✂️ Grammar B2-27: Reduced relative clauses
One deletion with one precondition. When the relative pronoun is the subject of its own clause, English lets you delete it together with the form of be, leaving a participle attached straight to the noun: the man who is standing over there becomes the man standing over there, and the book which was written by an unknown hand becomes the book written by an unknown hand. This material makes the precondition the first question, because that is where learners fail — an object relative such as the film that we watched has a different, older licence and no participle is ever available to it. It then separates the two shapes the reduction produces: the -ing form when the noun does the action, the past participle when the noun receives it. A gallery wall panel shows why signage, museum labels, journalism and academic prose reduce almost automatically, and the contrast section weighs what is gained against what disappears with the auxiliary — the tense.
Text version of this lesson
Grammar B2-27: Reduced relative clauses
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus
B2
≈ 30 min
B2-27
① The idea
The passengers who are waiting → the passengers waiting
A relative clause is a small sentence parked behind a noun. Quite often two of its words are doing no work at all — the pronoun and the form of be — and English lets you lift them out. What is left is a participle hanging straight off the noun: the passengers waiting at gate 4 , the report submitted last week . The meaning does not change. The weight does: two words fewer, and the sentence reaches its real verb sooner. This is the sound of signage, notices, journalism and academic prose, and it is the single most common reason a B2 text reads as adult English rather than as a school exercise.
The full relative clause
the passengers who are waiting at gate 4
Says everything out loud: pronoun, tense, number.
Handles anything — modals, negatives, any tense you like.
The normal shape in conversation.
The reduced version
the passengers waiting at gate 4
who are is simply gone; waiting attaches to the noun.
Denser, flatter, more written. A boarding screen would print this.
Tense disappears with the auxiliary — see section ⑤.
the passengers who are waiting at gate 4
the report which was submitted last week
and with no be to delete: people who live nearby → people living nearby
One deletion, one precondition. You may cut the pronoun (and the be that follows it) only when that pronoun is the subject of its own clause. The film that we watched has a subject already — we — so nothing here applies to it. That sentence has its own, much older licence: an object pronoun may simply be dropped, which is what B1-15 taught. Two different deletions; do not let them collide.
② The form
Two shapes, and one that needs no be at all
Everything on this page produces one of two endings. If the noun does the action, the clause leaves an -ing form behind. If the noun receives it, the clause leaves the past participle — the third form: submitted , taken , shown , left . That is the whole inventory.
the lorries which are blocking the lane ·
the platform which was closed for repairs ·
anyone who is not travelling today
struck through = what you delete green = what survives
Full relative clause What goes Reduced Why it works
the passengers who are waiting at gate 4 who are the passengers waiting at gate 4 Subject pronoun + be . Active, so an -ing form is left.
the report which was submitted last week which was the report submitted last week Subject pronoun + be . Passive, so the past participle is left.
the crates that are being loaded now that are the crates being loaded now A passive still in progress keeps being — only that are leaves.
people who live nearby who + the tense people living nearby No be to delete, so the verb itself turns into the -ing form.
anyone who is not travelling today who is anyone not travelling today A negative reduces too. Not moves in front of the participle.
the woman who is in the grey coat who is the woman in the grey coat What survives need not be a participle — a prepositional phrase will do.
the students who are eligible for a grant who are the students eligible for a grant Nor need it be a verb at all: an adjective phrase can sit behind the noun.
the roof, which was installed in 2021, leaks which was the roof , installed in 2021, leaks Non-defining clauses reduce as well — but the two commas stay put.
the film that we screen on Thursdays — nothing — the film we screen on Thursdays Object relative. The pronoun may vanish; no participle is ever available.
The third form is not a tense here. Submitted , taken , left , shown look like past tenses, and they are not: in the report submitted last week the participle is passive and carries no time of its own. The time comes from the main verb of the sentence and from words such as last week . So the same phrase works in any tense — the report submitted last week names four suppliers , … will name four suppliers .
③ How to choose
Four questions, and the first one decides everything
Learners rarely get the participle wrong once they are allowed to build one. What goes wrong is being allowed at all. So ask question 1 first, every time, and answer it by looking at the word straight after the pronoun.
Is the pronoun the subject of its clause? Look at the next word. A verb — who are waiting , which was submitted , who live — means the pronoun is the subject, and reduction is available. A new subject instead — that we screen , which the auditors rejected — means it is an object relative. Stop there. You may drop the pronoun, and that is all.
Is there a form of be inside the clause? If yes, delete the pronoun and the be together, in one movement. Whatever is left — waiting at gate 4 , submitted last week , in the grey coat , eligible for a grant — attaches straight to the noun.
