📖 Lesson B1 Grammar📐 Grammar

📅 Grammar B1-1: Present perfect with for / since

The first material of the Fleydo B1 grammar series, and the point where the present perfect stops being about experience and starts measuring time. The opening image is a line drawn from a past moment to now: Maya has had her dog Conker for six years, a sentence that holds the day he arrived and this morning together. The choice between for and since is taught as one question — is the phrase a length you could count, or the moment the period began? — and the choice of tense as another: does the period still touch today? A full form table covers every person with negatives, questions and short answers, the ’s-means-has contraction, and How long…?, the question that owns this grammar, with its two equally true answers. Two worked runs walk whole sentences through the three-question procedure, including since followed by a past-simple clause: since he was nine. The compare-and-verdict pair is the heart of the material — she has lived in Marbury for two years against she lived in Marbury for two years, the same for, a different life — and seven items drill exactly that line. A 125-word tap-and-explain text about Maya’s town, best friend, sister and dog shows open periods, sealed periods and their time phrases working together. Practice runs to thirty-one multiple-choice items in four sets, all explained, plus twelve time phrases to sort into for and since boxes, six real learner errors to repair, and three traps: since with a length, the present simple leaking under a since-period, and the clause after since. Teacher notes give a 45-minute sequence, the ruler-and-pin board move, the calendar rescue for a stuck learner, and Cambridge B1 Preliminary relevance.

🎒 Teens (11–16) 🧑‍💼 Adults (17+) 30 min Medium 36
FREE
Text version of this lesson

Grammar B1-1: Present perfect with for / since

Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus

B1

≈ 30 min

B1-1

① The idea

It started back then — and it is still true now

Maya got her dog Conker six years ago. He is asleep on her bed right now. English has one tense whose whole job is to hold those two facts together: Maya has had Conker for six years. That sentence is not about the day he arrived, and not only about today — it measures the unbroken stretch of time between them.

Maya + has had + Conker + for six years .

who have / has + third form what the period

the starting point — where since looks

the length of the line — what for measures

have / has + past participle + for + a length of time → for six years · for ten minutes

have / has + past participle + since + a starting point → since 2020 · since I was eight

The period must reach now. For and since draw a line from a point in the past all the way to this moment, and only the present perfect can stand on a line like that. The moment the period is over — she left, he stopped, it ended — the line is cut, and the past simple takes the sentence instead. That cut is the whole of section ⑤.

② The form

Have or has, the participle, then the period

Two words make the tense. The first is have or has — the auxiliary, the helper word — and it is the only part that changes with the person. Behind it stands the past participle, the third form of the verb, and it never moves for anybody. The for / since phrase usually sits at the end, and it survives negatives and questions unchanged.

Person Statement Negative Question Short answer

I I ’ve had this bike for three years. I haven’t had it for long. Have I had it for three years? Yes, you have .

you You ’ve known Finn since Year 4. You haven’t known him since Year 3. Have you known him since Year 4? Yes, I have .

he / she / it She ’s worked there for four months. She hasn’t worked there for a year. Has she worked there since March? Yes, she has .

we We ’ve lived here since 2021. We haven’t lived here for long. Have we lived here that long? Yes, we have .

they They ’ve been friends for ten years. They haven’t spoken since Friday. Have they been friends for long? No, they haven’t .

Read the third row twice: in She’s worked there for four months , the ’s is short for has , not is . Whenever ’s stands in front of a past participle, it is has — “she is worked” does not exist in English.

The question that owns this grammar

How long + has + Ella + worked there?

the question phrase have / has who the rest

How long…? asks about the size of an open period, and it accepts two different true answers: For four months — the length — or Since March — the moment it began. Both draw the same line to now; answer with whichever you happen to know.

The slip that costs the most marks: the present simple. “She works there for four months” sounds harmless, but the present simple can only describe this moment — it has no arm long enough to reach back to March. A period that starts in the past and touches today always rides on have / has + participle : she has worked there for four months.

③ How to choose

Three questions, always in this order

Do not choose by ear — at this level your ear still votes for the present simple. Run these three questions instead, every time, until they run themselves.

Is the period still running? Find the stretch of time in the sentence and ask whether it touches today. Still her job, still your friend, still true this morning → present perfect. Over and sealed → past simple, and you can stop reading this list.

Length or starting point? If you could measure the phrase — six years, ten minutes, half my life — it is a length, and a length takes for . If it names the moment everything began — 2021, last spring, my ninth birthday — it is a starting point, and a starting point takes since .

