📖 Lesson B2 Grammar📐 Grammar

🔗 Grammar B2-10: Relative clauses: full range

The tenth material of the Fleydo B2 grammar series completes the relative-clause system a learner half-owns after B1. Nothing from the defining and non-defining materials is re-taught; instead the clause is treated as what it becomes at B2 — a control for register and a device for packing two facts into one sentence. The spine is the preposition. A compare-and-verdict pair sets the team I play for against the team for which I play and the man who I spoke to against the man to whom I spoke, then says exactly when the formal version earns its place: writing that will be read rather than heard, fixed phrases such as in which case and the extent to which, and long clauses where a stranded preposition lands miles from its noun. The hard rule that governs everything follows: after a preposition only which and whom survive — never that, never who, and nothing may be dropped. Whom then gets a section of its own, reduced to a swap test — him or her means whom, he or she means who — with the overcorrection the candidate whom applied named as the error it is. The quantifier machine takes two worked runs, because thirty students, most of whom walk to school and two proposals, neither of which was affordable are precisely the structures that lift a B2 essay out of the comma splice. Whose is then freed from people (a company whose products, a building whose roof), when, where and why get their formal in which equivalents, and what is explained as a noun and a clause fused into one word — which is why the thing what can never be written. Clause-sized which returns briefly, now carrying prepositions: in which case, at which point, none of which. A four-question decision list (formal or spoken? preposition involved? amount involved? person or thing, subject or object?) is followed by thirty-six explained multiple-choice items in five sets, a 159-word magazine profile with ten tappable clauses, a twelve-chip sorter of mirror pairs sorted by register alone, six repairs and four traps. Teacher notes carry a 45-minute sequence, the arrow board move, the him-not-whom rescue and Cambridge B2 First relevance.

🎒 Teens (11–16) 🧑‍💼 Adults (17+) 30 min Challenging 12
FREE
Text version of this lesson

Grammar B2-10: Relative clauses: full range

Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus

B2

≈ 30 min

B2-10

① The idea

The team I play for · the team for which I play

You already build relative clauses. You know who , which , that , whose and where ; you know that a defining clause refuses commas and a non-defining one demands them. Nothing on this page cancels any of that. What changes at B2 is that the relative clause stops being only a labelling device and becomes a style control : it decides how formal you sound, and it lets you fold two whole sentences into one elegant one. Three pieces do most of that work — the preposition , whom , and the little machine most of whom / neither of which .

What B1 gave you

the manager who hired me · the report, which nobody read

Choosing the pronoun by what it points at: person, thing, place, owner.

Dropping the object pronoun: the report I wrote .

Commas or no commas — identify, or add.

What B2 adds

the manager by whom I was hired · nine reports, none of which was read

A preposition can move to the front of the clause — and that changes the register, not the meaning.

whom stops being a museum piece and becomes obligatory in one exact place.

An amount word plus of which / of whom joins two facts without a full stop.

everyday: the noun + (who / which / that / —) + clause + preposition

formal: the noun + preposition + which / whom + clause

after a preposition: only which / whom — that · who · nothing

Both lines are correct English. Neither is better in general — one is better in a report, the other in a conversation, and a B2 writer picks on purpose. The rest of this material is about picking on purpose.

② Preposition + relative

The same clause, two registers

Almost every relative clause you write has a preposition somewhere inside it: you work with a colleague, you move into a flat, you get figures from a report. English lets that preposition sit in two places, and the choice is the single clearest register signal in the whole system.

preposition at the end — the everyday one

the team I play for

the man who I spoke to

The preposition stays where the verb left it, at the end of the clause. The pronoun is free to be who , that , or nothing at all — the man I spoke to is the most natural of the three. This is the default of speech, of email, of fiction, and of most journalism. It is not careless; it is standard.

preposition at the front — the formal one

the team for which I play

the man to whom I spoke

The preposition jumps to the front of the clause and drags the pronoun with it. Once it does, the pronoun is locked: a thing takes which , a person takes whom , and nothing may be dropped. The sentence sounds measured and written — which is precisely its value in a report, a contract or an application.

