📖 Lesson B2 Grammar📐 Grammar

⚖️ Grammar B2-5: Present perfect simple vs continuous

At B1 the present perfect continuous arrived as the tense that points at the activity rather than the score. This material assumes all of that and goes after the part B1 could not afford: the places where both forms are grammatical and the choice is about what the sentence is for. It opens on Kirsten, an architect who spent Tuesday on one drawing and can say two true things about it at six o’clock — I’ve revised the roof plan hands over a finished thing, I’ve been revising the roof plan hands over a day — and a dual timeline that lays the continuous’s dashed stretch above the simple’s single standing result. After a two-minute form check with both shapes side by side, including the been-plus-participle passive that is neither of them, the lesson is organised as four axes, each with its own compare-and-verdict pair. Axis one is result against activity: what the listener walks away with. Axis two is count against duration, the most mechanical rule on the page — eleven versions, twelve emails, the third time, the best so far all force the simple, because you cannot count unfinished things. Axis three is permanent against temporary, and it is deliberately honest: with live, work, stay, teach and study plus for or since, both forms are correct and the continuous merely tints the arrangement provisional, so several items argue from tone rather than rules and say so. Axis four is evidence against announcement — you’ve been running, read off a pink face, against I’ve run a marathon, delivered as news. A state-verb gate runs before all four, because own, know, belong and contain refuse -ing whatever the period. Three worked runs include a single sentence that legitimately takes both tenses in its two clauses. A 128-word catch-up between two architects outside a building site carries thirteen tappable choices, and practice runs to forty-one explained multiple-choice items in five sets, twelve fragments to sort by score-focus and time-focus, six real B2 errors to repair, and four traps. Teacher notes give a 45-minute sequence, a two-column board move, the number test and the evidence test as rescues, and Cambridge B2 First relevance.

🎒 Teens (11–16) 🧑‍💼 Adults (17+) 30 min Challenging 15
FREE
Text version of this lesson

Grammar B2-5: Present perfect simple vs continuous

Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus

B2

≈ 30 min

B2-5

① The idea

Same work, same week — the result or the time it took

Kirsten spent Tuesday on one drawing. At six o’clock she can say two true things about that day, and English makes her choose which one to say. I’ve revised the roof plan puts a finished thing on the table: here it is, take it to the client. I’ve been revising the roof plan puts a day on the table instead: that is where Tuesday went, and no, it still isn’t right. Neither sentence is more correct than the other. They point at different things, and at B2 that pointing is the grammar.

Present perfect simple

have / has + past participle

hands over a result : the drawing, the decision, the fixed boiler

reports a count or a total: eleven versions, twelve emails

announces news : I’ve run a marathon

treats an arrangement as settled : she’s lived here all her life

Present perfect continuous

have / has + been + verb-ing

points at the activity and where the hours went

measures duration : since March, for a fortnight, all day

reads visible evidence : you’ve been running!

tints an arrangement temporary : he’s been living with us

the continuous lays a stretch of doing against now

the simple stands one finished outcome at now

have / has + been + verb- ing → the hours, the effort, the traces

have / has + past participle → the outcome, the score, the news

At B2 the question is almost never “which one is legal?” Both usually are. The question is what the sentence is for — and four things decide it: result or activity, count or duration, permanent or temporary, evidence or announcement. Sections ④ and ⑤ take them one at a time.

② The form

Two shapes off one auxiliary

You built both of these at B1, so this table is a two-minute check, not a lesson. Everything hangs off have or has . The simple adds a past participle straight after it; the continuous slides been in first and then puts -ing on the verb. Only the auxiliary ever changes for the person — been serves everybody without moving.

Person Simple — the result Continuous — the activity

I I ’ve revised the drawings. I ’ve been revising the drawings.

you You ’ve read the brief. You ’ve been reading the brief.

he / she / it She ’s sent the invoice. She ’s been sending invoices.

we We ’ve fixed the leak. We ’ve been fixing the leak.

they They ’ve waited an hour. They ’ve been waiting an hour.

