with have / has .
Past simple — the story tense
verb + -ed / second form → watched · went · saw · made
One word carries the whole tense: She texted me.
Questions and negatives call in did : Did she text? · She didn’t text.
It lives inside named, finished time: yesterday · in June · two years ago.
Present perfect — the news tense
have / has + third form → watched · gone · seen · made
Two words, always: She has texted me. I ’ve texted back.
Questions swap the first two words: Has she texted? · Negatives: she hasn’t texted.
It lives in open or unnamed time: ever · never · this week · so far.
Past simple Present perfect
Statement She missed the bus. I missed it too. She has missed the bus. I have missed it too.
Negative They didn’t miss it. They haven’t missed it.
Question Did he miss it? Has he missed it?
Short answer Yes, he did . / No, he didn’t . Yes, he has . / No, he hasn’t .
Time words it loves yesterday · last night · in 2022 · two hours ago · when I was ten ever · never · this week · so far · in my life · yet
The half-built perfect: “has wrote”, “have saw”, “has went” — that is the past simple jammed into the middle of the perfect. After have / has, only the third form may stand: has written , have seen , has gone . Where a verb’s second and third forms differ (go – went – gone, see – saw – seen, do – did – done), the perfect always takes the third.
③ How to choose
Hunt for the time before you touch the verb
Your ear will not settle this one — both tenses sound fine to it. Run the checklist instead, in this order, every time, until it runs itself.
Hunt for the time first. Before you look at the verb, read the sentence only for time words. Named and finished — yesterday, last week, in 2022, three days ago, when I was ten — means past simple. Choose it and stop reading this list.
No time named at all? Then ask what the sentence is doing. If it announces news, or a result the present can still feel — the window is broken, the homework is done, the keys are missing — the present perfect keeps the event connected to now.
Time named, but the box still open? This week, this term, today, so far, in my life — you are still standing inside those periods, so nothing is sealed. The present perfect counts whatever has happened inside them.
Is somebody digging for details? When, what time, where, who with — detail questions pin an event to a named time, so they run on the past simple. The perfect opens a topic; the past simple investigates it.
Sentence
Sana ___ (break) her glasses — that’s why she’s sitting at the front today.
Step 1
Hunt for the time: nothing is named. No date, no ago , no last anything.
Step 2
Is it news the present can feel? Yes — the glasses are still broken and she is squinting at the board right now. The result is in the room.
Answer
Sana has broken her glasses. Add a named time later — she broke them on Tuesday — and the past simple takes over at once.
Sentence
We ___ (see) that band live when they came to our city.
Step 1
Hunt for the time: when they came to our city — a whole little clause naming one finished evening. The box is sealed and labelled.
Answer
We saw that band live when they came to our city. Named, finished time → past simple — the checklist ended at step 1.
Sentence
___ you ever ___ (be) on TV? — Yes, once. The local news ___ (film) our class in 2023.
Step 1
The question names no time — only ever , which opens the whole of a life. An open, unnamed period → Have you ever been on TV?
Step 2
The answer does name a time: in 2023 , a sealed year. Named, finished time → past simple: filmed .
Answer
Have you ever been on TV? — Yes, once. The local news filmed our class in 2023. One conversation, both tenses, each obeying its own time.
④ Practice 1
Eight items on the machinery
Run step 1 of the checklist on every sentence: is a time named, and is it finished? 0 / 8
⑤ The contrast
The most famous pair of sentences at B1
Every word is identical except the tense — and the two sentences happen in two different worlds. Read them slowly.
I’ve lost my keys — the present feels it
I ’ve lost my keys.
News. The keys are missing at this very moment — she is at the front door, patting every pocket. No time is named because the time is not the point: the result is, and the result is standing on the doorstep.
I lost my keys — a story about the past
I lost my keys.
A story. It happened, it finished, and the teller has probably found them since — this sentence looks back at a past day from a safe distance. Add a named time — on the trip, last term — and nothing changes: the past simple already lives back there.
Verdict: same event, two homes. The present perfect keeps the event in the room; the past simple files it away as history. And the moment any finished time is named, the argument is over — I lost them five minutes ago , never I have lost them five minutes ago . Recent is not the test. Named is.
Seven items on exactly this line. Ask two things each time: does the present still feel it — and is any finished time named? 0 / 7
⑥ In context
The escape-room conversation
Jade and Carlos are on the bus home. Listen to how the conversation breathes: the present perfect opens each topic, and the past simple moves in the moment anyone asks for details. Tap any coloured phrase to see why it was chosen.
Carlos: Have you ever tried an escape room?
Jade: Twice! I did my first one in March , for my cousin Lara’s birthday — we escaped with four seconds left.
Carlos: Four seconds! Who found the final code?
Jade: My brother Ivan — he stayed calm and checked the bookshelf again. Why, have you booked one?
Carlos: The pirate room, for Saturday. I’ve never done one, so I’ve watched ten team videos this week .
Jade: And so far , what’s the lesson?
Carlos: In the last one, the team argued for ages and never found the door.
Jade: Then don’t argue — and take Ivan.
Tap any coloured phrase above. Green = open or unnamed time (present perfect) · blue = named or finished time (past simple) · orange = the time expressions steering it all.
