❓ Grammar A2-2: Wh-questions in the past
The second material of the Fleydo A2 grammar series, for learners of about eight to twelve who can already tell a simple past story and now have to ask about one. It teaches the two question shapes side by side: the question word plus did plus the person plus a plain verb, and the question word plus was or were, which needs no helper at all because the verb be moves to the front by itself. The learner is given a four-step procedure — name the missing piece, say the expected answer, look at its verb, read the question back — and then three worked examples that run through it, including the case where the question word is itself the person doing the action, so did disappears. Practice is spread across five blocks: eight warm-up items, eight on the did against was or were decision, a tapped interview, eight items inside real conversations, a ten-strip sorting task, six repairs and an eight-item unhinted test with a scored result band. Every answer explains its reason, never only its verdict. Teacher notes give a 45-minute sequence, a two-box board move, the finger technique for a stuck learner and the Cambridge A2 Key relevance.
Text version of this lesson
Grammar A2-2: Wh-questions in the past
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus
A2
≈ 25 min
A2-2
① The idea
What did you do? Where were you?
A yes/no question gives you one small word back. A wh-question asks for the missing
piece itself — a place, a time, a thing, a person or a reason. When that piece belongs to finished time,
one word in the question has to say so, and English puts that word near the front, before the person.
What + did + you + eat ?
question word did who plain verb
Where + were + you ?
question word were who
question word + did + who + plain verb + ?
question word + was / were + who + the rest + ?
Exactly one word in the question carries the past: did , or was / were .
Everything that comes after it stays in its plain form.
② The form
Nine question words, two past words
The question word tells the listener which piece is missing . It never changes for
the past — the change happens in the word straight after it.
What a thing
Where a place
When a time
What time a clock time
Who a person
Why a reason
How a way, a feeling
How long a length of time
How many a number
Question word With did — ordinary verbs With was / were — the verb be
What What did you buy? What was in your bag?
Where Where did Bea sit? Where were you?
When When did the film start? When was the last match?
What time What time did you leave? What time was the bus?
Who Who did you sit with? Who was your first teacher?
Why Why did Theo run? Why were you late?
How How did you get home? How was the pizza?
How long How long did it rain? How long was the queue?
How many How many did you make? How many people were there?
The two past words, person by person
Who Past of be A question with it The same person with did
I was Where was I in this photo? What did I say?
you were Why were you at the office? What did you take?
he / she / it was How long was she away? When did she call?
we were Where were we at seven? How did we win?
they were Who were they with? Why did they stop?
did has already said “past”. That is its whole job, so the verb behind it goes back to the plain
form you would find in a word list: What did you buy? — never What did you bought?
Notice too that did never changes for the person: did I , did she , did they .
When the question word is the doer
Usually the person doing the action stands after did . But sometimes the missing piece
is that person — and then there is nothing left for did to help, so the past verb stands alone.
The missing piece The question The answer
the person who did it Who broke the gate? Ravi broke the gate.
the thing that did it What happened here? A branch fell on the shed.
the person you helped Who did you help? I helped Bea. (you did it, so did stays)
③ How to choose
Four steps, in this order
Do not guess from the sound of the question. Build it from the answer you expect.
Name the missing piece and pick its word. A place → Where . A time → When or
What time . A thing → What . A person → Who . A reason → Why . A way or a
feeling → How .
Say the answer to yourself and find its verb. If that verb is be — am, is, are — then the
past of be does everything by itself. Put was or were straight after the question word.
Any other verb? Then you need did . Question word, did , the person, and finally the
verb in its plain form.
Read the question back. One past word only, the person right after it, and a question mark at the
end. If you can hear two past words, one of them has to go.
I want the place where Theo was on Saturday morning
The answer “Theo was at the swimming pool.”
Its verb be — there is no action word at all, so step 2 applies and no did is needed
Question Where was Theo on Saturday morning?
I want the thing Bea bought at the market
The answer “Bea bought a red notebook.”
Its verb buy — an ordinary verb, so step 3 applies: did comes in and buy goes back to plain
Question What did Bea buy at the market?
I want the person who broke the gate
The answer “Ravi broke the gate.”
Its verb break — an ordinary verb, but the missing piece is the person doing it, so did has nobody to help
Question Who broke the gate?
④ Practice 1
Eight to warm up
Say the answer in your head first. Its verb decides everything.
0 / 8
⑤ The contrast
did, or was / were?
These two build the same shape but for different verbs, and mixing them is the one mistake
that spoils a whole conversation.
did + plain verb
What did you buy?
The answer is an action: “I bought a hat.” An ordinary verb cannot move in front of the person by
itself, so it sends did to the front instead — and then hands over its past, going back to the plain
form buy . Use this for go, eat, buy, win, say, leave, work, get: every verb except be .
was / were
Where were you?
The answer is not an action: “I was in the garden.” The verb be is the one verb that can
jump in front of the person on its own, so it needs no helper at all. Use this whenever the answer would
say what somebody or something was — a place, an age, a feeling, a price, the weather.
The test that always works: build the answer first. If the answer sentence
contains an ordinary past verb (bought, went, said), the question needs did . If the answer sentence
only has was or were in it, the question takes was or were too — and never both at
once. Where did you were? is one past word too many; Where were you? is right.
Eight items on this one decision.