Is the starting point a whole clause? Since happily takes a little sentence: since I was six , since we moved here . That clause names one finished past moment, so it stays in the past simple — only the main clause carries the present perfect.

Sentence

Finn ___ (play) the drums ___ he was nine.

Question 1

Does the playing reach now? His kit is set up in the garage and he practised yesterday evening, so the period is open: have / has + participle , and Finn is a he — has played .

Question 2

“He was nine” measures nothing — you cannot count a he-was-nine of time. It names the moment the playing began, so it is a starting point: since .

Question 3

The starting point here is a whole clause, and it stays in the past simple: he was nine , never he has been nine .

Answer

Finn has played the drums since he was nine — and the whole street knows it.

Sentence

Ella ___ (work) at the pool café ___ four months.

Question 1

She is there every Saturday, including tomorrow. The period is open, Ella is a she — has worked .

Question 2

Four months is a measurement — you could count the days on a calendar. A length takes for .

Answer

Ella has worked at the pool café for four months . “Since four months” would need a moment on the calendar called four months — and no such moment exists.

④ Practice 1

For, since, have, has

Eight items on the machinery. Ask question 2 every time: could I measure this phrase, or does it name a moment? 0 / 8

⑤ The contrast

Same for, different tense, different life

For works with both tenses, and that is exactly where it turns dangerous. Read these two sentences about Maya’s aunt slowly — every word is identical except the tense, and they describe two different lives.

has lived — she is still there

She has lived in Marbury for two years.

The period is open: it started two years ago and it touches this morning. Ring her doorbell in Marbury today and she will answer it.

lived — she is gone

She lived in Marbury for two years.

The same two years, but sealed. The past simple cuts the period off from now: she moved away, and the sentence quietly tells you so without a single extra word.

Verdict: for only measures the period — it never says whether the period is finished. The tense says that. Open and touching now → has lived . Closed, however long it lasted → lived . So hunt for the clue that seals a period: she left , before , until , a finished year.

Seven items on exactly that line. Every sentence carries a clue that leaves the period open or seals it — find the clue first. 0 / 7

⑥ In context

Maya introduces everybody

Every coloured phrase below was chosen, not guessed. Tap one and read the reason underneath.

I ’ve lived in Westbrook since I was nine , and my best friend here is Finn. We ’ve known each other since Year 4 , when we both joined the chess club. The club closed after one term — the friendship didn’t.

Finn has played the drums since his ninth birthday , which means his neighbours have put up with the noise for six loud years. My sister Ella has worked at the pool café for four months . Before that she worked at the cinema for a whole year , but she left in January because the pay was terrible.

And Conker? He has been part of this family since the day we found him at the shelter: six years, one sofa, roughly ten thousand biscuits.

Tap any coloured phrase above. Green = an open period (present perfect) · blue = a sealed one (past simple) · orange = the for / since phrase itself.

⑦ Practice 2

Real sentences, all three questions at once

Harder now: lengths, starting points, open and sealed periods, and the questions — mixed. 0 / 8

⑧ Sort it

For or since? Sort the time phrases

Twelve time phrases, one question each: could I measure it, or does it name a moment? Tap a phrase and it goes into its box. 0 / 12

for — a length of time

since — a starting point

Start with three years . Could you count it?

⑨ Fix the mistake

Six sentences to repair

Every one of these is a sentence real B1 learners write. Tap it to see the correction and the reason.

⑩ Watch out

The three traps of for and since

Two of these will follow you all the way to B2. Learn to see them coming.

Trap 1 · since never takes a length

Ella has had her licence since two months.

Ella has had her licence for two months.

Two months is an amount of time, and since cannot hold an amount — it wants the moment the period began. Keep the amount and switch to for , or keep since and give it a real moment: since June.

Trap 2 · the present simple cannot reach back

I live in Westbrook since 2021.

I have lived in Westbrook since 2021.

Live describes only what is true at this moment. Since 2021 opens a period years long, and only have / has + participle can stretch across it. The same repair fixes “I am in this class for two years” → I have been in this class for two years.

Trap 3 · the clause after since stays past simple

We’ve been friends since we have been in Year 4.

We’ve been friends since we were in Year 4.

The little sentence after since names one finished moment, so it stays in the past simple. Only the main clause — the friendship that continues — carries the present perfect. One sentence, two tenses, on purpose.