If there is no be, is the clause active? Then the verb itself becomes the -ing form: people who live nearby → people living nearby ; anyone who wants a catalogue → anyone wanting a catalogue .
Does the noun do it, or receive it? The noun that acts takes -ing ; the noun that is acted on takes the past participle . The officers questioning the witness asked the questions. The officer questioned by the panel answered them. And if the clause sat between commas, keep the commas .
Sentence
The delegates who are waiting in the atrium have been told that the session which was scheduled for two o’clock will start late.
Clause 1
who are waiting — the word after who is are , a verb, so who is the subject. There is a be , and the delegates do the waiting: cut who are and keep the -ing form.
Clause 2
which was scheduled — again a verb straight after the pronoun, again a be . But nobody schedules itself: the session was scheduled by somebody, so the past participle survives.
Answer
The delegates waiting in the atrium have been told that the session scheduled for two o’clock will start late. Four words lighter, and both main verbs now arrive early enough to be found.
Sentence
The article that I read on the train quoted a scientist who works at the same lab.
Clause 1
that I read — the word after that is I , a brand-new subject. This is an object relative, so question 1 stops the process dead. The article reading on the train is not a shorter version of anything; it is nonsense.
Clause 2
who works — a verb next, so who is the subject. There is no be anywhere, so question 3 applies: the verb itself becomes working .
Answer
The article I read on the train quoted a scientist working at the same lab. Two deletions, two different rules: the first clause lost only its pronoun, the second was genuinely reduced.
④ Practice 1
Build the participle
Eight items on the shape alone. For each one, decide whether the noun acts or is acted on, then pick the form. 0 / 8
⑤ The contrast
Keep the clause, or cut it?
Both versions below are correct English. They are not, however, interchangeable, and the thing that separates them is not grammar but what the reader needs.
Full clause
The visitors who were standing in front of the mural blocked the doorway.
Explicit about time: were standing pins the scene in the past, before the blocking. It can also carry things a participle cannot — a modal ( who can read the label ), a perfect ( who had already left ), a different subject. And it is what a listener expects: in speech the full clause is the unmarked choice.
Reduced
The visitors standing in front of the mural blocked the doorway.
Two words lighter and noticeably more written. The reader gets to the real verb, blocked , sooner, which is why notices, museum labels, news copy and research papers reduce almost automatically. The cost is that the tense has gone: standing could be is , was or has been standing .
Reduce by default in writing, and keep the full clause when the deleted words were carrying something. They are carrying something whenever the clause holds a modal, a perfect, a negative you want the reader to notice, or a tense that contrasts with the main verb — the man who was standing there and the man who is standing there both reduce to the man standing there , so if that difference matters, do not throw it away. Keep it too when the participle would land far from its noun, or when you are speaking: that’s the man standing outside our flat all morning sounds like a caption read aloud.
Six items on the decision itself: is reduction even available, and if it is, is it the better sentence? 0 / 6
⑥ In context
A gallery text, written the way galleries write
This is the wall panel for a small photography room in a converted grain store. Reduction is not a stylistic flourish here — it is simply how the register works. Tap any coloured phrase to see why it looks the way it does. Green means the clause was reduced, blue means it could not be, amber is the comma case.
The room you are standing in was built as a grain store in 1868. The iron columns supporting the upper floor are original; the glass roof installed in 2021 replaced a corrugated one that leaked. Odile Kastrup, appointed curator in 2019 , rehung the whole collection herself.
Most of the prints shown in this gallery were made within a mile of the door. The photograph on the far wall — a queue of women waiting outside a bakery — is the only one whose photographer we have never identified . Visitors who grew up on Ferrier Street often stand in front of it for a long time.
Anyone wishing to photograph the prints may do so without flash. Bags left unattended will be removed. The short film we screen on Thursdays uses footage shot from a tram in 1961 .
Tap a highlighted phrase and its reason appears here.
⑦ Practice 2
Real registers: labels, news, notices, reports
Eight harder items, and one of them cannot be reduced at all — question 1 is still what catches it. 0 / 8
⑧ Sort
Reduce it, or leave it alone
Twelve relative clauses. Send each one to the bin that fits: some can lose their pronoun and turn into a participle, and some are stuck with the words they have. Tap a clause and read the reason. 0 / 12
Keeps its full clause
Reduces to a participle
Tap a clause to sort it and read the reason.
⑨ Fix it
Six sentences a real B2 writer produces
Every one of these comes from trying to reduce. Tap a line to see the repair and the question that would have prevented it.
⑩ Watch out
Five ways this goes wrong
Reducing an object relative
The novel reading on the beach was hers.
The novel I read on the beach was hers.