Shape Simple Continuous

negative I haven’t slept since Sunday. I haven’t been sleeping well.

question Have you finished the model? Have you been working on the model?

how long How long have you known her? How long have you been working here?

short answer Yes, I have . / No, we haven’t . Yes, I have . / No, we haven’t .

The contraction that catches people out: in She’s been sending invoices , the ’s is short for has , never for is . In front of been , ’s can only mean has. And notice the short answers: whichever form the question used, the reply stops at the auxiliary — Have you been waiting long? — Yes, I have.

Two participles that look alike and are not: I’ve been working is the continuous, built on been + -ing . I’ve been asked is a passive, built on been + past participle . So I’ve been finished the drawings is neither — if you mean the result, drop been: I’ve finished the drawings .

③ Practice 1

The machinery, checked once

Eight items on the parts: have or has, been, -ing, the negatives, the questions and the state verbs that never reach the four axes at all. 0 / 8

④ The first two axes

Axis 1 — what got done, or where the day went

This is the axis everything else grows out of. Kirsten has been at one desk with one drawing since Monday morning. Both sentences below are true of that fact, and they say completely different things to the person who hears them.

simple — the thing exists now

I ’ve revised the roof plan.

The revision is a thing in the world: printed, saved, ready to be argued about. The sentence hands it over. Nobody hearing it asks how long it took, because the hours are not what the sentence is pointing at.

continuous — that is where the time went

I ’ve been revising the roof plan.

This is an answer to what have you been doing? and often to why haven’t you done anything else? It accounts for the hours, and it quietly leaves the drawing unfinished — because if it were finished, you would have said so.

Verdict: ask what the listener walks away with. A finished object, decision or piece of news → simple . An explanation of how a stretch of time was spent → continuous . That is also why the continuous so often carries an unspoken and it isn’t done yet : a speaker with a result to report would have reported it.

Axis 2 — a number, or a length of time

The second axis is the most mechanical one on the page, and it overrides your instincts. You can only count things that are finished, so the moment a number, a total or a whole appears, the sentence is a scoreboard — and scoreboards are the simple’s.

simple — a count of finished units

I ’ve sent twelve emails this morning.

Twelve emails exist and have gone. Half an email is not one email, so a count is made of completed things and pulls the tense with it. The same happens with totals, ordinals and superlatives: the third time I’ve called , the best coffee I’ve had .

continuous — a stretch with no total

I ’ve been sending emails all morning.

No number, and none wanted. All morning , since eight , for a fortnight , on and off for months — expressions that measure a period lean hard on the continuous, because a period is exactly what it was built to hold.

Verdict: if a number is in the sentence, stop deciding — write the simple . If the only measurement is a length of time, the continuous is the natural home. And watch what happens when you take the number out: I’ve been sending emails is fine, I’ve been sending twelve emails is not.

Eight items on those two axes only — results against hours, counts against lengths. 0 / 8

⑤ The second two axes

Axis 3 — a fact of somebody’s life, or an arrangement with an end

With live , work , stay , teach and study , the tense stops reporting facts and starts colouring them. Both forms are grammatical. What the continuous adds is a sense that the situation is a phase — something with edges, something that could stop.

simple — this is simply how it is

She ’s lived in that street all her life.

Permanent, settled, part of who she is. All her life makes the point explicit, but the simple would carry it anyway: the sentence treats the arrangement as a fixed fact rather than a stage she is passing through.

continuous — for now, and not for ever

He ’s been living with us while his flat is painted.

A phase with a visible end. The continuous is doing tone work here, not grammar work: it says temporarily , and the while clause simply confirms what the tense had already implied.

Verdict: when the verb is one of the long-stay ones and the sentence carries for or since , both forms are correct and you are choosing a tone. Simple = settled, biographical, the CV line. Continuous = provisional, personal, this-phase-of-my-life. I’ve worked here for six years and I’ve been working here for six years report the same six years — the second one sounds more like a story you are still in the middle of.

Be honest about this one. There is no rule to break here. If a colleague says I’ve been teaching at this school since 2014 and another says I’ve taught at this school since 2014 , neither has made an error, and no examiner will mark either wrong. The difference is a shade: the continuous keeps the speaker inside the experience, the simple stands back and states the record.