Verdict: the fronted preposition earns its place in three situations. ① Formal writing that will be read rather than heard — a report, a proposal, an academic paragraph, a letter of application. ② Fixed phrases that only exist in this shape: in which case , at which point , the extent to which , as a result of which . ③ Long clauses, where a preposition marooned at the end lands miles from the noun it belongs to: the policy for which the committee eventually voted reads better than the policy the committee eventually voted for . Outside those three, choose the end preposition and sound like a human being.

The hard rule, and it has no exceptions. A preposition may only be followed by which or whom . That can never come after one — the team for that I play — because that is not a full pronoun and refuses to travel. Who cannot either — the man to who I spoke . And nothing may vanish: the colleague with I share an office is not a shorter version of anything. If you want that , or you want to drop the pronoun, the preposition must go back to the end of the clause, where both are welcome.

Everyday (end) Formal (front) What changed

the flat we moved into the flat into which we moved nothing but the register

the colleague I share an office with the colleague with whom I share an office the dropped pronoun had to come back as whom

the report that I got the figures from the report from which I got the figures that had to become which

the funding may be cut, and then we stop the funding may be cut, in which case we stop a fixed phrase; only the front version exists

③ Whom, demystified

One word, one job, one place it is compulsory

Whom frightens people because it looks archaic and gets used wrongly by writers trying to sound careful. It is much simpler than its reputation. Who is the subject form and whom is the object form — the same difference as he and him . That is the whole of it.

Position Example Status

subject of the clause (it does the verb) the candidate who applied twice who only — whom here is simply an error

object of the verb (the verb happens to it) the candidate whom we interviewed correct and formal; who , that or nothing are all fine too

straight after a preposition the colleague with whom I share an office whom is compulsory — no alternative exists

after an amount word forty staff, most of whom commute whom is compulsory; it follows of

the swap test: … him / her / them … → whom

… he / she / they … → who

Run the test on the clause, not on the sentence. Take the candidate ___ we interviewed on Tuesday . Turn the clause back into a sentence: we interviewed her — her , so whom . Now take the candidate ___ applied twice : she applied twice — she , so who . Writing the candidate whom applied twice is the classic overcorrection, and it is worse than never using whom at all.

Where whom is optional, it is still a choice. The candidate whom we interviewed , the candidate who we interviewed , the candidate that we interviewed and the candidate we interviewed all mean the same thing and are all correct. The last is what you will say out loud; the first is what a formal report will print. Use whom in object position when the sentence around it is already formal — dropped into casual speech it sounds stiff rather than educated.

④ Practice 1

Prepositions and whom

Eight items on sections ② and ③. Before you answer, find the preposition, and ask whether it is sitting in front of the pronoun or at the end of the clause. 0 / 8

⑤ Quantifier + of which / of whom

The elegant-sentence machine

This is the structure that most reliably lifts a B2 paragraph out of the B1 band, and it costs one comma. You have a group — students, options, emails, buildings — and something is true of part of it. Instead of a second sentence, the amount word walks into a relative clause on the arm of of which or of whom .

a group , + most / many / some / several / none / neither / both / all / half / two + of whom (people) / of which (things) + verb

Two sentences

There were thirty students. Most of them walk to school.

Perfectly correct, and perfectly flat. Two facts, two sentences, no relationship shown between them.

One sentence

There were thirty students, most of whom walk to school.

them becomes whom and the full stop becomes a comma. The second fact is now visibly a fact about the thirty.

Sentences

The council received two proposals. Neither of them was affordable.

Step 1

Find the group and the amount word. The group is two proposals ; the amount word is neither . The second sentence is not new information — it is a comment on the group.

Step 2

Proposals are things, so the pronoun is which . Replace the full stop with a comma and of them with of which . The clause is non-defining — it adds, it does not identify — so the comma is compulsory.

Step 3

The verb agrees with the amount word, not with the group: neither is singular, so was stays singular.

Result

The council received two proposals, neither of which was affordable. Ten words instead of eleven, and one idea instead of two.

Sentences

Ingrid Selkirk interviewed forty-one residents. She rehoused most of them within a mile.

Step 1

Residents are people, so the pronoun will be whom — and it must be whom , never who , because it comes straight after the preposition of .

Step 2

Careful: here the amount phrase is the object of the clause, not its subject. She rehoused most of them — so the clause keeps its own subject she , and the whole phrase most of whom moves to the front: most of whom she rehoused .