0 / 8
⑥ In context
Mira interviews Ravi about the fun run
Mira writes for the school paper. Read the interview, then tap any coloured question to see
why it is built that way.
Mira: The fun run was on Saturday.
Where were you
at half past eight?
Ravi: At the gate with Bea. The car park was already full.
Mira: How many people
were there ?
Ravi: About two hundred, I think.
Mira:
What did you eat
before the race?
Ravi: Two bananas. Bea ate four!
Mira:
How long was
the course?
Ravi: Five kilometres. It went round the lake twice.
Mira:
Why did you stop
at the bridge?
Ravi: My shoelace came undone. I lost about a minute.
Mira:
Who won
the cup?
Ravi: Bea won it. She was very fast on the hill.
Mira:
What time did you finish ?
Ravi: At ten past ten.
Mira:
How did you feel
at the end?
Ravi: Tired, and very happy.
Tap a coloured question above.
⑦ Practice 2
Eight in real conversations
Read the whole situation before you choose — the answer is hidden in it.
0 / 8
⑧ Sort
Which past word does this question need?
Each strip is the end of a question. Decide what has to come in front of it, then tap it.
0 / 10
did + plain verb
was / were
Start with the first strip. Would the answer contain an action, or only was / were ?
⑨ Fix the mistake
Six questions to repair
Every one of these is written by A2 learners every week. Tap a line to see the repair and the
reason behind it.
⑩ Watch out
Four confusions worth naming
1 · after did, the verb is plain
✗ What did you bought ? ✓ What did you buy ?
✗ Where did she went ? ✓ Where did she go ?
A question needs the past exactly once. did has already said it, so the verb rests.
2 · never did and was in the same question
✗ Where did you were ? ✓ Where were you ?
✗ Why did the shop was closed? ✓ Why was the shop closed?
These are two ways of doing the same job. Pick the one the answer asks for, and drop the other.
3 · the past word comes before the person, not after
✗ Where you did go? ✓ Where did you go?
✗ How long the trip was ? ✓ How long was the trip ?
A statement runs person first . A question turns that pair round: question word, past word, person.
4 · when Who or What is the doer, drop did
✗ Who did break the gate? ✓ Who broke the gate?
✗ What did happen here? ✓ What happened here?
Ask yourself who is doing the action. If the answer to that is the question word itself, did has
nobody to help — but if somebody else is doing it, did stays: Who did you help?
⑪ Quick test
Eight questions, no hints
Run the four steps silently for each one. 0 / 8
Answer all eight to see where you are.
Teacher notes
Sequence (45 min): §1 on the board, two model questions only (4 min) → §2 the question-word strip
chorally, then the first table read across in pairs (7 min) → §3 the four steps, with you thinking aloud
through worked example 1 and the class doing example 2 (7 min) → §4 alone, checked in pairs (6 min) →
§5 the verdict read aloud, then the eight items (8 min) → §6 in pairs, one learner reading Mira and one
reading Ravi, then tapping three questions each (5 min) → §8 as a whole-class race (3 min) → §11 silent, as
the exit ticket (5 min). §7, §9 and §10 are the homework, and they are also the re-teach if the exit ticket
goes badly.
The board move that works: write one answer sentence — Bea bought a red notebook — and
draw a box round the verb. Ask: is that verb be ? No, so write did on the left of the board and
the plain verb on the right, and build the question between them. Then rub out the answer, write
Bea was at the market , box was , and show that the box itself slides to the front. Two answer
sentences, two boxes, one picture the class keeps.
If a learner is stuck, it is almost always Where did you were? or What did you bought?
Do not re-explain. Cover the verb with your finger and ask: “Which word is already telling me this is the
past?” They point at did . Uncover the verb and let them repair it themselves. The same finger works for
every one of these errors, and it works faster the tenth time than the first.
Drill it as an interview, not as a worksheet. Give each pair three question words on cards and one
minute to ask about last weekend. Wrong questions are useful here: write two of them on the board without
names and fix them together at the end.
Cambridge A2 Key: Speaking Part 1 asks candidates directly about the past, and Part 2 requires them
to produce questions from prompts, which is exactly this material. In Reading and Writing Part 6 a short
message often has to contain a question. Marks are lost far more often for did you went than for
spelling.
Next: this follows A1-9 (question words), A1-25 ( was / were ) and A2-1 (past simple
consolidation), and it pairs immediately with A2-3 ( yesterday, ago, last… ), which supplies the time
phrases these questions ask about. A2-10 adds Whose…? B1-3 (present perfect vs past simple) is where
the finished time idea behind did is tested again.
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus A1–B2 · topic A2-2
Lesson Plan
- What a wh-question asks for, against a yes/no question
- Two pattern strips and the formula for both shapes
Key Vocabulary
Grammar Points
- question word + did + subject + plain verb + ?
- question word + was / were + subject + the rest + ?
- did carries the past, so the verb behind it never does
- was for I / he / she / it, were for you / we / they
- Never did and was in the same question
- Who or What as the doer takes the past verb alone: Who broke it?
Prerequisites
আমাদের ক্লাসে যোগ দিন!
আমরা বিশ্বাস করি সঠিক প্রশ্ন সঠিক উত্তর নিয়ে আসে। আপনার ইংরেজি শেখার যাত্রা সম্পর্কে কোনো প্রশ্ন থাকলে, আমরা সবসময় এখানে আছি।