Axis 4 — I can see it, or I’m telling you

The last axis is the one that most often decides real conversation. Are you reading something off a person or a room — mud, dust, red eyes, an empty biscuit tin — or are you delivering news the listener could not have guessed?

continuous — reading the evidence

You ’ve been running !

Said to somebody pink in the face and out of breath. The speaker is not reporting a distance; they are explaining a state they can see. The same tense carries mild accusation: Who’s been using my mug? — there is a coffee ring, and somebody is going to answer for it.

simple — announcing an achievement

I ’ve run a marathon.

News. A whole marathon, finished, on the record — and it may have been three years ago, with no trace of it in the room. The simple delivers achievements, firsts and life experience, because those are results, not activities in progress.

Verdict: if the sentence explains something visible — the dust, the breathlessness, the missing biscuits — reach for the continuous . If it announces a completed feat or a piece of news, reach for the simple . Notice how the meaning flips with one word: You’ve been running reads the state of you; You’ve run twenty kilometres reads the tracker.

Nine items on axes three and four, including several where both forms are correct and you are choosing tone. 0 / 9

⑥ How to choose

Four questions, always in this order

Before the four questions, one gate: is the verb a state verb? Know, own, believe, belong, contain, mean, cost, seem, deserve — situations you are in rather than things you do. They refuse -ing outright, so if the verb is one of those, the simple takes the sentence and you can stop. Everything else goes through the list below, in order, because the earlier questions overrule the later ones.

Result or activity? Is there something finished to hand over — a drawing, a decision, a repaired boiler — or are you explaining where a stretch of time went? A result takes the simple. An account of the hours takes the continuous.

Is there a count? Eleven versions, twelve emails, twice, the third time, the whole report. Numbers, totals, ordinals and superlatives are made of finished units, and they force the simple even when the work is obviously still going on.

Permanent or temporary? With live, work, stay, teach, study, both forms are correct. Ask whether the situation is a settled fact of the person’s life or a phase with edges. Settled leans simple; provisional leans continuous.

Evidence or announcement? Are you explaining something you can see in front of you, or delivering news? Visible traces call the continuous. Achievements, firsts and finished feats call the simple.

Sentence

Camille ___ (interview) engineers all week, and she ___ (speak) to nine of them so far.

Gate

Interview and speak are things you do — you can watch them happening — so the continuous is available for both.

Question 1

The first clause explains how the week was spent; the second hands over a running total. Different jobs, so the two clauses will not take the same tense.

Question 2

Nine is a count in the second clause, and a count overrules everything after it. The first clause has only all week — a length, not a number.

Answer

Camille has been interviewing engineers all week, and she has spoken to nine of them so far. One sentence, both tenses, no contradiction.

Sentence

Rasmus ___ (work) at the studio since 2019.

Questions 1–2

No finished object is being handed over and there is no count anywhere — so nothing yet forces the simple.

Question 3

This is the honest one. Work with since takes both forms, so the decision is tone. Is this the settled fact of his career, or the phase he happens to be in?

Answer

Both are correct. Has worked if you are reading out his record — the line on the staff page. Has been working if the story is still open: he arrived in 2019, he is still there this morning, and he might not be there next year.

Sentence

Your sleeves are white to the elbow. — I ___ (sand) the ceiling.

Question 1

Nothing is being handed over. The sentence exists to explain the sleeves.

Question 4

Pure evidence: the speaker is accounting for a visible state, not reporting that a ceiling is finished — and it plainly is not.

Answer

I ’ve been sanding the ceiling. Swap in I’ve sanded the ceiling and the sleeves stop being explained: that version says the job is done and invites you to go and look at it.

⑦ In context

Two architects catch up outside a building site

A hundred and thirty words in which almost every choice could have gone the other way — and didn’t. Tap any coloured phrase and read why that form was chosen.

— Kirsten! I haven’t seen you since March. What have you been doing with yourself?