Result

Ingrid Selkirk interviewed forty-one residents, most of whom she rehoused within a mile. The amount phrase always goes first in the clause, whatever job it does inside it.

The error this structure exists to prevent. There were thirty students, most of them walk to school. A comma cannot hold two verbs together on its own; them is a plain pronoun and starts nothing. Turning them into of whom is what licenses the comma. Either fix it that way, or use a full stop — but not a comma and them .

Six items on the machine. Watch the amount word, the verb after it, and whether the group is people or things. 0 / 6

⑥ whose, when / where / why, and what

The rest of the kit, tidied up

Three loose ends from B1, each of which turns out to be worth more than it looked.

whose is not only for people

Learners meet whose as the word for a person’s belongings — the boy whose phone rang — and then avoid it for objects, which is a waste. whose works for companies, countries, books, buildings, machines, anything at all: a company whose products are made locally , a novel whose ending nobody understands , a city whose airport keeps closing . The formal alternative the products of which are made locally exists, but it is heavy, and outside legal or academic prose whose is simply the better sentence.

when, where and why

Word Everyday Formal equivalent Note

when the year when we moved · the year we moved the year in which we moved after a time noun, when may simply be dropped

where the lab where she works the lab in which she works where already contains the in — never add a second one

why the reason why nobody applied · the reason nobody applied the reason for which nobody applied why follows only the noun reason

what means “the thing that” — and never follows a noun

what is not a relative pronoun at all; it is a noun and a relative clause fused into one word. What I need is time = the thing that I need is time . That fusion is exactly why it can never sit after a noun: the noun is already inside it.

What the report failed to mention was the cost.

the thing what I need · everything what she said → the thing that I need · everything she said

Why the thing what is wrong. What already carries its own noun inside it, so the thing what I need says the thing the thing that I need — the noun twice. After a noun, use that , or drop the pronoun entirely. Front position is where what belongs, and there it is a genuine B2 tool: putting What I keep saying is… at the start of a sentence pushes the important part to the end, where a reader remembers it.

Six items on whose , the time-and-place words, and what . 0 / 6

⑦ which for a whole clause

Revisited — because at B2 it takes a preposition too

You met this at B1: after a comma, which can point back not at a noun but at everything that came before it. The line closed for six weeks, which cost the district a hundred jobs. Nothing there has changed. What is new is that this which now joins the two structures you have just learned, and the results are the most useful linking phrases in formal English.

Phrase Example What it does

which + verb The survey took two years, which nobody had budgeted for. comments on the whole event before the comma

which is why The data arrived late, which is why the report slipped. marks the event as the cause

in which case The funding may be cut, in which case we stop in March. a fronted preposition — the only shape this phrase has

at which point He resigned in June, at which point the project stalled. fixes the moment; formal narrative and reports

all / none of which She made four promises, none of which she kept. the amount machine, pointing at a list

Two things this which is not. It is never what : The train was cancelled, what was annoying. And it is never that — that cannot follow a comma and cannot point at an event. Keep it attached to its sentence, too: starting a new sentence with Which was annoying. is a fragment, fine in a text message to a friend and out of place in anything you are marked on.

⑧ How to choose

Four questions, then eight sentences

Everything on this page collapses into four questions. Ask them in this order and the shape of the clause decides itself.

Formal or spoken? A report, an essay, an application, a proposal — the fronted preposition and whom are available, and in fixed phrases ( in which case , the extent to which ) they are the only option. A conversation, a message, a story — put the preposition at the end and drop the pronoun. Mixing the two registers inside one paragraph is what actually reads badly.

Is a preposition involved? If it has moved to the front, only which and whom may follow it — never that , never who , and never nothing. If it has stayed at the end, everything is allowed again: who , that , or silence.

Is an amount involved? most , several , none , neither , both , half , all , a number — then the shape is of whom for people and of which for things, and the verb agrees with the amount word, not with the group.

Person or thing, subject or object? The swap test settles it: him / her inside the clause means whom , he / she means who . A thing after a preposition is always which , and a possessor of anything at all is whose .

Task

A project report. Two facts: The panel included nine specialists. She had worked with six of them before.

Question 1

A report, so formal shapes are welcome, and joining the facts is better than listing them.

