🧬 IELTS Band 9 vs Band 6 Essay: One Task 2 Answer Rewritten Line by Line
This free IELTS Writing lesson puts an IELTS band 9 essay and a band 6 essay side by side on the same exam-style Task 2 question about AI in education, then compares them sentence by sentence. Each change is labelled with the criterion it affects: Task Response, Coherence and Cohesion, Lexical Resource, or Grammatical Range and Accuracy. You learn the eight upgrade moves that recur in every high-band essay, see a realistic band 7 rewrite as the bridge between the two, and get a plain-language self-check rubric and a table of mistakes candidates make when they try to write band 9. Two interactive practice sets (choose the higher-band sentence; identify the criterion a change improves), a paragraph rewrite task with a model answer and an eight-question quiz let you test the moves immediately. It suits adult candidates at band 5.5 to 7.0 who already write complete essays and want to know exactly what to change.
Text version of this lesson
IELTS · Writing · Band 6 → 9
IELTS Band 9 vs Band 6 Essay: One Task 2 Answer Rewritten Line by Line
The same exam-style Task 2 question answered twice, at band 6.0 and at band 9, then compared sentence by sentence so you can see which change moves which criterion, and what a realistic band 7 looks like in between.
⏰ 45 minutes 📈 B2 🎯 Task 2 essay upgrades ✅ Answer keys
01
The short answer
IELTS band 9 vs band 6 essay: what actually separates them?
A band 9 essay and a band 6 essay can use the same ideas on the same question and still sit three bands apart. The difference is rarely one impressive word; it is eight repeatable decisions: a position stated, not announced; topic sentences that claim something; examples with detail; hedged generalisations; referencing instead of repetition; error-free complex sentences; collocation instead of "big words"; and a conclusion that adds something.
Task 2 asks for at least 250 words in about 40 minutes and is marked on four equally weighted criteria: Task Response, Coherence and Cohesion, Lexical Resource, and Grammatical Range and Accuracy. Because they are averaged, every change below is labelled with the criterion it mainly affects.
help_outline The exam-style question used throughout
Some people think that artificial intelligence tools will improve education, while others believe they will make students lazy and less able to think for themselves.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
02
Two essays
The same IELTS Writing Task 2 question: band 6 and band 9 sample essays
Both essays are complete and over 250 words. The first is how a typical band 6.0 candidate writes: organised but general, repetitive and sometimes inaccurate. The second keeps the same order of ideas; every sentence simply does more work.
Model essay A
Band 6.0-style essay: clear, but general
About 265 words · 2 min read
In this modern era, artificial intelligence is a controversial issue in education. Some people think AI tools will improve education but other people think AI tools make students lazy and they cannot think by themselves. In this essay I will discuss both views and give my opinion.
On the one hand, there are many people who think AI tools improve education. Firstly, AI tools can help students to do their homework faster. For example, students can ask AI to explain a difficult topic and AI will explain it. Secondly, AI tools are available all the time, so students can study at any time they want. Moreover, teachers can use AI tools to make their lessons more interesting and this is good for the students.
On the other hand, some people believe AI tools make students lazy. This is because students use AI to do their homework and they do not think by themselves. For instance, a student can copy an essay from AI and give it to the teacher. In this case, the student does not learn anything. Also, if students always depend on AI, they will not develop their thinking skills and this will be a big problem for them in the future.
In my opinion, I think AI tools have both advantages and disadvantages. AI tools can improve education but students should not depend on them too much. Teachers should teach students how to use AI tools in a correct way.
In conclusion, AI tools can improve education but they can also make students lazy. I believe that it depends on how the students use them.
Model essay B
Band 9-style essay: the same structure, more work per sentence
About 280 words · 2 min read
Artificial intelligence has entered classrooms faster than most education systems have been able to respond, and opinion is divided over whether it sharpens learning or hollows it out . While the fear of dependence is legitimate , I would argue that the outcome depends far less on the technology itself than on how deliberately it is integrated into teaching.
Those who welcome AI point to its capacity to personalise learning in a way a single teacher cannot. A tool that explains a concept three different ways, sets a slightly harder problem each time, and responds at midnight gives a struggling student what only private tutoring once provided. Teachers benefit too: when routine marking and feedback are automated, more of their time goes into the conversations that actually move students forward.
Critics counter that convenience erodes effort. If an essay can be generated in seconds, the slow, uncomfortable process of forming and defending an idea, which is where most learning happens, can simply be skipped. This concern is not hypothetical ; any teacher who has received a polished but hollow assignment has seen the consequences. Yet the same objection was once raised about calculators and search engines, and in both cases the solution was not prohibition but a shift in what students were asked to do.