⑪ Quick test

Eight questions, no help

No hints this time. Run the three questions from section ③ in your head. 0 / 8

Answer all eight to see how you did.

Teacher notes

Sequence (45 min): §1 read together and draw the timeline large, 4 min — the line that touches NOW is the one image the whole lesson hangs on. §2 table plus a quick How-long chain drill around the room (How long have you had your shoes / phone / haircut?), 7 min. §3 walk both worked runs on the board with the class calling the question numbers, 7 min. §4 alone, then pairs compare reasons, 6 min. §5 the two-sentence board pair first, then items, 7 min. §6 read aloud once, then tap in pairs, 4 min. §7 alone, 4 min. §8 as a race, 2 min. §9 in pairs, 3 min. §10 read the traps aloud, 2 min. §11 silent, as the exit ticket, 5 min — plus takeaway: three true My-life sentences, one for, one since, one since + clause.

The board move that works: one long horizontal line, NOW at the right end. Plot the same fact twice: She has lived here for two years as an arrow that touches NOW, and She lived here for two years as a closed segment floating well left of it. Then hold two cards against the open arrow: for is the ruler laid along the line, since is the pin stuck into its left end. Every later error can be answered by pointing at the ruler or the pin.

If a learner is stuck, it is nearly always “since three years”. Take them to a calendar and ask them to put a finger on three years . They cannot — you can only count it, not point at it — so it cannot follow since. Anything a finger can land on (March, 2019, a birthday, the day we moved) takes since; anything you can only count takes for.

The deeper error is the present simple leak — I live here since 2020 — and it will not die from one correction. Drill the repair as a reflex: every time for / since appears with a present simple, the class choruses the have-form. The §6 text works read aloud with learners shouting the tense before each gap.

Cambridge B1 Preliminary: for / since gaps are regulars in Reading Part 5 and the open cloze Part 6; Speaking Part 1 runs on this grammar (How long have you lived / studied / played…?); and examiners flag “since three years” in Writing Part 1 emails every single session.

Comes from: A2-21 (present perfect for life experience, ever / never, been vs gone). Next: B1-2 (just / already / yet), B1-3 (present perfect vs past simple in full — today’s §5 grown into a whole material), then B1-21 (present perfect continuous: How long have you been playing…?) and B2-5.

Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus A1–B2 · topic B1-1

Lesson Plan

  • One tense holds two facts together: it started back then, and it is still true now
  • A timeline from the starting point to NOW: since is the pin, for is the ruler
  • The formula for both patterns, and the rule that the period must reach now

Key Vocabulary

forsinceHow long…?a length of timea starting pointstillagespast participleshort answerunfinished time

Grammar Points

  • have / has + past participle + for + a length: She has worked there for four months
  • have / has + past participle + since + a starting point: since 2021, since breakfast, since March
  • since + a whole clause stays past simple: I’ve known him since we were nine
  • How long have you…? asks about an open period; short answers with have / has: Yes, she has
  • past simple + for seals a finished period: She lived there for two years — and then she left
  • the present simple cannot carry a for / since period: I have been here since May, never I am here since May

हमारी कक्षाओं में शामिल हों!

हम मानते हैं कि सही प्रश्न सही उत्तर लाते हैं। चाहे आपके पास अपनी अंग्रेजी सीखने की यात्रा के बारे में कोई प्रश्न हो, हम हमेशा यहां हैं।

मोबाइल ऐप

Fleydo English School आपकी जेब में

Fleydo के छात्रों और पैरेंट्स के लिए लेसन, होमवर्क, मैसेज और गेम्स। iPhone और Android पर मुफ़्त।

App Store से डाउनलोड करेंइसे Google Play पर पाएं
ऐप के बारे में और जानें
QR कोड जो App Store या Google Play में Fleydo English School ऐप खोलता हैडाउनलोड करने के लिए स्कैन करेंआपके फ़ोन के लिए सही स्टोर खोलता है।fleydo.com/app
FleyPath

आपके बच्चे का व्यक्तिगत रोडमैप — 3, 6 या 12 महीने

🚀शुरुआत
👋Hello
😊Body
🦁Animals
🔢Numbers
🏆आत्मविश्वासी अंग्रेज़ी
गेमिफाइड अंग्रेज़ी अभ्यास

गेम जैसा — बस फ़र्क इतना कि वे सच में सीख रहे हैं