⑦ Practice 2
Real conversations, real containers
Harder now: conversation swings, open containers, and phrases that change with the clock. 0 / 8
⑧ Sort it
Which tense does each time expression call?
Twelve time expressions, one question each: is the box sealed, or are you still standing inside it? Tap a phrase to file it. 0 / 12
Finished time → past simple
Open time → present perfect
Start with yesterday . Can the day still grow, or is it sealed?
⑨ Fix the mistake
Six sentences to repair
Every one of these is a sentence real B1 learners write. Tap it to see the correction and the reason.
⑩ Watch out
Three traps that follow you to the exam hall
Learn their faces now and they lose their power.
Trap 1 · the perfect never holds a named, finished time
We have visited the aquarium last term.
We visited the aquarium last term.
However fresh the memory feels, last term is a sealed, named box, and the perfect cannot reach now from inside it. Either keep the date and switch tense — we visited it last term — or keep the perfect and drop the date: we have visited the aquarium.
Trap 2 · when the answer names the time, the conversation drops down
Have you seen Sana today? — Yes, I have seen her at breakfast.
Have you seen Sana today? — Yes, I saw her at breakfast.
The question may stay perfect — today is still open — but the answer names its moment, at breakfast , and the moment it does, the past simple takes the sentence. Open with the perfect, land in the past: that swing is the sound of natural English.
Trap 3 · this morning moves house at noon
It’s 8 p.m., and I’ve seen Carlos this morning.
It’s 8 p.m., and I saw Carlos this morning.
At 10 a.m., this morning is still open and rides the perfect: I ’ve seen Carlos this morning. By evening, the morning is a closed, named box, so the past simple takes it. The phrase did not change — the clock did. The same trick moves today at midnight and this week on Sunday night.
⑪ Quick test
Eight questions, no help
No hints this time. Hunt for the time first, every single sentence. 0 / 8
Answer all eight to see how you did.
Teacher notes
Sequence (45 min): §1 read the two Tuesday sentences aloud and draw the box-and-arrow picture, 4 min. §2 the table, then a transformation chain around the room — statement → question → negative in both tenses, 5 min. §3 the three worked runs on the board with the class calling out the step numbers, 6 min. §4 alone, then pairs compare reasons, 5 min. §5 the keys pair first — act it out at the door — then the items, 6 min. §6 read the dialogue in pairs twice, once for meaning and once tapping every mark, 4 min. §7 alone, 4 min. §8 as a race, 2 min. §9 in pairs, 3 min. §10 read the traps aloud, 2 min. §11 silent exit ticket, 4 min. Takeaway: three true sentences about your week — one with a named time, one with an open container, one Have you ever…? question for tomorrow’s partner.
The board move that works: one long line, NOW at the right end, and two magnets you keep all year: a closed box (past simple) and an arrow head touching NOW (present perfect). Every example gets placed — box or arrow — before anyone may say a tense name. When a learner writes I have seen it yesterday , put the box magnet on yesterday and invite them to make the arrow reach NOW from inside a sealed box. They cannot, and that is the whole lesson in one gesture.
If a learner is stuck, shrink the checklist to one physical question: can you point at the time on a calendar? Yesterday, last week, in 2022, three days ago — a finger lands on them, so past simple. Ever, never, so far, in my life — there is nowhere to point, because the period is still growing under your feet, so present perfect. Gesture first, sentence second, for one whole exercise.
The error that survives correction is the swing: learners who know the rule still answer Have you ever…? entirely in the perfect — “Yes, I have gone there in 2023.” Drill ping-pong in pairs: A opens with Have you ever…?, B answers Yes + a past-simple detail, A follows up with When / Where / Who with. Three minutes of this daily beats an hour of it once.
Cambridge B1 Preliminary: this contrast is the most-tested grammar on the paper. Reading Part 5 gaps it directly; the Writing Part 1 email always mixes news (perfect) with a recount (past simple); and Speaking Parts 1–2 are built on the swing — Have you ever…? followed by Tell me about it. Examiners listen for the drop into the past simple.
Comes from: A2-21 (present perfect for life experience), B1-1 (for / since), B1-2 (just / already / yet). Next: B1-4 (used to), then B1-21 (present perfect continuous) and B2-5 (present perfect simple vs continuous), where today’s question grows a second floor.
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus A1–B2 · topic B1-3
Lesson Plan
- Two true sentences about one project: I finished it on Tuesday, and I’ve finished it
- A timeline: the past simple lives in a sealed, named box; the present perfect reaches NOW
- The rule that runs the lesson: find the time before you touch the verb
Key Vocabulary
Grammar Points
- Named, finished time takes the past simple: I saw that film yesterday · we met in 2022 · she broke it five minutes ago
- Open or unnamed time takes the present perfect: I’ve seen that film · Have you ever…? · I haven’t finished yet
- Open containers count with the perfect: this week, this term, so far, in my life — until the clock seals them
- The conversation swing: the perfect opens a topic, the past simple asks for its details — When did you go?
- After have / has only the third form stands: has written, has gone — never has wrote, has went
Приєднуйтеся до наших груп!
Ми віримо, що правильні запитання приносять правильні відповіді. Чи маєте ви запитання про свій шлях вивчення англійської, чи потребуєте допомоги з певною мовною навичкою — ми завжди поруч.