Question 3

An amount is involved — six — and specialists are people, so the phrase is six of whom , and it moves to the front of the clause even though it is the object of had worked with .

Question 2

A second preposition is hiding here: you work with somebody. It can stay at the end ( six of whom she had worked with before ) or go to the front of its own phrase ( with six of whom she had worked before ) — the second is very formal and slightly stiff.

Result

The panel included nine specialists, six of whom she had worked with before. One sentence, one comma, and the relationship between the two facts is now visible.

Eight harder items, all of them in real contexts and mixing every section above. 0 / 8

⑨ In context

Profile: the planner and the freight yard

A magazine profile, the kind of prose that mixes registers on purpose: formal machinery for the facts, everyday shapes for the speech. Ten clauses are tappable — tap one and read why it has the shape it has.

Maren Okoye, whose office overlooks the freight yard , spent nine years on a scheme few people believed in. The scheme, for which she has now won a national award , replaced a six-lane road with a park. The council saw three proposals, none of which it liked , and the one Okoye defended was the cheapest.

She is blunt about the cost. ‘ The residents I did the work for were never in the room,’ she says. Forty-one families moved, most of whom stayed within a mile . The year in which the park opened was also the year the freight line closed, which cost the district a hundred jobs .

Okoye refuses the easy version of the story. ‘ What I keep saying is that a park is not an economy.’ Her new colleague, with whom she now shares an office , is an economist — a decision at which nobody who knows her is surprised .

Tap any coloured clause. Blue = the everyday shape · green = a fronted preposition · orange = the specialists: whose , the amount machine, clause-sized which and what .

⑩ Sort it

Would you say it, or would you write it?

Twelve phrases, six mirror pairs. Every one of them is correct English — that is the point. The only question is which register it belongs to: the shape you would use out loud, or the shape you would print in a report. Tap a chip and it goes to its side. 0 / 12

you would say it

you would write it

Start with the team I play for . Where is the preposition, and did anything have to be kept?

⑪ Fix it, then watch out

Six repairs and four traps

Every sentence below comes out of real upper-intermediate writing. Tap one to see the repair and the reason.

Trap 1 · that can never follow a preposition

This is the scheme for that she won the award.

This is the scheme for which she won the award. / the scheme she won the award for

The commonest error in this whole area, because that feels like the safe all-purpose pronoun. It is not: it cannot travel to the front of a clause with a preposition. Once you front the preposition you must upgrade to which or whom ; if you want to keep that , send the preposition back to the end, where it is welcome.

Trap 2 · nothing may vanish after a preposition

She named the colleague with she shares an office.

She named the colleague she shares an office with.

The dropping trick you learned at B1 works only when the preposition stays at the end. A fronted preposition needs a pronoun immediately after it — there is nothing for it to attach to otherwise — so either restore whom ( with whom she shares an office ) or put with back at the end and let the pronoun disappear again.

Trap 3 · an amount takes of which, not of them

The council saw three proposals, none of them was affordable.

The council saw three proposals, none of which was affordable.

Of them begins nothing; it is a plain phrase, so the comma is left holding two complete sentences together and the sentence breaks in the middle. Of which is what turns the second half into a relative clause and licenses the comma. The alternative repair is a full stop and None of them was affordable.

Trap 4 · what never follows a noun

Everything what the report says about costs is wrong.

Everything the report says about costs is wrong. / What the report says about costs is wrong.

What means the thing that , so it already contains a noun. Put it after everything , the thing or all and you have written the noun twice. After a noun use that or nothing at all; at the front of the sentence, what is the right word and a genuinely useful one.

⑫ Quick test

Eight questions, no hints

Register, preposition, amount — the four questions from section ⑧, run silently. 0 / 8

Answer all eight to see how you did.

Teacher notes

Sequence (45 min): §1 read the two cards and put the two versions of one sentence on the board, 3 min. §2 the compare pair aloud, then the class converts five end-preposition phrases to the front and back again, 7 min. §3 the swap test drilled fast round the room — he or him? — 5 min. §4 alone, then pairs compare reasons, 5 min. §5 both worked runs on the board, then the six items, 8 min. §6 skim the table, drill only what , 4 min. §7 read aloud, 2 min. §8 the three questions on the board, then the eight items, 6 min. §9 read the profile aloud once, then tap in pairs, 3 min. §10 as a race, 2 min. §11 in pairs, 3 min. §12 silent, as the exit ticket, 5 min.