The word after the pronoun was I , so the clause already had a subject and the pronoun was only its object. Object relatives lose the pronoun and nothing else. Ask question 1 before you build any participle.
-ing where the noun is the one being acted on
The man arresting at the border was released the same night.
The man arrested at the border was released the same night.
An -ing form says the noun did it — the officers arresting him are the ones doing the arresting. If somebody did it to the noun, the past participle is the only form available.
Losing the commas of a non-defining clause
Odile Kastrup appointed curator in 2019 rehung the collection.
Odile Kastrup, appointed curator in 2019, rehung the collection.
Reduction deletes the pronoun and the be . It never deletes punctuation. Without the commas the phrase reads as a label picking out which Kastrup is meant — and there is only one.
Deleting the pronoun but keeping the auxiliary
The crates are being loaded now are for the Bergen show.
The crates being loaded now are for the Bergen show.
The pronoun and the be leave together, in one movement. Leave are behind and the sentence grows a second main verb, which is why the reader stalls halfway through it.
Cutting the pronoun off a clause that has no be
The staff work in the basement have been moved upstairs.
The staff working in the basement have been moved upstairs.
With no be in the clause there is nothing to delete alongside the pronoun, so the verb has to change shape itself. A bare tensed verb left behind a noun always produces this collision of two main verbs.
⑪ Quick test
Eight items, no hints
Mixed shapes, mixed registers, and one clause that refuses to reduce. 0 / 8
Answer all eight to see how you did.
Teacher notes · B2-27 Reduced relative clauses
Forty-five minutes. 0–5: write the passengers who are waiting at gate 4 on the board and cross out two words in front of the class. 5–15: sections ① and ②, with the class supplying the participle for six more clauses. 15–22: section ③, running question 1 aloud on every clause. 22–30: Practice 1 and the contrast. 30–38: the gallery text in ⑥ read as a wall panel, then the sorter. 38–45: Fix it and the quick test.
The board move that works. Draw one column headed next word . Under it write only the word that follows each pronoun: are , we , was , the auditors , live , I . Ask for a show of hands: verb or new subject? The class sorts twelve clauses in ninety seconds without producing a single participle, and the precondition is learned before the form is.
Stuck-learner rescue. Nearly every wrong answer is the active/passive mix-up, not the deletion. Hand the learner one question: does this noun do it, or does somebody do it to this noun? Then the pair the officers questioning the witness / the officer questioned by the panel , out loud, twice. If the mistake is instead the novel reading on the beach , go back to question 1 rather than to the participle — the form was never the problem.
Do not let this merge with B2-26. Participle clauses there open a sentence and replace a conjunction — Feeling tired, she went to bed — and their subject is the subject of the main clause. Reduced relatives sit after a noun and modify only that noun. Same participles, different job, different position; learners who blur them start writing dangling openers.
Cambridge B2 First. Reading and Use of English Part 4 (key word transformation) and Part 2 (open cloze) both test this — a gapped the report ___ last week wants one word, and it is the participle. It is also the fastest way to lose two or three words in a Writing Part 1 essay that has run long, so it belongs in exam-preparation writing feedback, not only in the grammar slot.
Follow-up refs. B1-15 (defining relatives and the object-pronoun drop) is the direct prerequisite; B1-31 and B2-10 supply the commas and the full pronoun range. B2-26 is the adverbial sibling. B2-28 and B2-29 continue the same B2.2 theme: shaping a sentence so the important part arrives where the reader needs it.
Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus A1–B2 · topic B2-27
Lesson Plan
- Two words in a relative clause often do no work: the pronoun and the form of be.
- The full clause and the reduced version side by side, with what each one buys.
- The precondition stated at once: subject relatives only.
Key Vocabulary
Grammar Points
- Subject relative + be: delete the pronoun and be together, leaving a participle, prepositional phrase or adjective phrase — the passengers waiting at gate 4, the woman in the grey coat.
- Active clauses leave an -ing form, passive clauses leave the past participle — the officers questioning the witness versus the officer questioned by the panel.
- A subject relative with no be still reduces: the verb itself becomes the -ing form — people who live nearby, people living nearby.
- Negatives and progressive passives survive the cut: anyone not travelling today, the crates being loaded now.
- Non-defining clauses reduce and keep both commas: Odile Kastrup, appointed curator in 2019, rehung the collection.
- Object relatives, whose-clauses, where-clauses and clauses built on a modal cannot be reduced — only the object pronoun may be dropped.
Prerequisites
हमारी कक्षाओं में शामिल हों!
हम मानते हैं कि सही प्रश्न सही उत्तर लाते हैं। चाहे आपके पास अपनी अंग्रेजी सीखने की यात्रा के बारे में कोई प्रश्न हो, हम हमेशा यहां हैं।