— Surviving. We ’ve been rebuilding the old market hall since the spring, and the deadline has moved twice. I ’ve drawn eleven versions of the roof.

— You look exhausted.

— I ’ve been sleeping about five hours a night. But we ’ve finally passed the fire inspection, so the worst is over.

— And Rasmus?

— He ’s been living in my spare room while his flat is rewired, and he ’s been complaining about the noise for a fortnight. Though he ’s fixed the boiler and repainted the hall, so he can stay.

— How long has he had that flat?

— He ’s owned it for fourteen years. He ’s just never finished it.

Tap any coloured phrase above. Green = the continuous and its hours · blue = the simple and its results · orange = a state verb, which has no choice to make.

⑧ Practice 2

All four axes at once

Harder, and in real scenes. Run the gate and then the four questions before you tap — and remember that one of these has no wrong answer, only a better-sounding one. 0 / 8

⑨ Sort it

Score-focus or time-focus?

Twelve fragments you might meet inside a sentence. Ask of each one: is it counting something, or is it measuring a stretch? Tap a fragment and it moves into its box. 0 / 12

score-focus → the simple

time-focus → the continuous

Start with eleven versions . Can you put a number on it, or only a clock?

⑩ Fix the mistake

Six sentences to repair

Six errors out of real B2 writing — not one of them is a spelling slip. Tap a sentence to see the repair and the reasoning.

⑪ Watch out

The four traps at this level

Three of these are hard rules that beat every axis on the page. The fourth is the one that costs marks in speaking, because it sounds so reasonable.

Trap 1 · state verbs refuse -ing, whatever the period

He’s been owning that flat for fourteen years.

He’s owned that flat for fourteen years.

Know, own, believe, belong, contain, mean, cost, seem, deserve — these name situations, not activities, and nothing that is not being done can wear -ing. Length of time changes nothing: fourteen years of owning is still owning. Watch have especially: How long have you had that car? is possession and takes the simple, while having lunch is an activity and does not.

Trap 2 · a number beats every other instinct

I’ve been sending twelve emails this morning.

I’ve sent twelve emails this morning.

The morning-long slog is real and the continuous feels right — but you cannot count unfinished emails, so the number takes the sentence. If you want the hours instead, remove the score: I’ve been sending emails all morning . The same trap wears other clothes: the third time , twice , the whole thing , the best I’ve had .

Trap 3 · the present cannot reach back over for or since

I’m working on this report since Monday.

I’ve been working on this report since Monday.

The present continuous only sees this minute; it has no arm long enough to reach back to Monday. Any stretch that starts in the past and touches now needs a perfect form. This is a B1 leak, and it is still the single most flagged error in B2 writing — check every for and since in your work before you hand it in.

Trap 4 · a result verb has no stretch to measure

I’ve been finding my keys, so we can leave.

I’ve found my keys, so we can leave.

Find, break, arrive, lose, notice, decide, win — these happen at a point, not across a period, so there is no doing to lay against the clock. The activity that led up to them is a different verb, and that one takes the continuous happily: I’ve been looking for my keys for twenty minutes, and I’ve finally found them .

⑫ Quick test

Eight questions, no colours, no hints

Gate first, then the four questions, silently, for every item. 0 / 8

Answer all eight to see how you did.

Teacher notes

Sequence (45 min): §1 read the two cards aloud and put one line on the board — both are legal; they point at different things — 4 min. §2 skim only; this class has built both forms before, 3 min. §3 the two compare boxes, then the eight items in pairs with reasons said aloud, 8 min. §4 the axis-3 honesty box read twice, then the nine items, 8 min. §5 the gate and the four questions on the board, all three worked runs called out by the class, 6 min. §6 alone, 4 min. §7 read the dialogue in pairs, then tap and challenge, 5 min. §8 alone, 4 min. §9 as a two-team race, 2 min. §10 and §11 in pairs, 4 min. §12 silent, as the exit ticket, 5 min — takeaway: a six-line progress report on something they are actually doing, containing at least one count, one duration and one piece of evidence.