That shift is the crux of the matter . Where assessment rewards finished products, AI invites shortcuts; where it rewards reasoning, drafts and reflection, the same tool becomes a sparring partner rather than a ghostwriter. In short, AI neither improves nor damages education on its own: the effect is determined by whether institutions redesign their teaching around it or simply leave students to use it unsupervised.
Notice what did not change: the order of ideas, both views, an opinion. The band 9 essay has no vocabulary a B2 learner could not learn. Everything that did change is in the next table.
03
The core
Band 6 vs band 9 essay compared line by line
Read each row left to right: the band 6 sentence, the band 9 sentence doing the same job, what changed and the criterion it mainly affects. TR Task Response · CC Coherence & Cohesion · LR Lexical Resource · GRA Grammatical Range & Accuracy.
Band 6 sentence Band 9 sentence What changed
In this modern era, artificial intelligence is a controversial issue in education. Artificial intelligence has entered classrooms faster than most education systems have been able to respond, and opinion is divided over whether it sharpens learning or hollows it out. Memorised filler becomes a specific claim; the two views are paraphrased, not labelled. LR TR
In this essay I will discuss both views and give my opinion. While the fear of dependence is legitimate, I would argue that the outcome depends far less on the technology itself than on how deliberately it is integrated into teaching. Announcing the essay becomes a real position; the "While…" concession shows the counter-view is understood. TR GRA
On the one hand, there are many people who think AI tools improve education. Those who welcome AI point to its capacity to personalise learning in a way a single teacher cannot. The topic sentence states the one reason the paragraph will defend instead of repeating the question. CC TR
For example, students can ask AI to explain a difficult topic and AI will explain it. A tool that explains a concept three different ways, sets a slightly harder problem each time, and responds at midnight gives a struggling student what only private tutoring once provided. A circular example becomes a concrete scenario with three parallel details, in one accurate complex sentence. TR GRA
Moreover, teachers can use AI tools to make their lessons more interesting and this is good for the students. Teachers benefit too: when routine marking and feedback are automated, more of their time goes into the conversations that actually move students forward. Vague "interesting / good" becomes cause and effect; "too" and a colon replace the listing linker. LR CC
On the other hand, some people believe AI tools make students lazy. Critics counter that convenience erodes effort. Seven words that argue; "counter" signals contrast, "erodes effort" is natural collocation. CC LR
For instance, a student can copy an essay from AI and give it to the teacher. In this case, the student does not learn anything. If an essay can be generated in seconds, the slow, uncomfortable process of forming and defending an idea, which is where most learning happens, can simply be skipped. Two simple sentences become one conditional with an embedded relative clause that explains why learning is lost. GRA TR
Also, if students always depend on AI, they will not develop their thinking skills and this will be a big problem for them in the future. This concern is not hypothetical; any teacher who has received a polished but hollow assignment has seen the consequences. Yet the same objection was once raised about calculators and search engines, and in both cases the solution was not prohibition but a shift in what students were asked to do. The view is evaluated, not reported: concede, then limit it with a parallel. "This concern" refers back instead of repeating "AI tools". TR CC
In my opinion, I think AI tools have both advantages and disadvantages. AI tools can improve education but students should not depend on them too much. That shift is the crux of the matter. Where assessment rewards finished products, AI invites shortcuts; where it rewards reasoning, drafts and reflection, the same tool becomes a sparring partner rather than a ghostwriter. "Advantages and disadvantages" is not a position; band 9 names the condition that decides the outcome, in a balanced "where…; where…" structure. TR GRA
In conclusion, AI tools can improve education but they can also make students lazy. I believe that it depends on how the students use them. In short, AI neither improves nor damages education on its own: the effect is determined by whether institutions redesign their teaching around it or simply leave students to use it unsupervised. Band 6 repeats the question; band 9 synthesises and adds who is responsible, which the body has earned. TR CC
04
The method
The 8 upgrade moves behind every IELTS band 9 essay
The ten rows above come down to eight moves. Use them as a checklist on your own drafts.
Move What it means Band 6 → band 9
1. Precise position TR Say what you think, and under what condition, in the introduction; keep it stable. "I will give my opinion" → "AI helps, provided teaching is redesigned around it."
2. Topic sentences that argue CC The first sentence of a body paragraph makes a claim, not a topic. "There are many benefits." → "The main benefit is personalisation."
3. Specific examples TR A scenario with who, what, how often and the result. No statistics needed. "AI explains things." → "A tool that explains a concept three ways and responds at midnight."
4. Hedged generalisations GRA LR Soften absolute claims with tends to, appears to, in most cases . "Students will become lazy." → "Convenience tends to erode effort."
5. Referencing, not repetition CC Refer back with this concern, such tools, they instead of repeating the noun. "AI tools… AI tools… AI tools" → "AI tools… such systems… they".