The board move that works: write the team I play for and draw an arrow from for up over the words to the front of the clause. As the arrow lands, write for which I play underneath and cross out the two things the arrow killed on the way: the dropped pronoun and the possibility of that . Learners remember the picture — the preposition drags a pronoun with it, and only which and whom will come. Then run the arrow backwards on the man to whom I spoke and watch whom relax into who , that , or nothing.

Stuck-learner rescue: almost every whom error is an overcorrection, so stop teaching whom and teach him instead. Cover the noun with a finger, turn the clause into its own sentence, and say it with him or he : we interviewed him → whom ; he applied twice → who . Three rounds of that fixes more than any rule. For the amount machine, write the two separate sentences one above the other, circle them , and physically rub it out and write of whom over it while replacing the full stop with a comma — the visible swap is the whole grammar.

Cambridge B2 First: this material sits on top of two exam tasks. Reading and Use of English Part 2 (open cloze) regularly wants a single word after a preposition — the extent to ___ , most of ___ — and only which or whom can be right there. Part 4 (key word transformations) uses whose , of whom and fronted prepositions to test exactly this rewriting skill. In Writing Part 1 (the essay) one clean most of whom or none of which is among the cheapest range marks available, and examiners penalise the comma splice it replaces.

Comes from: B1-15 (defining clauses: the pronoun kit and the drop rule) and B1-31 (non-defining clauses: the comma fence, the ban on that , clause-sized which ) — both assumed throughout and never re-taught here. Next: B2-27 (reduced relative clauses: the specialists working on the scheme , the road replaced by a park — today’s clauses with the pronoun and the verb taken out), and B2-19 for the wider work of building complex written sentences.

Fleydo English School · CEFR Grammar Syllabus A1–B2 · topic B2-10

Lesson Plan

  • What B1 gave you and what B2 adds: the preposition, whom, and the amount machine
  • The two formulas side by side, and the ban on that after a preposition
  • Neither register is better in general — a B2 writer picks on purpose

Key Vocabulary

for whichto whomwith whomin which caseat which pointthe extent to whichmost of whomneither of whichnone of whichwhosewhatregisterfronted prepositionquantifier

Grammar Points

  • Two registers for the same clause: the team I play for (everyday) and the team for which I play (formal)
  • After a preposition only which or whom: the man to whom I spoke — never to who, never for that, never a dropped pronoun
  • whom is the object form: the candidate whom we interviewed, but the candidate who applied twice
  • Quantifier + of which / of whom joins two facts: thirty students, most of whom walk to school; two options, neither of which works
  • whose works for things as well as people: a company whose products are made locally
  • what means the thing that and never follows a noun: What I need is time — never the thing what I need

Ελάτε στις Τάξεις Μας!

Πιστεύουμε ότι οι σωστές ερωτήσεις φέρνουν τις σωστές απαντήσεις. Είτε έχετε μια ερώτηση για τη διαδρομή σας στην εκμάθηση Αγγλικών είτε χρειάζεστε βοήθεια με μια συγκεκριμένη γλωσσική δεξιότητα, είμαστε πάντα εδώ για εσάς.

Εφαρμογή για κινητά

Η Fleydo English School στην τσέπη σας

Μαθήματα, εργασίες, μηνύματα και παιχνίδια για τους μαθητές της Fleydo και τους γονείς τους. Δωρεάν σε iPhone και Android.

Λήψη στο App StoreΑποκτήστε το στο Google Play
Περισσότερα για την εφαρμογή
Κωδικός QR που ανοίγει την εφαρμογή Fleydo English School στο App Store ή στο Google PlayΣαρώστε για λήψηΑνοίγει το κατάλληλο κατάστημα για το κινητό σας.fleydo.com/app
Το FleyPath

Ο προσωπικός οδικός χάρτης του παιδιού σας — 3, 6 ή 12 μήνες

🚀Έναρξη
👋Hello
😊Body
🦁Animals
🔢Numbers
🏆Αγγλικά με Αυτοπεποίθηση
Παιχνιδοποιημένη εξάσκηση Αγγλικών

Σαν παιχνίδι — μόνο που μαθαίνουν πραγματικά