The board move that works: write one fact — Kirsten. Roof drawing. Monday to Friday. — and then build four pairs of sentences off it, one pair per axis, in two columns headed WHAT EXISTS NOW and WHERE THE TIME WENT. The class supplies the sentences; you only supply the column. By the fourth pair they stop asking which is correct and start asking which one they mean, which is the whole objective of the lesson.

If a learner is stuck, use the number test and then the evidence test, in that order. First: can you add a number to your sentence? If the number fits, the sentence was a scoreboard and wants the simple. Second: could the sentence answer why do you look like that? If it could, it is evidence, and evidence takes the continuous. For the live/work/teach group, refuse to give a rule — ask instead whether they would be surprised if the person left next month.

The mixed-tense sentence is worth ten minutes on its own if the class is strong: I’ve been marking essays all weekend and I’ve finished eleven of them. One clause for the hours, one for the score. Learners who can produce that sentence unprompted have understood the topic, and it is exactly the kind of sentence that lifts a Writing answer out of the B1 band.

Cambridge B2 First: the pair is standard in Reading and Use of English Part 4 (key word transformations often force How long have you been…? against a count) and in Part 2 open cloze, where been is a favourite gap. In Speaking Part 1 the examiner’s how long have you been studying English? expects the continuous, and in Writing Part 1 an unchecked I am living here since… is one of the most common accuracy penalties at this level.

Comes from: B1-1 (for / since), B1-3 (present perfect vs past simple), B1-21 (the continuous introduced). Next: B2-2 (past perfect continuous — this contrast pushed one step back) and B2-19 (narrative tenses, where the same choice shapes a whole paragraph).

Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus A1–B2 · topic B2-5

Lesson Plan

  • One architect, one Tuesday, two true sentences — and the pointing is the grammar
  • Side-by-side cards for what each form does: results, counts, news, settled facts against hours, durations, evidence, phases
  • A dual timeline: the continuous’s dashed stretch above the simple’s single standing result

Key Vocabulary

have / has + past participlehave / has been + verb-inga resultan activitya countdurationpermanenttemporaryevidencean announcementa state verban ordinal

Grammar Points

  • result against activity: I’ve revised the roof plan / I’ve been revising the roof plan
  • counts, totals, ordinals and superlatives force the simple: I’ve sent twelve emails, it’s the third time I’ve called
  • durations lean continuous: since the spring, all week, for a fortnight, on and off for months
  • permanent against temporary with live, work, stay, teach, study — both forms correct, the continuous tinting the situation provisional
  • evidence against announcement: you’ve been running / I’ve run a marathon
  • state verbs refuse -ing whatever the period: he’s owned it for fourteen years, how long have you had that ring?

আমাদের ক্লাসে যোগ দিন!

আমরা বিশ্বাস করি সঠিক প্রশ্ন সঠিক উত্তর নিয়ে আসে। আপনার ইংরেজি শেখার যাত্রা সম্পর্কে কোনো প্রশ্ন থাকলে, আমরা সবসময় এখানে আছি।

মোবাইল অ্যাপ

Fleydo English School আপনার পকেটে

Fleydo-র শিক্ষার্থী ও অভিভাবকদের জন্য ক্লাস, হোমওয়ার্ক, মেসেজ ও গেম। iPhone ও Android-এ বিনামূল্যে।

App Store থেকে ডাউনলোড করুনএটি Google Play তে পান
অ্যাপ সম্পর্কে আরও জানুন
QR কোড, যা App Store বা Google Play-তে Fleydo English School অ্যাপ খোলেডাউনলোড করতে স্ক্যান করুনআপনার ফোনের জন্য সঠিক স্টোর খুলে দেয়।fleydo.com/app
FleyPath

আপনার সন্তানের ব্যক্তিগত রোডম্যাপ — ৩, ৬ বা ১২ মাস

🚀শুরু
👋Hello
😊Body
🦁Animals
🔢Numbers
🏆আত্মবিশ্বাসী ইংরেজি
গেমিফায়েড ইংরেজি অনুশীলন

একটি গেমের মতো — কিন্তু তারা সত্যিই শিখছে