6. Complex but accurate GRA Conditionals, relative clauses, concession, but only the ones you can write without error. "Students copy. They don't learn." → "If an essay can be generated in seconds, the process of forming an idea can be skipped."
7. Collocation over big words LR Words that belong together beat rare words used slightly wrongly. "make a big problem" → "pose a serious problem"; "utilise" → "use".
8. A conclusion that synthesises TR CC Combine the two views into the condition or consequence the body has proved; do not repeat the thesis. "It depends on how students use it." → "The effect depends on whether institutions redesign teaching or leave students unsupervised."
priority_high The order matters
Moves 1, 2 and 8 are planning decisions; make them before you write. Moves 3 to 7 are sentence-level. Adding "band 9 vocabulary" at the end is move 7 without moves 1 and 2: the essay stays at band 6 with harder words in it.
Band 6 habit Write first, then hunt for synonyms to "upgrade" the essay.
Band 9 habit Decide the position and each paragraph's claim first; vocabulary follows the argument.
05
Realistic target
Band 7 is the realistic bridge: two paragraphs rewritten
Most candidates are aiming for 7.0, and that is sensible: a band 7-style essay already has a clear position throughout, logical paragraphs, some less common vocabulary and a mix of complex sentences, with occasional errors that do not obscure meaning. Here are the band 6 introduction and second body paragraph rewritten at band 7.
Model essay C · extract
Band 7-style rewrite: introduction and body paragraph 2
The realistic middle step · 1 min read
Artificial intelligence is now widely used in education, and people disagree about its effects. Some believe it improves learning, while others argue that it makes students dependent and less able to think independently. In my view, AI can benefit education, but only if teachers show students how to use it as a support rather than a substitute for their own thinking.
However, critics argue that AI tools encourage laziness. When a student can generate a complete essay in seconds, they may skip the difficult process of planning and developing their own ideas, which is exactly where learning takes place. For example, a student who submits an AI-written assignment may receive a good grade without understanding the topic at all. In the long term, this dependence could weaken their ability to analyse problems and express opinions without assistance.
What band 7 does that band 6 does not What band 9 adds
A real position with a condition ("but only if…"). The condition runs through every paragraph and returns in the conclusion.
"This dependence", "they", "which" refer back instead of repeating "AI tools". Paragraphs link to each other ("That shift…", "Yet the same objection…") so the essay reads as one argument.
Hedges ("may", "could") and natural collocations ("encourage laziness", "weaken their ability"). Hedges, then evaluates the concern ("not hypothetical… yet…"); collocation plus controlled imagery ("sparring partner").
Mixes complex forms with safe simple sentences; a few slips remain. Sustains complex forms with no errors and varies sentence length deliberately.
06
Self-assessment
IELTS Writing Task 2 self-check rubric and common mistakes
A plain-language rubric for your next essay. It paraphrases what examiners look for and is not the official wording. Score each criterion honestly, then fix the lowest first.
Criterion Band 6 Band 7 Band 8–9
Task Response All parts answered but the position is unclear or appears only at the end; examples thin. Clear position throughout; main ideas extended, though some could go further. Precise, nuanced position; every idea developed with specific support.
Coherence & Cohesion Paragraphs exist; linkers are mechanical ("Firstly… Moreover"); nouns repeated. Each paragraph has one clear idea; linking mostly natural, a few overused devices. Progression feels effortless; cohesion carried by referencing and structure; linkers barely noticed.
Lexical Resource Adequate vocabulary; less common words often slightly wrong; some spelling errors. Some less common and topic vocabulary with collocation awareness; occasional errors. Wide, precise, natural vocabulary; rare slips at most.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Simple and complex sentences mixed; errors frequent but meaning clear. Variety of complex structures; most sentences error-free. Full range used naturally; errors rare and only slips.
Common mistakes when candidates try to "write band 9"
Mistake Why it costs marks Fix
Thesaurus words ("utilise", "plethora", "myriad") Rare words in the wrong collocation lower Lexical Resource rather than raising it. Choose the word that belongs with its neighbours: "pose a problem", "widen access".
Memorised openings ("In this modern era… a controversial issue…") Examiners recognise memorised language; it does not answer the question. Open with one specific sentence about the actual topic.
Position only in the conclusion Task Response wants a position that is clear from the start and maintained. Put the position, with its condition, in the introduction.
Long sentences that break One error in a 40-word sentence can make the whole idea unclear. One complex structure per sentence; check it; move on.
Writing 400 words to look thorough More words, more errors, less time to check; no credit for length beyond the minimum. Aim for 270–300 words and keep 4–5 minutes to check.
07
Practice
Practice: spot the higher-band sentence and rewrite a paragraph
Practice 1 · Choose the higher-band sentence
💡 Two sentences that do the same job. Choose the one an examiner would rate higher; the feedback names the move.
A. Nowadays, technology is very important in our life. B. Few areas of daily life remain untouched by technology, and education is no exception. Higher band:
A. Remote work has clear benefits for employers, chiefly lower office costs and access to talent beyond commuting distance. B. Remote work has many advantages for employers, for example it is good for them in many ways. Higher band:
A. Firstly, AI is good. Secondly, AI is useful. Thirdly, AI is helpful. B. AI's main educational value lies in instant, individual feedback. Higher band:
A. Heavy social-media use appears to be linked with poorer sleep among teenagers, though the cause is still debated. B. Everyone agrees that social media is bad for teenagers. Higher band:
A. Governments should invest in public transport. Public transport reduces traffic. Public transport is also cheaper for people. B. Governments should invest in public transport, which reduces congestion and, for most commuters, costs far less than running a car. Higher band:
A. This is a serious problem, and one that will only grow as populations age. B. This is a very big problem for the society and we must solve it. Higher band:
A. The utilisation of pedagogical AI implementations facilitates the augmentation of learner outcomes. B. Used well, AI tools can lift student performance. Higher band:
A. On balance, online learning widens access but cannot yet replace the discipline that a classroom imposes. B. In conclusion, there are advantages and disadvantages of online learning. Higher band:
You got 0 out of 8 correct.
Practice 2 · Which criterion does the change mainly improve?
💡 Each item describes one edit. Choose the criterion it most directly improves.
An introduction that ended "This essay will discuss both views" now ends "In my view, the benefits outweigh the risks, provided schools set clear rules." Criterion:
"AI tools" appeared four times in one paragraph; the later three are now "these tools", "such systems" and "they". Criterion:
"This will make a big problem" became "This will pose a serious problem." Criterion:
"Students use AI. They do not think. This is bad." became "Because students outsource their thinking to AI, they rarely practise the reasoning the exam is meant to test." Criterion:
A paragraph that said only "AI helps students a lot" now adds "a student who asks the tool to explain photosynthesis three different ways until one makes sense." Criterion:
"The government have been made many policy" became "The government has introduced many policies." Criterion:
You got 0 out of 6 correct.
Practice 3 · Rewrite a band 6 paragraph (90–120 words)
Upgrade body paragraph 1 of the band 6 essay
Rewrite this paragraph at band 7 or higher. Keep the ideas; change how they are expressed.
On the one hand, there are many people who think AI tools improve education. Firstly, AI tools can help students to do their homework faster. For example, students can ask AI to explain a difficult topic and AI will explain it. Secondly, AI tools are available all the time, so students can study at any time they want. Moreover, teachers can use AI tools to make their lessons more interesting and this is good for the students.
a topic sentence that makes one claim (move 2) one example with concrete detail (move 3) no sentence begins with Firstly , Secondly or Moreover "AI tools" at most twice, then referencing (move 5) two complex sentences you are sure are correct (move 6) one hedge: tends to, can, in most cases (move 4)
Word count: 0 words
Model answer (band 8-style, 98 words)
Supporters of AI in education point first to personalisation. A tool that can re-explain a concept in simpler terms, generate extra practice at the right level and respond at any hour offers each student something close to a private tutor, which most families could never afford. There are gains for teachers as well: once routine marking is automated, they can spend their limited classroom time on discussion and individual feedback, where their expertise matters most. Used in this way, such systems do not replace teaching; they free it.
Why it is higher: one claim per paragraph, a detailed example, "such systems / they / which" instead of repeating "AI tools", a correct colon and semicolon, and the hedge "something close to".
08
Final check
Quiz: can you tell a band 9 sentence from a band 6?
Eight questions on the moves and the criteria. Aim for 7 out of 8.
Question 1 of 8 Score: 0
0/8
Great work!
You can see the moves. Now use them.
Next step. Answer the Part 1 question in 40 minutes and score it with the Part 6 rubric. A teacher's mark on one essay shows which move is holding your band down; you can get one in a free trial lesson at fleydo.com/en/ielts .
Free material from Fleydo English School — one-to-one IELTS preparation online with native English-speaking teachers.
Band estimate in a free trial lesson: fleydo.com/en/ielts · Band calculator: fleydo.com/en/ielts/band-score-calculator
Lesson Plan
- Exam-style question on AI in education
- Band 6.0-style essay (about 265 words)
- Band 9-style essay (about 285 words) with highlighted vocabulary
Key Vocabulary
हमारी कक्षाओं में शामिल हों!
हम मानते हैं कि सही प्रश्न सही उत्तर लाते हैं। चाहे आपके पास अपनी अंग्रेजी सीखने की यात्रा के बारे में कोई प्रश्न हो, हम हमेशा यहां हैं।
